Crash test scores only tell part of the safety story. Real-world death rates, drawn from actual fatal crashes, show which models their drivers are most likely to die in. Using figures from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety and an iSeeCars analysis of federal crash data, here are 11 cars with troubling records.
Read next on Morning Overview: New FCC rules on how people can stop robocalls and texts take effect Nov. 25
1. Kia Rio: The Highest Driver Death Rate

The Kia Rio had the highest driver death rate in the latest IIHS study of 2023 and equivalent models, at 170 deaths per million registration years. The average across all makes and models was 37.
IIHS found that more than half of the 2023 models with the highest driver death rates were small cars, sports cars or muscle cars. Small cars carry a size and weight disadvantage in crashes with larger vehicles. The Rio is one of the least expensive cars sold in America, which made it a popular entry-level choice.
2. Dodge Charger HEMI: A Muscle Sedan on Both Lists

IIHS found the two-wheel-drive Dodge Charger and Charger HEMI among the models with the highest driver death rates, according to the institute’s report. They also appeared among the models with the highest death rates for drivers of other vehicles.
That double listing means the car’s own drivers and the people they crash into both fared badly. IIHS has pointed to powerful engines and marketing that attracts aggressive drivers as a key issue for muscle cars. The institute says such cars are dangerous mainly because of how they are driven.
3. Chevrolet Camaro: The Camaro’s Double Listing

The Chevrolet Camaro was one of the few models that IIHS found among both the highest driver death rates and the highest death rates for drivers in other vehicles, according to the IIHS report.
The Camaro shares that distinction with the two-wheel-drive Charger and Charger HEMI and the Chevrolet Malibu. Sports and muscle cars with powerful engines have long featured near the top of IIHS death rate tables. The institute links the pattern to how these cars tend to be driven, not only how they are built.
4. Nissan Versa: A Budget Sedan’s Grim Number

The Nissan Versa posted 164 driver deaths per million registered vehicle years in the IIHS figures, second only to the Kia Rio, according to Carscoops’ breakdown of the study.
The Versa is among the most affordable new cars in America and is often bought by younger or first-time drivers. IIHS notes that driver death rates reflect more than crashworthiness, including who drives a model and where. Even so, small size remains a disadvantage in collisions with heavier vehicles.
5. Chrysler 300: The Worst Large Car

The two-wheel-drive Chrysler 300 recorded 132 driver deaths per million registered vehicle years, the worst of any large car in the IIHS table, according to Carscoops.
Large cars usually fare better than small ones in death rate studies because of their size and weight. The 300’s figure stands out for that reason. Like its Dodge cousins, the 300 was offered with powerful V8 engines, and it shared much of its engineering with the Charger.
6. Dodge Challenger: Another Dodge Near the Top

The two-wheel-drive Dodge Challenger recorded 125 driver deaths per million registered vehicle years in the IIHS figures, according to Carscoops’ report on the study.
The Challenger is a classic American muscle car, sold with engines ranging up to supercharged V8s. IIHS has said powerful engines and marketing that attracts aggressive drivers are the issue for sports and muscle cars. The Challenger fits that profile closely, and the two-wheel-drive version is the one that appeared in the table.
7. Hyundai Kona: A Small SUV With a High Rate

The two-wheel-drive Hyundai Kona small SUV recorded 95 driver deaths per million registered vehicle years in the IIHS table, according to Carscoops.
That is well above the all-model average of 37 reported by IIHS. Small SUVs sit higher than small cars but still carry less mass than larger vehicles. The figure shows that riding higher is not by itself a guarantee of better real-world safety. Driver behavior and crash partners also play a role.
8. Hyundai Venue: The Highest Fatal Accident Rate

In the iSeeCars study, the Hyundai Venue had the highest fatal accident rate of any model, 13.9 per billion vehicle miles, or 4.9 times the average. The analysis used federal FARS crash data for model years 2018 to 2022.
The Venue is Hyundai’s smallest SUV in America. iSeeCars measured fatal accidents per mile traveled rather than per registered vehicle, so its method differs from the IIHS approach. Small cars and SUVs ranked prominently in its findings.
9. Chevrolet Corvette: A Sports Car With a Deadly Record

The Chevrolet Corvette’s fatal accident rate was 13.6 per billion vehicle miles, 4.8 times the average, in the iSeeCars analysis of federal fatality data.
The Corvette is one of America’s best-known performance cars, and its high power can tempt drivers into risky speeds. Performance cars ranked prominently in the iSeeCars list. The study counted crashes that resulted in at least one occupant fatality, using data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
10. Porsche 911: A Porsche on the List

The Porsche 911 had a fatal accident rate of 13.2 per billion vehicle miles, 4.6 times the average, according to the iSeeCars study.
The 911 is an iconic sports car with a long racing history and strong performance. Like the Corvette, it ranked among the five deadliest vehicles in the iSeeCars findings. The study measured fatal crashes against miles traveled, so the rate reflects how these cars are actually used on the road.
11. Kia Forte: A Compact Sedan’s Risk

The Kia Forte had a fatal accident rate of 8.1 per billion vehicle miles, 2.9 times the average, according to iSeeCars.
The Forte is an affordable compact sedan, popular with budget-conscious buyers. iSeeCars found small cars had the highest fatal accident rate of any size category. Modern small cars carry advanced safety technology, but they remain at a size and weight disadvantage in crashes with larger vehicles such as pickups and big SUVs.
More from Morning Overview
- Cadillac cut the price of its cheapest EV, which goes up to 317 miles on a charge
- Winter weather advisories cover I-80, I-70 and the Bighorns with up to 15 inches of snow
- Arizona’s governor declared a statewide emergency after Flagstaff logged its wettest Nov. 1 on record
- Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA