Dependability is easiest to judge once a car has survived a few years of real ownership. The 2026 Vehicle Dependability Study surveyed owners of three-year-old 2023 models, and one model finished at the very top. Here are twelve winners that earned that distinction, from sedans and SUVs to minivans and pickups.
The tech news worth your time: 400,000+ professionals from Google, Apple and OpenAI read Techpresso, a daily email with the most interesting tech news and insights.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Lexus IS: Top Overall Model
The Lexus IS earned the top overall spot in J.D. Power’s 2026 Vehicle Dependability Study, which surveys owners of three-year-old vehicles from the 2023 model year. That finish places the compact sports sedan ahead of every other model in the official J.D. Power study, a result that also makes it the premium compact car winner.
A ranking built on three years of ownership says more about long-term durability than a showroom impression does. For shoppers weighing a used premium sedan, the IS carries the study’s strongest endorsement.
2. Toyota Camry: Midsize Car Champion
The Toyota Camry won the midsize car segment, one of eight model-level awards Toyota collected in the 2026 dependability study. The study’s industry average stood at 204 problems per 100 vehicles, the yardstick against which every segment winner is measured.
Winning a segment in a survey of three-year-old cars points to a sedan that holds up well after the new-car glow fades. The Camry’s award adds to a Toyota sweep that runs through much of this list.
3. Toyota Sienna: Minivan Standout
Toyota’s Sienna took the minivan prize in the J.D. Power’s model-level awards, a model-level award in a year when the industry averaged 204 problems per 100 vehicles. Owners of 2023 models reported on how the van had performed over its first three years.
Family haulers rack up school runs and road trips quickly, so a dependability win carries extra weight in this class. The Sienna gives minivan buyers a data-backed reason to keep it on the shortlist.
4. Toyota Tacoma: Midsize Pickup Pick
The Toyota Tacoma is listed among the model-level award winners and represents the midsize pickup segment. The honor comes from the model-level award winners, which gathered feedback from owners of 2023 model-year vehicles.
Trucks tend to be worked harder than most vehicles, which makes a segment win after three years of ownership a meaningful mark. The Tacoma adds another Toyota name to the winners circle. The study’s industry average of 204 problems per 100 vehicles gives that win useful context for anyone comparing midsize trucks on the used market.
5. Toyota Corolla: Compact Car Benchmark
The Toyota Corolla won the compact car category, and the Autoblog’s report on the study coverage describes it as a durability benchmark in the compact class. The compact segment is often where buyers look first for affordable, long-lasting transportation.
Few nameplates carry the reputation for lasting reliability that the Corolla does. Its win suggests the three-year-old examples in the survey are living up to that standing. Owners of 2023 models in the study were reporting on a car now three years into daily use, which is where a durability claim gets tested.
6. Toyota 4Runner: Rugged Tie at the Top
The Toyota 4Runner tied with the Buick Enclave in the upper midsize SUV segment, according to the Autoblog’s analysis. The coverage credits the result to durability over cutting-edge tech, a trade-off the old-school SUV makes plainly.
Choosing proven hardware over newer features appears to pay off in owner-reported problems. The shared win also shows that a traditional truck-based SUV and a modern crossover can both land at the top. Both vehicles are recognized in the same upper midsize category, so neither can claim sole bragging rights.
7. Cadillac XT6: Cadillac Closes the Gap
The Cadillac XT6 won the premium three-row midsize SUV segment in the Autoblog’s coverage of the winners. The coverage frames the result as Cadillac narrowing the reliability gap, backed by measurable data rather than marketing claims.
A luxury brand winning on dependability helps change a long-running perception about American premium vehicles. For buyers needing three rows and a nicer cabin, the XT6 now has a credential to point to. Cadillac’s brand score of 175 problems per 100 vehicles shows how close the gap has become.
8. Chevrolet Equinox: Quality Control Gains
The Chevrolet Equinox claimed the compact SUV segment in the Autoblog’s report. The coverage points to meaningful quality control gains behind the result, suggesting the improvement came from the factory floor.
Compact SUVs are among the most heavily shopped vehicles, so a segment win carries real influence. The Equinox result shows a mainstream model can rise through steady production improvement. Chevrolet’s brand score of 178 problems per 100 vehicles still sits below the industry’s 204 average, which supports the broader trend.
9. Nissan Murano: Midsize SUV Winner
The Nissan Murano took the midsize SUV segment in the Guide Auto Web’s winners list. It joins a roster dominated by Toyota and General Motors nameplates, giving Nissan a place in the list of segment leaders.
The Murano’s win is a reminder that dependability honors are not limited to the usual suspects. Used-car shoppers comparing midsize crossovers may find the award a useful tiebreaker. The award is based on feedback from owners of three-year-old vehicles rather than on lab testing or short-term impressions.
10. Chevrolet Tahoe: Large SUV Leader
The Chevrolet Tahoe won the large SUV segment, and its brand ranks fifth among mass-market brands at 178 problems per 100 vehicles, according to Guide Auto Web’s list of winners. The full-size SUV topped its class in the survey of three-year-old models.
Large SUVs often serve as tow vehicles and family transport, so dependability is a core purchase concern. The Tahoe’s win gives Chevrolet a second segment award alongside the Equinox. That 178 score sits well below the industry average of 204 problems per 100 vehicles.
11. Buick Enclave: Three-Row Winner
The Buick Enclave won the three-row midsize SUV segment, as listed by Guide Auto Web’s rundown. Buick itself is the No. 2 brand overall in the study at 160 problems per 100 vehicles.
Strong brand-level results suggest the Enclave’s win is not an isolated bright spot. Shoppers wanting a roomy, comfortable family vehicle can see that Buick’s reliability extends across its lineup. The Enclave shares its category win with no other nameplate here, while Buick’s brand score trails only Lexus at 151.
12. Ram 1500: Pickup Segment Winner
The Ram 1500 took the large light-duty pickup award, according to Guide Auto Web’s list. It stands as the full-size truck winner among the models recognized for three-year dependability.
Full-size pickups are expensive, heavily used vehicles, so owners care a great deal about long-term problems. The Ram’s win rounds out a list that spans sedans, SUVs, vans and trucks. The award is specific to large light-duty pickups, so it speaks to the full-size half-ton class rather than to every truck.
The tech news worth your time: Subscribe to Techpresso →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- Ford is recalling 223,472 F-150 pickups because the fuel tank can leak or detach
- Hybrids have 15% fewer problems than gas cars, while EVs and plug-in hybrids have about 80% more, Consumer Reports finds
- Regulators cleared the first U.S. small modular reactor, 4 months early
- Lake Powell sank to a record 3,517 feet, nearing the level that stops Glen Canyon Dam’s turbines
