A few years ago, buying a used electric vehicle meant paying a steep premium over a comparable gas car. That gap has nearly vanished. By early 2024, the average used EV sold on Carvana cost just $1,300 more than an equivalent internal-combustion model, according to the company’s quarterly SEC filings. At the same time, 44% of used EVs on the platform sold for under $25,000, a threshold that matters because it is the price ceiling for the federal used-EV tax credit.
For shoppers who assumed electric cars were still a luxury-tier purchase, those numbers tell a different story. And the trend has only continued into 2026, as lease returns flood the market and competition among sellers intensifies.
Where the $1,300 gap comes from
Carvana, the largest online-only used car retailer in the U.S., disclosed the pricing shift in its Q1 2024 Form 10-Q and shareholder letter filed with the SEC. The company broke out average selling prices by powertrain type, showing that the premium buyers paid for a used EV over a gas equivalent had compressed dramatically from the thousands-of-dollars gap that existed in 2022 and early 2023.
Because Carvana moves hundreds of thousands of vehicles annually and operates nationwide, its data serves as a meaningful barometer, though not a complete picture. Traditional franchise dealerships, independent lots, and private sales may reflect different pricing. Cox Automotive’s market insights reports have tracked a similar downward trend in used-EV premiums across the broader market, reinforcing that the compression is not unique to one platform.
The models driving this shift are familiar names. Used Chevrolet Bolts, Nissan Leafs, and Tesla Model 3s have become some of the most commonly listed used EVs, with many Bolts and Leafs now priced well below $20,000. Hyundai Ioniq 5s and Kia EV6s from 2022 and 2023 model years have also started appearing in volume as early leases expire.
Why the $25,000 mark matters so much
Under Section 25E of the Internal Revenue Code, created by the Inflation Reduction Act, buyers of qualifying used EVs can claim a federal tax credit of up to $4,000. But the vehicle’s sale price must be $25,000 or less. The car must also be at least two model years old, purchased from a licensed dealer who reports the transaction, and the buyer’s modified adjusted gross income must fall below $75,000 for single filers or $150,000 for joint filers. The IRS used clean vehicle credit page lays out the full requirements.
When 44% of used EVs already clear that price ceiling before any credit is applied, the math gets compelling. A $23,000 used EV purchased by an eligible buyer through a qualifying dealer could effectively cost $19,000 after the credit. That puts it in the same territory as a well-equipped used Honda Civic or Toyota Corolla, but with significantly lower fuel and maintenance costs over time.
As of mid-2026, the credit remains in effect, though its future is not guaranteed. Budget negotiations and shifting political priorities could alter or eliminate it. Buyers planning around the credit should confirm eligibility at the point of sale rather than assuming rules will remain unchanged.
Lease returns are reshaping supply
The pricing compression did not happen in a vacuum. A large wave of mass-market EV leases signed in 2021 and 2022 began expiring in 2024, and that cycle has continued into 2025 and 2026. When a lease ends and the lessee does not buy the vehicle, it returns to the market as used inventory. The result has been a sustained increase in the number of used EVs available for sale.
This supply surge has outpaced demand growth for new EVs in some segments, putting downward pressure on used prices. Bloomberg has reported on the boom in used-EV sales driven by this lease-return cycle, noting that inventory turnover has actually accelerated at lower price points. Cars are not sitting unsold; they are moving quickly, which suggests genuine buyer demand rather than a market flooded with unwanted vehicles.
Tesla’s decision to cut new-vehicle prices multiple times in 2023 and 2024 also rippled through the used market, pulling down resale values for Model 3s and Model Ys. That was painful for existing owners watching their cars depreciate, but it has been a windfall for used-car shoppers.
The battery question buyers should not ignore
A used EV priced at $22,000 looks attractive on a sticker, but the battery pack is the most expensive component in the vehicle, and its condition is not always obvious. Replacement packs for popular models range widely in cost: a Nissan Leaf battery replacement might run $5,000 to $8,000, while a Tesla Model 3 pack can exceed $12,000 to $15,000, according to repair industry estimates compiled by Recurrent Auto.
Most EV manufacturers offer battery warranties of eight years or 100,000 miles, whichever comes first, as required by federal emissions regulations. But a used EV that is five or six years old may have limited warranty coverage remaining. Buyers should check whether the original battery warranty transfers to subsequent owners (it typically does) and how much coverage is left.
Tools for assessing battery health have improved. Recurrent Auto provides free battery health reports for many popular EV models, using telematics data to estimate remaining range capacity. Some buyers also use OBD-II diagnostic tools to pull battery state-of-health readings before purchase. These steps do not eliminate risk, but they narrow the information gap that made early used-EV purchases feel like a gamble.
What the data does and does not tell us
The strongest evidence behind this story rests on two primary sources: Carvana’s SEC filings, which carry the legal weight of public-company disclosure obligations, and the IRS’s published credit rules, which reflect binding tax law. Within their stated scope, both are reliable.
What they do not cover is equally important. No publicly available dataset aggregates every used-EV transaction in the country with enough granularity to confirm the $1,300 gap holds across all sales channels. Automakers do not publicly disclose how many vehicles are cycling back through off-lease channels. And no federal agency publishes independent battery health assessments tied to specific model years.
That means the most consequential question for any individual buyer remains partly unanswered: is a sub-$25,000 used EV a good long-term deal, or just a cheap upfront purchase with hidden costs? The pricing data is solid. The total ownership picture depends on the specific car, its battery condition, and whether the federal credit applies.
What to do before signing
For anyone actively shopping, a few steps can prevent expensive surprises. First, verify that the specific vehicle qualifies for the federal used-EV tax credit before committing. The sale must go through a dealer who reports the transaction to the IRS, and the vehicle must meet age and price requirements. The IRS used clean vehicle credit page is the most reliable place to confirm current rules.
Second, request or pull a battery health report. Recurrent Auto’s free reports cover many models, and dealerships increasingly provide state-of-health data as a selling point. Third, check the remaining manufacturer battery warranty and confirm it transfers to you as a second or third owner.
Used EVs are no longer a niche curiosity priced out of reach for mainstream buyers. At $1,300 above gas-car equivalents, and with nearly half priced below the federal credit threshold, the economics have shifted faster than most shoppers realize. The deals are real. The due diligence still matters.
More from Morning Overview
*This article was researched with the help of AI, with human editors creating the final content.
