Midsize sedans are often sold as sensible, low-drama transportation, yet owner complaint databases show that certain model years stand out for expensive failures. The entries below pair each car with the problem that drives its worst ratings on CarComplaints. Here are twelve sedans where a particular year deserves extra caution.
Tech news in one quick read: Get the most interesting stories in startups, tech and programming, each with a short TLDR, in one daily email from TLDR.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Nissan Altima: The Standout Model Year
CarComplaints’ Altima page shows the Altima with 5,369 complaints, the most of any Nissan. It rates 2013 worst with 974, led by CVT shudder costing $3,100 at 56,000 miles.
A 2013 Altima shopper should ask about transmission service and test-drive for shudder. Other model years may be less problematic. Complaint totals reflect how many owners reported problems and are not a failure rate, so they work best as a starting point for research. Checking the VIN at NHTSA for recalls is another easy step.
2. Toyota Camry: Oil Consumption Woes
The Camry has 3,617 complaints, the most of any Toyota, and CarComplaints’ Camry listings rates 2008 worst. Oil consumption fixes there averaged $2,700 at about 107,000 miles.
Buyers considering a 2008 Camry should check oil levels and ask whether any consumption repairs were done. Complaint counts are not failure rates, but a pattern at a specific mileage is useful for planning. A maintenance history and an independent inspection round out the due diligence.
3. Honda Accord: Transmission Trouble Early
CarComplaints holds 12,906 Accord complaints, the most of any Honda, and the CarComplaints Honda page names the 2003 Accord’s transmission failure, averaging $2,700 at 98,000 miles, its #2 worst problem.
A used 2003 Accord should get a transmission-focused inspection, and shift quality on a test drive is worth noting. Older cars like this can still be worthwhile if the price reflects the risk. Checking recalls by VIN at NHTSA and reading owner reports for the exact year are sensible habits.
4. Chevrolet Malibu: A Rough Model Year
Owners filed 4,703 Malibu complaints, according to CarComplaints’ Malibu data. Its worst year, 2010, is led by a transmission that stopped working at an average $3,200.
A 2010 Malibu with a murky service history is a gamble. Asking for records and a pre-purchase inspection is practical. Complaint databases track owner reports rather than every vehicle sold, so the numbers indicate a pattern more than a probability. An independent inspection is worth the cost before buying.
5. Hyundai Sonata: Seized Engines Reported
The Sonata has 2,543 complaints, the most of any Hyundai, per CarComplaints’ Hyundai page. Its No. 1 problem is a seized 2011 engine averaging $5,100 at 96,000 miles.
Engine trouble is the costliest category here, so a 2011 Sonata deserves a records check, and recall status can be verified by VIN at NHTSA. Other model years in this family may fare differently, so the advice here is about one year rather than the whole nameplate. Verify the year before judging a listing.
6. Kia Optima: Engine Failure Costs
Owners logged 787 Optima complaints, per CarComplaints’ Kia page, and 2011 Optima engine failure averages $4,600 to fix at 103,000 miles.
That is a smaller complaint pool than some rivals, but the repair bill is large. Ask about engine maintenance and recall work on any 2011 model. Since the figures come from owner reports, the pattern is a guide rather than a guarantee. A pre-purchase inspection and complete maintenance records help show how a given car was treated.
7. Ford Fusion: Steering Fails Early
The Fusion has 2,347 complaints, and CarComplaints’ Fusion page rates 2011 worst, led by power steering failure averaging $1,500.
Power steering problems are noticeable on a test drive as heavy or erratic effort, so shoppers can check for that and for any recall repairs. Not every owner will see this problem, but it is worth knowing before buying. Repair records and a short drive on rough pavement and in parking lots can reveal a lot about condition.
8. Chevrolet Impala: Rough Shifting Reported
The Impala has 4,812 complaints, the most of any Chevrolet, per CarComplaints’ Impala listings. The 2005 model is rated worst with 394, led by rough shifting averaging $1,800.
A 2005 Impala should be driven through all gears, with attention to harsh or delayed shifts, before a buyer commits. Other model years of the nameplate are not rated worst, so the caution applies to this year in particular. Reviewing service records is a straightforward way to judge any individual car.
9. Dodge Charger: Premature Engine Failure
The Charger has 932 complaints, and CarComplaints’ Charger page shows the 2006 model with the most, 190. Premature engine failure averages $5,500 at about 94,000 miles.
With a repair bill that large, a 2006 Charger merits a thorough inspection and a request for maintenance records. Performance-oriented sedans can be driven hard, so a maintenance history is especially valuable. A compression test or a mechanic’s inspection may be money well spent.
10. Chrysler 200: Slipping at 39,000 Miles
The 200 has 1,273 complaints, and CarComplaints’ Chrysler 200 page shows that 2013 models’ transmission slipping ranks #3 among its worst problems, at $4,000 and 39,000 miles.
The low mileage stands out, so a 2013 200 should be checked for slipping during acceleration and gear changes. A problem showing up that early in mileage suggests some owners faced costly repairs sooner than expected. Asking about any transmission replacement or warranty repair is a smart move.
11. Chrysler Sebring: Oil Sludge Ends Engines
The Sebring has 1,549 complaints, and CarComplaints’ Chrysler listings says its #1 problem is oil sludge ending in engine failure on 2002 models, averaging $4,000 at 94,000 miles.
Sludge points to neglected oil changes, so a 2002 Sebring needs proof of regular service. Regular oil changes are the usual defense against sludge, so a complete service history can be more telling than the odometer. Anyone unsure about the history can have the engine inspected.
12. Ford Taurus: Transmission Failed Early
The Taurus draws 2,656 complaints, and CarComplaints’ Ford page puts transmission failure in the 2003 model at the top, averaging $1,900 at 93,000 miles.
A 2003 Taurus should be test-driven for slipping or delayed engagement, and maintenance records requested. Transmission trouble can appear without much warning, so a test drive that includes reversing, hard acceleration and stops is worthwhile. Fluid condition and service records are also informative. Keeping an eye on fluid color and smell is a simple way to spot early trouble.
Tech news in one quick read: Subscribe to TLDR →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- Winter weather advisories cover I-80, I-70 and the Bighorns with up to 15 inches of snow
- Arizona’s governor declared a statewide emergency after Flagstaff logged its wettest Nov. 1 on record
- A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned
- A Chevy dealer wants $696,445 for a Corvette ZR1X after adding a $400,000 markup
