The sticker price is only the start of what a car costs to own. Insurance premiums climb fast for vehicles that are powerful, expensive to repair or popular with thieves. Using 2026 data from CarInsurance.com and Compare.com, here are 10 cars that come with some of the biggest insurance bills.
Read next on Morning Overview: Melting permafrost is setting off a newly identified kind of catastrophic landslide, scientists say
1. BMW M8 Gran Coupe: The Priciest to Insure

The BMW M8 Gran Coupe is the most expensive vehicle to insure in 2026, averaging $6,744 a year, according to CarInsurance.com. It carries a sticker price starting at $140,000 and a 617-horsepower engine.
Insurers look at how much a car costs to replace and repair, and how likely it is to be involved in a costly claim. The M8 Gran Coupe combines a high price, big power and expensive luxury parts. That mix puts it at the top of the list.
2. BMW M5 Touring: A Wagon With a Supercar Engine

The BMW M5 Touring, which starts at $125,300 and makes 717 horsepower, costs $6,708 a year to insure on average, according to CarInsurance.com’s rankings.
The M5 Touring is a high-performance station wagon, a rare body style in the American market. Its hybrid V8 powertrain gives it more horsepower than many sports cars. Repairing advanced electronics and high-end parts after a crash can be very costly, which pushes premiums up. Drivers can sometimes lower costs by raising deductibles or bundling policies.
3. Mercedes-AMG G63: A Luxury Off-Roader

The Mercedes-AMG G63 performance SUV averages $3,127 for six months of coverage in CarInsurance.com’s 2026 rankings.
The G63 is a boxy, hand-built luxury SUV with a powerful twin-turbo V8 and a price tag well into six figures. Its distinctive body panels and AMG parts are expensive to replace. The G-Class has also become a status symbol, which can make it a target for thieves. Its six-month premium works out to more than $6,000 a year, similar to the costliest cars on the list.
4. Porsche 911 Turbo: A Sports Car Icon

Insuring a Porsche 911 Turbo runs about $3,200 for six months, one of the highest rates for any sports car in the 2026 study by CarInsurance.com.
The 911 Turbo is one of the fastest versions of Porsche’s famous sports car, built for very high speeds. Its performance and price both feed into the premium. Owners often pay extra for specialized repairs, since even minor damage can require costly parts and skilled labor. Where the car is kept and how far it is driven can also move the price for each owner.
5. BMW M5: A Powerful Executive Sedan

The BMW M5 sedan ranks third among the most expensive vehicles to insure in 2026, at an average of $6,593 a year for full coverage, according to a Stacker report on the rankings.
The M5 has long been one of the best-known fast luxury sedans. The latest version uses a plug-in hybrid V8 that adds weight, power and complexity. With the M8 Gran Coupe and M5 Touring, it gives BMW three of the top spots on the list, a sign of how costly its performance models are to cover.
6. Audi e-tron GT: An Electric Sports Sedan

The Audi e-tron GT averages $6,413 a year for full coverage, putting the electric sports sedan among the five most expensive vehicles to insure in 2026, according to Stacker.
Electric vehicles can cost more to insure because battery packs and specialized parts are expensive to repair or replace after a crash. The e-tron GT pairs that with strong performance and a luxury price. Its low, sleek body also uses costly materials. Shoppers should get an insurance quote before buying any high-end EV.
7. BMW M4: Top of Another List

The BMW M4 tops Compare.com’s list of the most expensive vehicles to insure, at an average of $319 a month for full coverage.
The M4 is a high-performance coupe aimed at drivers who want speed and sharp handling. Compare.com found that the three priciest cars on its list were all built for performance. Sports cars tend to be driven harder, which insurers price into their premiums. Rates also vary widely by age, location and driving record, so individual quotes can differ a lot from the average.
8. Nissan GT-R: Godzilla’s Premium

The Nissan GT-R averages $318 a month for full coverage, close behind the BMW M4 in Compare.com’s data.
The GT-R earned the nickname Godzilla for its blistering acceleration and racing pedigree. It is a supercar-level machine with an all-wheel-drive system and a twin-turbo V6. High performance and costly repairs combine to keep insurance bills high for owners. Its monthly premium is nearly identical to the M4’s, a gap of just one dollar. Collectors and enthusiasts who keep the car garaged may still find better rates.
9. Toyota GR86: An Affordable Sports Car’s Surprise

The Toyota GR86 sports coupe averages $318 a month for full coverage, among the priciest cars to insure in Compare.com’s quotes.
The GR86 has a far lower sticker price than the other cars on this list, which makes its premium stand out. Insurers often charge more for sports cars that appeal to younger drivers. The GR86 is a small, rear-wheel-drive coupe designed for fun on twisty roads. Young drivers who buy one should shop around carefully for coverage before signing a loan.
10. Tesla Model 3: The Costliest EV to Insure

The Tesla Model 3 averages $300 a month for full coverage, the highest of any EV in Compare.com’s list of the most expensive vehicles to insure.
The Model 3 is one of the best-selling electric cars in America, yet its insurance costs are high. Repairs on Teslas can be expensive and are sometimes limited to approved body shops. Strong acceleration, even in base models, can also factor into premiums. Tesla also sells its own insurance in some states, giving owners another option to compare.
More from Morning Overview
- Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating
- A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die