Small cars attract budget-minded shoppers, yet some model years turned out to be expensive mistakes. The entries below pull from CarComplaints pages and flag the specific years and repairs that owners reported. Here are eleven compact and subcompact models, with the year to watch for each.
Tech news worth reading: Get Techpresso, the daily email with the most interesting tech news and insights, read by 400,000+ professionals from Google, Apple and OpenAI.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Volkswagen Jetta: A $26,000 Transmission
The Jetta has 1,402 complaints, and its number one problem is a grinding transmission on the 2019 model, averaging $26,000 to fix at just 17,000 miles, per the Volkswagen complaint page.
A repair figure that large at such low mileage makes warranty coverage the key question. Anyone considering a 2019 Jetta can verify what coverage remains, review service records, and check recalls by VIN at NHTSA. Dealers can often look up open warranty or campaign coverage by VIN, which costs nothing to ask about.
2. Dodge Dart: Weak Suspension Woes
The Dart’s 2013 model year drew 425 of its 671 complaints, and weak suspension that year averaged $7,000 to fix at only 15,000 miles, as the Dodge Dart page reports.
Nearly two thirds of all Dart complaints land on a single year, which makes 2013 the one to inspect most carefully. Buyers can check suspension condition, request records, and verify recalls by VIN. A mechanic who has seen the model before can quickly spot worn suspension parts.
3. Chevrolet Cruze: Two Bad Years
CarComplaints rates 2017 as the Cruze’s worst year, with a cracked piston averaging $2,700 at 33,000 miles. A 2011 transmission failure on the Chevrolet Cruze page averages $3,300 at 65,000 miles.
Two different years carry two different failures, so Cruze shoppers should match the problem to the model year at hand. Service records, a VIN recall check, and an independent inspection all help. Owner-reported averages guide expectations, though an actual quote for a specific car may differ.
4. Ford Fiesta: Failed Transmission Trouble
The Fiesta has 719 complaints on file. In its worst year, 2011, with 183 complaints, a failed transmission averaged $3,400 at about 67,000 miles, according to the Ford Fiesta listing.
The 2011 model produced about a quarter of all Fiesta complaints. Shoppers considering that year can test-drive for shifting problems, ask for service records, and check recalls by VIN. A seller who can document past transmission service is a better bet than one who cannot.
5. Chevrolet Cobalt: Steering and Gearbox Woes
The Cobalt’s worst year, 2005, drew 400 complaints, with power steering failure averaging $1,000. A 2008 transmission grinding problem averages $2,600, according to the Chevrolet Cobalt page, which lists 1,088 complaints overall.
Older Cobalts warrant a close look at steering feel and transmission behaviour on a test drive. Buyers can also request service records and run a VIN recall check before agreeing to a price. Owner-reported averages are only a guide, so a quote from a trusted shop is worth getting.
6. Honda Civic: Honda’s Top Complaint
CarComplaints names the 2001 Civic’s transmission failure its number one Honda problem, averaging $2,300 at 105,000 miles, according to the Honda complaint page. The Civic has 6,985 complaints overall.
The failure arrives at high mileage, so a 2001 Civic with a long history deserves questions about whether the transmission has been serviced or replaced. Records and an independent inspection are the best protection. Owner reports guide the questions worth asking, rather than predicting any single car’s future.
7. Toyota Corolla: Oil-Burning Engine
The Corolla has 1,568 complaints, and 2002 is rated worst for engines that use excessive oil, a repair averaging $2,500 at 99,000 miles, per the Toyota Corolla page.
A buyer looking at a 2002 Corolla can ask for oil-change records, check the oil level during a test drive, and have a mechanic look for signs of consumption. Checking recall status by VIN is a quick extra. Averages come from owner reports, so treat the figure as a rough guide to what a repair might involve.
8. Ford Focus: Shudder in the Gearbox
The Focus has 5,279 complaints, and transmission problems are its worst category, according to the Ford Focus complaint page. A 2015 shudder averages $1,400 to fix.
Shoppers considering a 2015 Focus can test-drive carefully for shuddering under light acceleration, ask for service records, and check recalls by VIN. An independent inspection before purchase is worth the modest cost. Owner-reported figures are a guide, so a local quote gives a firmer picture of cost.
9. Mazda Mazda3: Clutch Failure Trouble
The failed clutch on the 2010 Mazda3 is Mazda’s top complaint, averaging $1,200 at 39,000 miles, the Mazda brand page shows. The Mazda3 has 645 complaints.
Failure at 39,000 miles is early for a clutch. Anyone looking at a 2010 Mazda3 can test the clutch engagement on a drive, ask whether it has already been replaced, and request service records. Owner-reported averages are a rough guide, and an independent quote will give a firmer number.
10. Chevrolet Cavalier: Fuel Pump Trouble
The Cavalier has 1,170 complaints, with 2005 its worst year, and a 2003 fuel pump failure averages $700 at 71,000 miles, per the Chevrolet Cavalier page.
The fuel pump repair is a smaller bill than many others in this gallery, but it can leave a car stranded. Buyers of an older Cavalier can ask about past fuel system repairs, review records, and check recalls by VIN. Averages come from owner reports and can vary by shop, so a local quote helps.
11. Chevrolet Aveo: Timing Belt Failure
A 2004 Aveo timing belt failure ranks among Chevrolet’s worst problems on the Chevrolet brand page, averaging $2,200 at 73,000 miles.
Timing belts are a scheduled replacement item, so a buyer of an older Aveo should ask for proof that the belt has been changed and when. Without that paperwork, budgeting for the work or walking away are both reasonable choices. Owner-reported costs are averages, and quotes for a specific car can run higher or lower.
Tech news worth reading: Get Techpresso →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- A Chevy dealer wants $696,445 for a Corvette ZR1X after adding a $400,000 markup
- Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power
- Neanderthals in Spain carved a wooden object that matches nothing archaeologists have ever found
