Cars are expected to last well beyond the loan that pays for them, yet some models earn reputations for failing early. These picks draw on Jalopnik, MotorBiscuit, The Car Guide and GOBankingRates, covering transmission, engine and electrical complaints across compacts, sedans, crossovers and a minivan. Here are eleven cars known for breaking down too soon.
Read next on Morning Overview: Refiners are making less gasoline and more diesel, and here’s why
1. Ford Focus: Shifting Gears Badly

The 2012-2016 Focus fitted with the PowerShift automatic earns its place through a gearbox that can slip, buck, kick and jerk, according to a Jalopnik transmission roundup published by Jalopnik in April 2026. The complaints were widespread enough that they ended in a class action settlement over the transmission.
Shoppers weighing a used compact from those model years should treat the automatic as the risk and test drive it carefully for hesitation or shuddering at low speed. Cars with a manual gearbox sit outside the problem entirely, which makes them the safer way into an otherwise affordable, familiar hatchback or sedan.
2. Ford Fiesta: Same Gearbox, Same Grief

The 2011-2015 Fiesta shares the DPS6 gearbox with the Focus and carries the same drivability problems, as noted in the used-car transmission list from Jalopnik. It is a small, inexpensive hatchback and sedan, which is exactly why so many were sold with the troublesome automatic.
The same caveat applies: the issues do not affect manual versions, so the transmission type matters more than mileage or condition. A buyer eyeing a cheap used Fiesta should confirm which gearbox is fitted before negotiating on price, since the automatic is the version that draws the complaints.
3. Chrysler 200: Crimped Wiring, Lost Power

On the 2015 Chrysler 200, insufficient crimps in a wiring connection could cause the transmission to shift to neutral and cut power while driving, a defect covered in recall 16V529 and described in Jalopnik’s transmission coverage from Jalopnik. Losing drive at speed is a safety issue as much as an inconvenience for any sedan owner.
The fix lies in the recall, so owners of a 2015 car should confirm through the manufacturer that the repair was completed. A used example without documented recall work deserves caution, since the fault strikes without much warning and leaves the driver coasting in neutral.
4. Jeep Cherokee: Neutral at the Worst Moment

The 2014-2015 Jeep Cherokee, the compact crossover built with a nine-speed automatic, can shift into neutral without warning. Jalopnik’s used-car transmission rundown blames a poorly-designed wiring harness, and a recall addressed the wiring.
Sudden neutral on a highway on-ramp or in traffic is the kind of failure that makes this early nine-speed notorious. Buyers of a used 2014 or 2015 Cherokee should verify the wiring recall was performed and pay attention during a test drive to any hesitation, harsh shifts or unexpected loss of drive.
5. Mitsubishi Mirage: A Short Runway for the CVT

The Mitsubishi Mirage is a bargain subcompact whose continuously variable transmission has a reputation for trouble. MotorBiscuit lists it among its cars that struggle past 100,000 miles because CVT issues can surface well before 100,000 miles. Mitsubishi discontinued the car after the 2024 model year.
Low purchase prices and strong fuel economy are the draw, but a high-mileage Mirage on its original CVT is a gamble. A used buyer should look for service records and listen for whining, slipping or shuddering, remembering that a discontinued model may be harder to support in the long run.
6. Kia Optima: Engines That Drink Oil

The Kia Optima appears in MotorBiscuit’s list of short-lived cars for two separate problem windows: 2011-2015 models with engine failures and oil use, and 2016-2020 models with premature transmission failure. Few midsize sedans spread their troubles across so many years.
Shoppers cannot count on one safe generation to dodge both issues. Checking oil consumption history and engine service records matters on the earlier cars, while the later ones call for a careful look at transmission behavior. A well-documented example is worth far more than a cheap one with gaps in its maintenance history.
7. Fiat 500: The Oil System Scare

The Fiat 500’s 1.4L MultiAir engine is the source of its reputation. MotorBiscuit’s report on cars that fall short says the oil system fails in a way that has drivers thinking the engine literally blew up. The retro-styled city car was sold in the United States with this small engine.
Regular oil changes and attention to any warning lights are the practical defenses, and a used 500 deserves a thorough inspection before purchase. The charm of the design is real, but a buyer who skips the check risks discovering the oil system problem on the side of the road.
8. Mini Cooper: Cute, Quirky, Fragile

The Mini Cooper hatchback built from 2001 to 2012 collects a familiar set of complaints. MotorBiscuit’s cars under 100,000 miles roundup cites wiring issues, engine hiccups and gearbox failures, a mix that can turn a fun small car into a regular visitor to the repair shop.
Buyers drawn to the styling and handling of a used Mini should budget for repairs and favor examples with strong service histories. Electrical gremlins and drivetrain trouble make a pre-purchase inspection by a specialist sensible, especially on higher-mileage cars from the early years of the modern Mini.
9. Nissan Altima: The CVT Countdown

The Nissan Altima’s continuously variable transmission tends to experience premature failure, frequently occurring shortly after reaching the 100,000-mile mark, according to a list of cars to avoid buying from GOBankingRates carried by AOL in January 2026. That timing lands right as many owners expect their cars to settle into the long haul.
A replacement transmission is among the costliest repairs a midsize sedan can face, so a used Altima with an unclear service history is a risk. Buyers should ask for fluid change records and test the car for shuddering, whining or delayed response before committing.
10. GMC Acadia: Last Place in Reliability

The GMC Acadia ranked as the least reliable 2026 model in Consumer Reports, with a score of 14. The Car Guide’s top ten least reliable models from December 2025 points to transmission trouble, including leaking transmission fluid and sometimes a full replacement.
A last-place finish in a widely watched survey is a signal worth heeding for anyone shopping a three-row crossover. Prospective owners should check the transmission for leaks and request service records, and compare the Acadia against rivals that scored better before signing any paperwork.
11. Chrysler Pacifica: Plug-In Trouble

The Chrysler Pacifica Hybrid scored 26 in Consumer Reports’ 2026 reliability ranking, and The Car Guide’s least reliable 2026 models list from December 2025 ties the result to EV charging and EV battery problems, including battery cooling issues.
The finding matters because the plug-in system is the selling point of the minivan. Families considering a Pacifica Hybrid should confirm warranty coverage on the battery and charging hardware, and test that the car charges as expected before relying on its electric range for daily errands.
More from Morning Overview
- Tesla’s Cybercab has already crashed 8 times, and the worst one came at highway speed
- Hidden wear was found inside a New Jersey nuclear reactor during its outage
- California’s Long Valley supervolcano is quietly sinking, its biggest drop on record
- Up to 5 feet of snow is burying Donner Pass, and forecasters warn against Sierra travel