When a head gasket fails, the repair bill can run from about $1,200 to as much as $7,500. Consumer Reports owner data, trade write-ups and a Honda warranty extension point to the same group of models. Here are thirteen cars and SUVs where that repair has cost owners dearly.
Help yourself and the planet: The Cool Down makes it easy to help yourself while helping the planet, with smart, simple changes to save more and waste less in your everyday life.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. BMW X1: A $7,500 Dealer Bill
One owner paid $7,500 at a dealership to fix the head gasket on a 2014 X1, according to Consumer Reports owner data. Failures on the model were reported between 76,000 and 82,000 miles, which is well short of the lifespan many buyers expect from a luxury compact crossover.
That single invoice anchors the headline figure for the list. It also shows how quickly a gasket job on a premium badge can climb once dealership labor and parts are added to the repair order.
2. BMW 3 Series: The Top Offender
Motor1 names the 2006-2007 3 Series as the top head gasket offender in its roundup, with failures possible between 90,000 and 138,000 miles. The ranking draws on the Consumer Reports owner survey that other trade write-ups have since repeated.
The wide mileage window matters for used shoppers. A car that has already passed 90,000 miles may be entering the risk zone, so service records and any coolant loss deserve a close look before purchase.
3. Chevrolet Cruze: Trouble From 62,000 Miles
The compact Chevrolet sedan appears on the list too, and head gasket issues on the Cruze can start as early as 62,000 miles, per the Motor1 summary of the Consumer Reports ranking. That is the earliest onset cited for any model in the package.
An early start means the problem can surface while a car is still near the end of a typical warranty, or just past it. Owners of a Cruze in that range are the ones most likely to face the bill themselves.
4. Buick Lucerne: A Big Sedan, A Big Range
Consumer Reports owner reports show head gaskets on the 2011 Buick Lucerne failing between 101,000 and 162,000 miles, as listed in its head gasket ranking. The spread is among the widest on the list.
A range that long makes the Lucerne a harder car to predict. Some owners get a long stretch of trouble-free driving, while others face a major repair well before the odometer reaches 120,000 miles, so the used price should reflect that uncertainty.
5. Mini Cooper: Cooper And Clubman
The Consumer Reports list puts the 2013 Mini Cooper and Clubman at 76,000 to 89,000 miles for head gasket failure. The two body styles share the entry, so the finding covers both the standard hatchback and the longer wagon-style model.
The window sits in the same neighborhood as the BMW X1, a reminder that several European small cars cluster at similar mileage. Buyers of a used Mini in that age bracket should ask about cooling system history.
6. Buick Encore: Trouble Near 75,000
Head gasket failures on the 2015 Buick Encore cluster around 75,000 miles, according to the Consumer Reports data. Unlike most entries, the listing gives a single approximate figure instead of a broad range.
That tight clustering suggests owners tend to meet the problem at a similar point in the car’s life. For a small crossover that many people use as a commuter, 75,000 miles can arrive within a handful of years.
7. Subaru Impreza: A $1,500 Repair
The 2011 Impreza saw head gaskets fail at 85,000 to 109,000 miles in the Consumer Reports survey, and one owner reported that the fix cost $1,500. It is one of the cheaper repair bills attached to the list.
The price is modest next to the $7,500 BMW X1 invoice, yet it still represents a large share of the value of an older compact. Costs vary by shop, and a dealership quote can differ sharply from an independent estimate.
8. Subaru Forester: The 2.5-Liter Weak Spot
Jalopnik lists the 1999-2010 Forester among the Subaru model years with head gasket problems, noting that the 2.5-liter engines fail at 120,000 to 150,000 miles. Repairs run from $1,200 to $2,500.
Those mileage figures are higher than many on the list, so the Forester often runs for years before the trouble appears. The wide price band reflects differences in shop rates and in what else is replaced during the job, so quotes are worth comparing.
9. Subaru Outback: The Second Wave
Jalopnik places the 2000-2009 Outback in the second wave of Subaru head gasket failures tied to the 2.5-liter engine. The Outback shares the problem with the Legacy and Forester from the same era.
The Outback is a popular used wagon, which makes that history relevant to a large pool of shoppers searching the used market. Anyone considering an example from those years should check whether the head gaskets have already been replaced and by whom.
10. Mazda MX-5 Miata: A Sports Car On The List
A 2000 Mazda MX-5 is the sports car on the Consumer Reports based list reported by Motor1. It sits alongside luxury sedans and family crossovers, which makes it the most unexpected name in the group.
The roadster has a reputation for simplicity, so its appearance is a useful caveat. Even a lightweight, long-lived design can need an expensive gasket repair, and that is worth weighing for anyone shopping among older examples.
11. BMW X5: The 2013 Entry
A 2013 BMW X5 rounds out the Motor1 roundup of models most likely to need a head gasket replacement, alongside a 2008 Infiniti M. The X5 is the larger sibling of the X1 and X3 that also appear in the owner data.
As a high-priced luxury SUV, it carries a repair bill that can rival the X1 figure at the top of the list. Used buyers should factor that risk into the price they are willing to pay for an older example.
12. Honda Accord: A 150,000-Mile Extension
Honda extended head gasket coverage on the Accord to 10 years or 150,000 miles, because the original gaskets are not holding up, according to CarComplaints. The program covers the Civic, Accord and CR-V families plus two Acuras.
Unlike the Consumer Reports entries, this item rests on a manufacturer decision rather than owner complaints alone. Owners should check whether a specific car qualifies, since coverage depends on the model and its build.
13. Honda Civic: Coverage For Coolant Leaks
Honda also extended head gasket coverage on the Civic to 10 years or 150,000 miles, as outlined in the warranty extension notice. Symptoms include coolant leaks, overheating and misfires.
Those warning signs give owners something concrete to watch for, and the extended coverage should reduce out-of-pocket cost for qualifying cars. The broader point is that a manufacturer acknowledged a pattern, which few brands on this list have done so openly.
Help yourself and the planet: Get The Cool Down →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- Two passengers died at an Ohio toll plaza, and the NTSB now wants the cash lanes shut
- Long use of a common prostate pill is tied to a higher chance of glaucoma
- Ford is recalling 223,472 F-150 pickups because the fuel tank can leak or detach
- Hybrids have 15% fewer problems than gas cars, while EVs and plug-in hybrids have about 80% more, Consumer Reports finds
