Crash-test ratings from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety do not always match a vehicle’s reputation, and several popular trucks and SUVs landed at the bottom of the scale. The results come from updated front-crash and rear-seat evaluations published in 2023, plus crash-avoidance tests of work pickups released in October 2026. Here are thirteen pickups and SUVs that earned a poor rating in at least one of those evaluations.
Read next on Morning Overview: A dangerous unpatched Windows exploit is now public and can hand attackers full control
1. Jeep Gladiator: Crew Cab Falls Short

In its June 2023 small pickup ratings, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety gave the 2022-23 Jeep Gladiator crew cab an overall poor in the updated moderate overlap front test.
A crew cab is the only body style covered, and only for those model years. None of the five small crew cab pickups the institute tested in that round earned a good rating, so the Gladiator was in company rather than alone.
2. Toyota Tacoma: Poor Overall Under Updated Test

The 2022-23 Toyota Tacoma crew cab earned an overall poor in the updated moderate overlap front test, according to IIHS small pickup findings. The institute says that overall rating is unchanged under its 2024 criteria.
That durability matters for shoppers, because a later change in methodology did not lift the result. The finding applies to the crew cab versions of the 2022-23 model years, one of five small crew cab pickups that failed to earn a good rating.
3. Ford Ranger: Rear Dummy Slid Under the Belt

The Ford Ranger drew a poor rear-passenger rating because the rear dummy slid beneath the lap belt, in IIHS’s own description. Under the institute’s 2024 criteria, the Ranger’s overall rating is poor.
Submarining means the lap belt rides up off the hips and onto the abdomen, which is why it counts heavily against a vehicle. For families that regularly carry passengers in the back seat of a small pickup, this rear-seat result is the number to weigh.
4. Ford F-150: Strong Sides, Weak Back Seat

The 2023 Ford F-150 crew cab got a poor overall rating and a poor rating for rear passengers, while its side protection was good, based on IIHS large pickup ratings. Large pickups did not perform as well in the new moderate overlap evaluation.
The split result is the useful part: the F-150 protects occupants well in a side crash but not in the rear seat of a front crash. Buyers who haul passengers behind the front row should read the rear-seat score rather than the side score.
5. Ram 1500: Rear Passengers Rated Poor

The 2023 Ram 1500 crew cab was rated poor overall and poor for rear passengers in the updated moderate overlap test, as IIHS large pickup results report. Submarining was a problem for all four large pickups tested.
The Ram shares its weakness with the rest of the group rather than standing apart from it. The rating covers the 2023 crew cab, so owners of other model years or cab styles should not assume the same figures apply.
6. Toyota Tundra: Poor, Not Marginal

The 2023 Toyota Tundra rated poor for rear-passenger protection. Under the new methodology, IIHS says, the Tundra’s overall rating is poor instead of marginal, a downgrade driven by the revised test rather than any change to the truck.
The Tundra was the one large pickup in the group where belt forces were not too high, yet the overall score still landed at poor. The change from marginal to poor came from the methodology, not from any change to the truck itself.
7. Ford F-350: Class 3 Work Truck Misses Braking Test

IIHS rated the 2025 Ford F-350 Class 3 pickup poor in vehicle-to-vehicle front crash prevention, a finding in its cargo van and work pickup tests released on October 8, 2026. The institute called the results a wake-up call for commercial vehicle makers.
Among Class 3 pickups, the Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD and GMC Sierra 3500 also scored poor, while the Ram 3500 managed marginal. Fleet buyers choosing heavy-duty work trucks should note that this test measures crash avoidance, a different yardstick from the crashworthiness ratings above.
8. GMC Sierra 3500: Poor in Crash Prevention

The 2025-26 GMC Sierra 3500 Class 3 pickup got poor in vehicle-to-vehicle crash prevention and marginal for pedestrians, according to the crash avoidance report published October 8, 2026. IIHS stresses that front crash prevention is especially important for larger, heavier vans and trucks.
The reasoning is about other road users: a heavy truck poses more danger to them, so automatic braking matters more. Fleet managers specifying a Sierra 3500 should treat these results as a gap the manufacturer still has to close.
9. Jeep Wrangler: No Rear Curtain Airbag

The four-door Jeep Wrangler (2021-23) earned poor overall and poor for rear passengers. As IIHS midsize SUV findings note, the Wrangler lacks a side curtain airbag in the rear, a gap that sets it apart from most rivals in the group.
That missing airbag is a concrete design gap, not a matter of tuning. Anyone regularly carrying adults in the back of a four-door Wrangler should know the rear seat lacks that protection in the 2021-23 model years.
10. Jeep Grand Cherokee: Head Between Window and Airbag

The 2022-23 Jeep Grand Cherokee rated poor overall in the updated test. In IIHS midsize SUV tests, IIHS noted the rear dummy’s head ended up between the window and the airbag.
An airbag that does not sit where a passenger’s head lands cannot do its job, which explains the rating. The finding covers the 2022-23 model years, and it appears in the same group as four other midsize SUVs flagged for rear-seat risk.
11. Honda Pilot: High Injury Risk in the Back

The 2022 Honda Pilot got poor overall and poor for rear passengers, with a high risk of head or neck injury to the rear dummy, as IIHS rear-seat findings document. The Pilot was one of five SUVs flagged for that risk.
The others named were the CX-9, Grand Cherokee, Murano and Palisade. For a three-row family vehicle whose back rows often carry children and teenagers, the rear-passenger score is arguably the most relevant number on the sheet.
12. Hyundai Palisade: High Belt Tension

The 2022-23 Hyundai Palisade earned poor overall in the updated moderate overlap test, and IIHS reported that rear seat belt tension was high. High belt tension raises the force transmitted to a passenger’s chest in a crash.
The CX-9, Grand Cherokee and Pilot shared that belt-tension finding. As a three-row SUV marketed to families, the Palisade carries a result that prospective buyers of 2022-23 models should weigh against its other strengths.
13. Nissan Murano: Head Close to the Front Seatback

The 2021-23 Nissan Murano rated poor overall. As IIHS midsize SUV ratings record, the head of the rear passenger dummy came close to hitting the front seatback in the Murano.
The Murano was also among the five midsize SUVs where the institute saw a high risk of head or neck injuries to the rear passenger. The rating spans the 2021-23 model years, so owners of those vehicles are the ones directly affected.
More from Morning Overview