Few mechanical problems cost a truck owner as much as a failing automatic transmission. Recalls, technical service bulletins, repair-cost reports and class-action lawsuits have all targeted pickups from the big domestic brands and from Toyota and Nissan. Here are twelve pickup trucks whose gearboxes have earned a reputation for trouble.
Read next on Morning Overview: California’s Long Valley supervolcano is quietly sinking, its biggest drop on record
1. Ford F-150: Lunging Into Gear

SlashGear’s June 2026 roundup lists 10-speed automatic problems on the F-150: harsh shifting, unintended lunging from park to drive, hesitation, clunking and sudden power loss. The transmission has drawn technical service bulletins, and a federal judge let a lawsuit over it proceed.
Owners of 10-speed trucks who notice a clunk or surge when selecting drive have a documented pattern to point to. Raising it with a dealer early, while the truck is still under warranty, keeps the paper trail simple if a bulletin-based repair is needed.
2. Ram 2500 and 3500 HD: Heat Inside the Case

A 68RFE transmission recall covered 84,978 Ram heavy-duty pickups. It cited a possible buildup of pressure and heat inside the transmission, a risky condition for trucks that are often bought specifically to tow and haul heavy loads.
Anyone shopping for a used 2500 or 3500 with this gearbox should confirm through the manufacturer that the recall work was completed. Heavy trailers add thermal load, so fluid condition and service history matter more here than on a lightly used pickup.
3. Toyota Tundra: A 280,663-Truck Recall

The 2022-2024 Tundra’s 10-speed automatic is covered by recall 24V-125 from February 2024, which spanned 280,663 pickups and SUVs. A separate technical service bulletin addresses hesitation and surge, a reminder that a new-generation truck can still carry drivetrain complaints early in its run.
Buyers of a 2022-2024 Tundra should run the VIN for open recalls and ask whether the bulletin procedure was performed. A smooth, decisive launch from a stop is the first thing worth checking on a test drive.
4. Nissan Titan: Parking Pawl Trouble

Nissan’s Jatco nine-speed transmission in the Titan led to a recall for the parking pawl, and the recall expanded to 203,223 vehicles, according to SlashGear. The part is what holds a parked truck in place, so a transmission recall touching it is a safety matter and not just a shifting annoyance.
Titan owners and used buyers should check whether the recall repair is on record. The wide scope of the expansion means many trucks needed the fix, and a seller who cannot show completion deserves extra questions.
5. Ram 1500: Rebuild Money

Gadget Review flagged the 2012-2019 Ram 1500 for hard shifting and slipping, with rebuild or replacement quoted at $4,000-$6,000. The report was published in October 2025, long after the trucks left showrooms, which makes the bill a used-market concern as much as a warranty one.
A figure in that range can erase much of the savings that make an older half-ton attractive. Pricing a transmission rebuild into the offer, or paying for an independent inspection, is cheaper than discovering the slip after purchase.
6. Ford Super Duty F-250: Seven-Thousand-Dollar Shifts

Super Duty trucks from 2017-2019 drew complaints of harsh shifting and delayed engagement, and repair costs often topped $7,000, Gadget Review reported in October 2025. The F-250 is a work truck, so a gearbox failure also means lost working days.
Buyers of these model years should listen for lag when moving from park into gear and ask for service records. Commercial owners may weigh an extended plan against a repair quote that approaches the price of a decent used engine.
7. Toyota Tacoma: Delayed Engagement

Gadget Review reports that thousands of owners of the 2015-2019 Tacoma described delayed transmission engagement, jerking and hesitation, and ties the complaints to transmission control calibration. The pattern appears in a truck better known for durability than for drivetrain drama.
A calibration link suggests software and tuning could matter as much as hardware. Prospective buyers should test the truck cold and in stop-and-go traffic, then ask a dealer whether any updates were applied.
8. Nissan Frontier: Coolant in the Fluid

The 2005 and 2008 Nissan Frontier suffered a radiator defect that let coolant contaminate transmission fluid, Gadget Review reported. The report’s concern was that the damage often occurred suddenly and without warning signs, so a truck could run normally until the gearbox failed.
Owners of these early Frontiers should treat the cooling system as part of the transmission’s health. Checking fluid colour and condition, and replacing an aging radiator, is a modest step against a very costly failure.
9. Chevrolet Silverado 1500: The Harper Lawsuit

The 2015-2019 Silverado 1500 is named in Harper v. General Motors, a case alleging that GM’s 8-speed automatic can shudder and jerk. CarComplaints.com summarised the lawsuit’s allegations, which say the transmission can slip, buck, kick, jerk and harshly engage.
As a January 2022 article on a lawsuit, it records allegations rather than findings. Silverado shoppers can still use the list of symptoms as a test-drive checklist for a truck of that era.
10. GMC Sierra 1500: Sierra Joins the Suit

The GMC Sierra 1500 from 2015-2019 is named in the same GM 8-speed transmission lawsuit, according to CarComplaints.com’s report published in January 2022. It shares the broad truck family with the Silverado, so the shuddering complaints sit in the same drivetrain territory.
The listing means a plaintiff’s attorney considered the Sierra affected, not that a court found a defect. Owners who feel shudder or harsh engagement should document each occurrence and keep dealer paperwork.
11. Chevrolet Colorado: Midsize Shudder

The 2017-2019 Chevrolet Colorado is also on the list in the GM 8-speed lawsuit, which alleges shuddering and hesitation, per the CarComplaints.com article from January 2022. It shows the complaint was not confined to full-size trucks.
Midsize pickups often serve as daily drivers, so stop-and-go behaviour matters. Colorado buyers of these years should test drive in traffic and note any shudder at low speed, then ask whether any updates were performed.
12. GMC Canyon: Colorado’s Twin

The GMC Canyon, built alongside the Colorado, appears as well: the 2017-2019 Canyon is named in the GM 8-speed lawsuit covered by CarComplaints.com’s coverage in January 2022. The overlap follows from the two trucks sharing so much underneath.
Because the Canyon and Colorado are close relatives, a symptom reported on one is worth checking on the other. Shoppers should treat the lawsuit as allegations, not a verdict, and let a drive and service history decide.
More from Morning Overview
- Czech Skyfox jets could become Ukraine’s cheap answer to Shahed attack drones
- A windstorm slammed western Washington, blocking I-5 and knocking out power for thousands
- Tesla’s Cybercab has already crashed 8 times, and the worst one came at highway speed
- Hidden wear was found inside a New Jersey nuclear reactor during its outage