Luxury badges do not guarantee trouble-free ownership, and certain model years carry repair bills far larger than most owners expect. The entries below draw on CarComplaints brand pages, plus one RepairPal estimate, to flag specific years and failures. Here are twelve premium vehicles where the model year matters a great deal.
AI, explained every day: The Deep View is the go-to daily newsletter for 600,000+ founders, knowledge workers and professionals who want to stay up to date with artificial intelligence.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. BMW 7 Series: Seized Engine Risk
A 2012 BMW 750 with a seized engine ranks third among BMW problems on the CarComplaints BMW page, averaging about $15,000 to fix at 89,000 miles.
A bill of that size makes a thorough pre-purchase inspection from a BMW specialist worth the cost for anyone considering a 2012 750. Requesting full service records and checking recalls by VIN at NHTSA are reasonable additions. Even a clean car history does not remove the need to ask direct questions about engine health.
2. Mercedes-Benz C-Class: Early Engine Failure
A 2016 C300 engine failure is the third-ranked Mercedes-Benz problem on CarComplaints’ Mercedes page, averaging $15,600 at only 48,000 miles. The C300 also has 141 complaints on file for the brand.
Failure at that mileage means even a fairly low-mileage car is not automatically in the clear. Shoppers can check the warranty status, ask for service records, and have an independent mechanic examine a 2016 C300 before buying. Owner reports on CarComplaints are a starting point, not a guarantee of what any single car will do.
3. Infiniti Q60: Engine Malfunction Warning
An engine malfunction on the 2017 Q60 is the second-ranked problem on CarComplaints’ Infiniti listing, with an average repair of $14,200 at 51,000 miles.
The reported mileage falls early in a car’s life, so a 2017 Q60 with modest miles still merits scrutiny. Buyers can request service records, confirm recall status by VIN, and pay for a pre-purchase inspection before committing. A seller who can document oil changes and any engine work is far easier to trust than one who cannot.
4. Infiniti QX60: Two Costly Problems
The QX60 appears twice on the Infiniti problem list. A 2014 model’s transmission shudder tops the ranking at $6,900 and 110,000 miles, while a 2019 QX60 engine sludge problem averages $13,000 at 44,000 miles.
The two years point to different failures, so the specific model year being considered matters. Buyers can ask whether oil-change maintenance was kept up, review service records, and check recalls by VIN. Comparing the two failures against the specific car’s mileage helps decide which risk is more relevant.
5. BMW X3: Chain Guide Trouble
The worst-ranked BMW problem on CarComplaints is a broken timing chain guide on the 2013 X3, averaging about $9,000 to fix at 83,000 miles, as the BMW complaint page shows. The X3 also has 150 complaints on file.
Timing components sit deep in the engine, so shoppers considering a 2013 X3 should ask whether chain work was ever done and request the records. A specialist inspection and a VIN recall check are sensible steps.
6. Audi A4: Oil Use Problem
The A4 has 286 complaints on the Audi brand page, and excessive oil usage on the 2011 model is the site’s top Audi problem, averaging $6,000 at 65,000 miles.
Buyers eyeing a 2011 A4 can ask for records of oil top-ups and engine repairs, watch the oil level during a test drive, and have an independent mechanic check for consumption before agreeing to a deal. Owner-reported averages are only guides, so a quote from a trusted independent shop is worth getting.
7. Mercedes-Benz E-Class: Balance Shaft Failure
A balance shaft failure on the 2006 E350 is Mercedes’ number one problem on CarComplaints, averaging $4,800 at 85,000 miles, according to the Mercedes-Benz complaint listing. The E350 has 165 complaints.
Any 2006 E350 on the market is now a decidedly older car, so history matters. Buyers can ask whether the repair was already performed, obtain service records, and have the engine inspected before paying. Documentation of past repairs counts for a great deal on a car of this age.
8. Audi Q5: Thirsty Engine Problem
The Q5 has 225 complaints on the Audi complaint page, and excessive oil consumption on the 2014 Q5 averages $3,200 at 70,000 miles.
Oil consumption is something a buyer can test for. Ask for oil-change records, check the level at the start and end of a test drive, and get an independent inspection of any 2014 Q5. A recall check by VIN at NHTSA is a quick extra. Averages in owner reports vary, so treat these figures as a rough guide rather than a quote.
9. BMW X5: Most-Complained BMW
The X5 draws the most BMW complaints at 167, and the 2011 and 2013 model years are named among the brand’s worst, based on the BMW brand page.
The page names years rather than a single repair, so research on these model years should cover the full complaint list. Buyers can request records, check VIN recalls with NHTSA, and arrange a specialist inspection. Owner reports of this kind are most useful when matched against a specific car’s history.
10. Cadillac SRX: Water in the Lights
The SRX collects 627 complaints on the Cadillac complaint page, and 2010 water in the lights averaged $1,600 to fix at 80,000 miles.
Moisture in lighting is a visible issue, so inspecting both headlights and taillights for fogging is a sensible check on a 2010 SRX. Buyers can also ask for repair records and check recalls by VIN. Averages come from owner reports, so an actual repair quote may differ somewhat from the figure above.
11. BMW 3 Series: Worst Years for the 3
The 328 has 93 complaints on the BMW complaint listing, and the 2007 328 and 2007 335 are both named among the brand’s worst models.
Naming two trims from one year suggests the year itself deserves caution. Shoppers interested in a 2007 328 or 335 can review that year’s complaint detail, ask about past repairs, and pay for a specialist inspection. Owner-reported rankings guide the questions to ask, not the final decision on any one car.
12. Land Rover Range Rover Sport: Air Suspension Cost
Unlike the entries above, this one is a repair estimate rather than a model-year flag. RepairPal’s compressor estimate puts replacing a Range Rover Sport’s air-suspension compressor at $2,183 to $2,276.
Per the estimate, parts run $1,984 and labor $199 to $291, so most of the cost is the compressor itself. Shoppers can ask whether the suspension has been serviced and check that the vehicle holds its ride height. Estimates vary by region and shop, so a local quote is the better guide to the real cost.
AI, explained every day: Get The Deep View →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned
- A Chevy dealer wants $696,445 for a Corvette ZR1X after adding a $400,000 markup
- Zero Motorcycles unveiled an electric motorcycle targeted at under $8K and a street-legal dirt bike at EICMA
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power
