Skip to main content

Morning Overview

12 rides where a failed engine can cost thousands

When an engine fails, the repair bill can rival the value of the car itself. Owner reports on CarComplaints.com show average engine repair costs climbing into five figures for some models. Here are 12 vehicles where engine trouble has proved costly, along with what owners reported paying on average.

Read next on Morning Overview: Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks

1. Volkswagen Beetle: A Five-Figure Engine Repair

Volkswagen Beetle — Image Credit: Riley from Christchurch, New Zealand - CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Riley from Christchurch, New Zealand – CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, engine failure is the second most-reported problem for the Volkswagen Beetle, logged on the 2013 model, according to the site’s Beetle page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $19,500 at about 69,000 miles.

That figure is an average of what owners reported, not a set price. The 2013 Beetle belongs to the redesigned generation that launched in 2012. An engine failure at that cost can exceed what an older Beetle is worth, so maintenance records are vital.

2. Ford Flex: A Water Pump Inside the Engine

Ford Flex — Image Credit: IFCAR - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: IFCAR – Public domain/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, a water pump leaking coolant internally is the third most-reported problem for the Ford Flex, logged on the 2010 model, according to the Flex page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $10,000 at about 144,000 miles.

On some Ford V6 engines of this era, the water pump sits inside the engine and is driven by the timing chain. When it leaks, coolant can mix with oil and badly damage the engine. Replacing it is a labor-intensive job, which helps explain the high cost.

3. Volkswagen Golf: A Failing Fuel Pump

Volkswagen Golf — Image Credit: OSX - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: OSX – Public domain/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, a high-pressure fuel pump failure is the second most-reported problem for the Volkswagen Golf, logged on the 2010 model, according to the site’s Golf page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $9,500 at about 40,000 miles.

Direct-injection engines rely on a high-pressure fuel pump to deliver fuel at very high pressure. When it fails, the car may stall or lose power. The site rates 2015 as the Golf’s worst model year and engine problems as its worst category.

4. Lincoln MKZ: Coolant Leaks and Overheating

Lincoln MKZ — Image Credit: Ryan Hildebrand - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Ryan Hildebrand – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, a coolant leak leading to engine overheating is the third most-reported problem for the Lincoln MKZ, logged on the 2017 model, according to the MKZ page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $8,400 at about 70,000 miles.

Overheating can warp engine parts and lead to major damage if a driver keeps going. Owners should watch the temperature gauge and any low-coolant warnings closely. The MKZ was Lincoln’s midsize sedan, built on the same platform as the Ford Fusion.

5. Kia Soul: A Knocking Engine

Kia Soul — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, knocking is the second most-reported problem for the Kia Soul, logged on the 2014 model, according to the site’s Soul page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $8,300 at about 101,000 miles.

Engine knock can point to worn bearings or other internal damage. The site rates 2016 as the Soul’s worst model year and engine problems as its worst category. Kia has faced engine-related recalls and lawsuits on several models from this period.

6. Chevrolet Trax: A Small SUV’s Engine Failure

Chevrolet Trax — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, engine failure is the top reported problem for the Chevrolet Trax, logged on the 2016 model, according to the Trax page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $8,200 at about 94,000 miles.

The Trax is one of Chevrolet’s least expensive SUVs, and the site also rates 2016 as its worst model year. Its small turbocharged engine needs regular oil changes. Buyers should ask for maintenance records and listen for unusual engine noises.

7. Ford EcoSport: A Recall Over Oil Pressure

Ford EcoSport — Image Credit: EurovisionNim - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: EurovisionNim – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

Ford recalled 2018-2022 EcoSport crossovers with the 1.0-liter three-cylinder engine because the oil pump drive belt tensioner arm can fracture, cutting oil pressure and possibly seizing the engine, according to Motor1.

Motor1 also reported that NHTSA had opened a probe into nearly a quarter-million EcoSports over alleged engine failures. An engine that seizes while driving can cause a sudden loss of power. Owners should confirm the recall repair has been done at a Ford dealer.

8. Kia Telluride: Oil Use in a Hit SUV

Kia Telluride — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, high oil consumption is the top reported problem for the Kia Telluride, logged on the 2020 model, according to the site’s Telluride page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $7,000 at about 114,000 miles.

The Telluride became one of the most popular three-row SUVs after its 2020 launch. The site also rates 2020 as its worst model year. Owners can check the oil level between changes and keep records in case they need warranty help.

9. Subaru Outback: Burning Oil in a Subaru

Subaru Outback — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, excessive oil consumption is the second most-reported problem for the Subaru Outback, logged on the 2014 model, according to the Outback page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $6,000 at about 34,000 miles.

Oil consumption complaints affected several Subaru models in this era. The site rates 2013 as the Outback’s worst model year. Owners who notice the oil level dropping between changes should report it to a dealer while the vehicle is still under warranty.

10. Honda Insight: A Hybrid That Burns Oil

Honda Insight — Image Credit: Rennett Stowe from USA - CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Rennett Stowe from USA – CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, excessive oil consumption is the third most-reported problem for the Honda Insight, logged on the 2011 model, according to the site’s Insight page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $6,000 at about 87,000 miles.

The Insight was Honda’s affordable hybrid hatchback, built to compete with the Toyota Prius. The site rates 2012 as its worst model year. Even hybrids rely on their gas engines, and low oil can cause serious damage.

11. Hyundai Accent: An Economy Car’s Thirst

Hyundai Accent — Image Credit: Bull-Doser - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: Bull-Doser – Public domain/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, excessive oil consumption is the top reported problem for the Hyundai Accent, logged on the 2016 model, according to the Accent page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $5,200 at about 111,000 miles.

The Accent was one of the least expensive cars sold in America. The site also rates 2016 as its worst model year. For a car with a modest resale value, a repair of that size can be a hard decision for owners.

12. GMC Terrain: A Crossover’s Oil Problem

GMC Terrain — Image Credit: IFCAR - Public domain/Wiki Commons
Image Credit: IFCAR – Public domain/Wiki Commons

On CarComplaints.com, excessive oil consumption is the top reported problem for the GMC Terrain, logged on the 2011 model, according to the site’s Terrain page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $5,100 at about 93,000 miles.

The Terrain’s four-cylinder engine of this era drew widespread oil consumption complaints. The site also rates 2011 as its worst model year. Buyers should check the oil level and look for blue smoke from the exhaust on startup.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.