A failed transmission is one of the most expensive repairs a car owner can face. Owner reports collected by CarComplaints.com show average repair bills running from a few thousand dollars to $26,000. Here are 12 cars whose transmission troubles have hit drivers hard, along with what owners reported paying.
Read next on Morning Overview: The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power
1. Volkswagen Jetta: A $26,000 Average Repair

On CarComplaints.com, the top reported problem for the Volkswagen Jetta is a grinding noise from the transmission on the 2019 model, according to the site’s Jetta page. Owners who reported it listed an average repair cost of $26,000 at an average of about 17,000 miles.
That figure is an average of owner-reported costs, not a quote from a dealer. The site also rates 2019 as the Jetta’s worst model year. Buyers of a 2019 Jetta should listen for unusual noises when shifting and confirm whether any transmission work was covered under warranty.
2. Toyota C-HR: A Small SUV’s Big Bill

On CarComplaints.com, the top reported problem for the Toyota C-HR is transmission failure on the 2018 model, according to the C-HR page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $14,500 at about 121,000 miles on average.
The site rates 2018 as the C-HR’s worst model year and transmission problems as its worst category. The C-HR uses a continuously variable transmission. A failure well past the warranty period can leave owners paying the full cost themselves.
3. Toyota Highlander: A Family SUV’s Failure

On CarComplaints.com, transmission failure is the third most-reported problem for the Toyota Highlander, logged on the 2017 model, according to the site’s Highlander page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $8,600 at about 57,000 miles.
The Highlander is one of Toyota’s most popular family SUVs. The site rates 2003 as its worst model year overall and engine trouble as its worst category. Even reliable brands can produce costly repairs, so service records matter when buying used.
4. Ford Transit Connect: A Work Van’s Weak Spot

On CarComplaints.com, transmission failure is the second most-reported problem for the Ford Transit Connect, logged on the 2019 model, according to the Transit Connect page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $7,500 at about 85,000 miles.
The Transit Connect is a small van popular with tradespeople and delivery businesses. The site rates 2012 as its worst year and transmission as its worst category. For a work van, a breakdown can also mean lost income while it sits in the shop.
5. Honda HR-V: Losing Power Completely

On CarComplaints.com, the third most-reported problem for the Honda HR-V is a complete loss of power with a failed transmission, logged on the 2016 model, according to the site’s HR-V page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $7,400 at about 100,000 miles.
The 2016 was the HR-V’s first model year in the United States, and the site rates it as the worst. A sudden loss of power can be dangerous in traffic. The HR-V uses a continuously variable transmission, which owners should have serviced on schedule.
6. Nissan Murano: Jerking on the Road

On CarComplaints.com, the top reported problem for the Nissan Murano is jerking on the 2015 model, according to the Murano page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $6,500 at about 21,000 miles.
The site rates 2015 as the Murano’s worst model year and transmission problems as its worst category. Nissan’s continuously variable transmissions drew many complaints in this era. A long test drive with stops and starts can reveal jerking or hesitation.
7. Dodge Caliber: A Scratching Noise

On CarComplaints.com, the second most-reported problem for the Dodge Caliber is a loud scratching noise from the transmission on the 2009 model, according to the site’s Caliber page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $6,000 at about 48,000 miles.
The Caliber was Dodge’s compact hatchback, and the site rates 2007 as its worst year. Many are now inexpensive used cars, so a repair of that size can exceed the car’s value. Buyers should listen for any unusual sounds while accelerating.
8. Volkswagen Beetle: An Icon’s Transmission Trouble

On CarComplaints.com, the top reported problem for the Volkswagen Beetle is transmission failure on the 2004 model, according to the Beetle page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $5,500 at about 92,000 miles.
The New Beetle revived a classic design, and the 2004 is the model year the site rates as worst. Older Beetles with automatic transmissions should be inspected carefully. A failed transmission on a car this old can be a deal-breaker for many owners.
9. Mitsubishi Lancer: A Compact Sedan’s Failure

On CarComplaints.com, transmission failure is the third most-reported problem for the Mitsubishi Lancer, logged on the 2016 model, according to the site’s Lancer page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $5,000 at about 63,000 miles.
Many later Lancers used a continuously variable transmission. The site rates 2011 as the Lancer’s worst year overall. Mitsubishi stopped selling the Lancer after 2017, so owners rely on dealers and independent shops for parts and repairs.
10. Subaru BRZ: A Noisy Sports Car

On CarComplaints.com, the top reported problem for the Subaru BRZ is a noisy transmission on the 2013 model, according to the BRZ page. Owners reported an average repair cost of $4,500 at about 30,000 miles.
The BRZ is a lightweight rear-wheel-drive sports car developed with Toyota. The site rates 2013, its first model year, as the worst. Many BRZs are driven hard, so a used buyer should check for signs of abuse and listen for gearbox whine.
11. Ford Fiesta: The PowerShift Problem

A Jalopnik guide to used cars with transmission problems, published in April 2026, lists the 2011-2015 Ford Fiesta, which used the same troubled dual-clutch automatic as the Focus.
Owners of these Fiestas complained of shuddering, hesitation and rough shifts. Ford issued software updates and extended warranty coverage for many owners. Anyone buying a used Fiesta with an automatic should ask whether the clutch pack has been replaced and take a long test drive in traffic.
12. Nissan Sentra: CVT Struggles

A MotorBiscuit list of used cars with transmissions built to break says various Nissan Sentra model years struggled with CVT problems, including surging and early failure.
The Sentra is an affordable compact sedan that sells in large numbers, which means many are on the used market. A continuously variable transmission can be costly to replace once it fails. Regular fluid changes may help, and buyers should ask for service records.
More from Morning Overview
- Neanderthals in Spain carved a wooden object that matches nothing archaeologists have ever found
- The FAA wants $2.39 million from a flight school it says flew a Cessna about 280 times with an unapproved part
- A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned
- Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman