Skip to main content

Morning Overview

Physicists finally have evidence of a decay that happens only once in 10 billion

Out of roughly every 10 billion particles of a certain type produced at the Large Hadron Collider, one is expected to break apart in a very particular way: into a muon and its antimatter twin, an antimuon. Physicists have been hunting for that decay for more than 40 years. The LHCb experiment at CERN now says it has evidence that it happens.

Read next on Morning Overview: Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman

The result, presented at a CERN seminar, reaches a statistical significance of 3.2 standard deviations, enough to count as evidence in particle physics but short of the 5 standard deviations needed to claim a discovery. It also agrees with the Standard Model, the theory that describes known particles and forces.

The Bd meson and the muon-antimuon decay

The particle in question is the Bd meson, made of a beauty quark and a down antiquark. Its decay into a muon and antimuon is extremely rare because the Standard Model allows it only through quantum processes that suppress it heavily. A closely related decay of the Bs meson into the same pair occurs about three times per billion decays, and the Bd version is predicted to happen about 30 times less often, which is where the one-in-ten-billion figure comes from, according to CERN’s announcement.

Physicists call such processes “golden channels” in the search for new physics. Because the Standard Model predicts their rates with high accuracy, any hidden particle or force that contributes to the decay would show up as a rate that is too high or too low. So far, LHCb’s measurement matches the prediction.

The LHCb experiment was built for this kind of work. Unlike the giant general-purpose detectors ATLAS and CMS, which surround the collision point on all sides, LHCb is a single-arm detector that looks down one direction of the beam, where particles containing beauty quarks tend to fly. Its tracking systems can pinpoint where a B meson decayed, a few millimeters from where it was created, which helps separate real decays from the background of particles produced directly in the collision.

The muons themselves are relatively easy to spot because they pass through thick layers of material that stop almost everything else. The hard part is proving that a given pair came from a Bd meson, rather than from a Bs meson or from two unrelated particles that happened to emerge together.

3.0 sigma from the upgraded LHCb detector

The new evidence comes largely from the upgraded LHCb detector, which began collecting data in 2024 at five times the rate it managed from 2010 to 2018. Data from 2024 and 2025 alone gave a significance of 3.0 standard deviations. Combined with the experiment’s 2011 to 2018 data, the significance rises to 3.2, ScienceDaily reported from CERN’s release.

“Extreme precision is required to pick the muons out of the overwhelming background,” said Marco Santimaria, who co-led the international team of 19 scientists behind the analysis. The challenge is that collisions at the LHC produce enormous numbers of particles, and muon pairs that only look like they came from a Bd decay vastly outnumber the real thing. Harry Cliff, LHCb’s rare decays convener and analysis co-lead, said that “seeing evidence of this rare decay is incredibly exciting.”

Forty years of searching and a 2015 false start

The history of the search shows how hard the measurement is. In 2015, a joint analysis by LHCb and the CMS experiment, published in Nature, observed the more common Bs decay and reported initial evidence for the Bd decay as well. Later analyses that added data through 2018 did not confirm the Bd signal, and it faded below the evidence threshold. The new result revives it with far more data behind it, measured with a detector that records collisions several times faster than the one used a decade ago.

Three standard deviations means there is roughly a one-in-a-few-hundred chance that background fluctuations alone would produce a signal this strong. That is why physicists treat 3 sigma as evidence worth reporting but not proof; several 3-sigma signals in particle physics have disappeared with more data. Five sigma, the discovery standard, corresponds to odds of about one in 3.5 million.

The High-Luminosity LHC from 2030

More data is coming. The High-Luminosity LHC upgrade is scheduled to begin operating in 2030, and a further LHCb upgrade is planned for the mid-2030s. Together they could increase the experiment’s data rate by about a factor of ten, which should be enough to push the Bd measurement past the discovery threshold and to pin down its rate.

That precision is the real goal. Confirming that the decay exists checks a prediction; measuring its rate to a few percent would test whether any new physics is quietly adding to it. For now, the decay sits where the Standard Model said it would, and the question of whether anything else is hiding in the one-in-ten-billion channel will have to wait for the next decade’s data.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.



More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.