Skip to main content

Morning Overview

SpaceX finally caught a Starship back from space, the ship NASA needs for its Moon landing

Ship 42 settled between the two arms of the launch tower at Starbase, Texas, at about 3:20 p.m. Central on Saturday, Nov. 14, after a flight of roughly 22.5 hours and 14 laps of Earth. No Starship upper stage had ever returned from orbit and been plucked out of the air by the tower, and this one arrived intact enough that the first outside reports described the vehicle as looking undamaged.

Read next on Morning Overview: Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman

The double catch SpaceX had hoped for did not materialize. Booster 22 abandoned its approach to the tower and was destroyed over the Gulf of Mexico, so recovering both stages from a single flight is still undone. The ship is the harder half of the system and the part that matters most to the space agency, which is paying SpaceX to develop a Starship that can land Artemis astronauts on the Moon.

Ship 42’s 14 orbits and the catch on the tower

Flight 15 lifted off from Pad 2 at Starbase on Friday, Nov. 13, at 22:47 UTC, two minutes behind plan, according to a recap on SpaceInfo Club. Ship 42 reached orbit about 26 minutes into the flight at roughly 275 kilometers and began releasing 26 Starlink V3 satellites around the 35-minute mark, finishing by one hour 17 minutes. SpaceX skipped its early ocean-return options and flew the full mission instead.

The deorbit burn came on Saturday, Nov. 14, at about 20:23 UTC and lasted roughly 10 seconds, which SpaceX described as nominal. The catch followed near 21:20 UTC, and SpaceX posted “Mechazilla catches Starship!” a minute later. SpaceX said the ship and its heat shield looked healthy, and three of the Starlink satellites carried cameras that imaged the shield.

KPBS, carrying the Associated Press account, reported that SpaceX officials said Saturday’s catch demonstrates the full reusability of Starship, the vehicle intended for travel to the Moon and Mars. It was SpaceX’s 15th flight of a full-scale Starship since 2023 and only its second trip to orbit.

Preparation for the attempt was visible months ahead. Ship 42 and Booster 22 were both Block 3 vehicles, the fourth such pair to fly, and the mission summary notes the ship completed cryogenic testing and ran chopstick and quick-disconnect catch tests at Pad 2 on Sept. 11 and 12, while the booster ran a static fire on Oct. 25. The ship had also been designed to loiter for about 21 hours before its deorbit burn, which gave controllers a long window to confirm the vehicle was healthy before committing to the return.

Booster 22 and the abort over the Gulf

The booster’s story ended about 6.5 minutes after liftoff. SpaceInfo Club reports that one of the 33 Raptor engines dropped out after stage separation, so the boostback burn ran on 32, and early indications pointed to a low fuel mass alarm that cut the burn short. The landing burn began with 13 engines lit, but the booster judged that it was out of position for a catch and aborted.

Dan Huot, a SpaceX spokesperson, said on the webcast that the catch was called off automatically after a guidance, navigation and control issue, according to the live coverage on drohnen.de. The booster flew to an offshore site in the Gulf, where its flight termination system fired before it reached the water. Elon Musk wrote on X that the booster was “slightly low on fuel,” which he attributed to engines slightly underperforming.

The North Atlanta Star’s account notes that the explanation shifted from a possible guidance problem to a low-fuel alarm and an early-ending return burn, and that engineers were still investigating why the return sequence fell short. SpaceX recovery teams were on site after the splashdown collecting debris that washed ashore. No root cause has been named.

NASA’s lander requirement and the steps still missing

NASA is paying for Starship to land Artemis astronauts on the Moon, as the AP report on the catch states. The agency’s formal arrangement with SpaceX goes back to a 2021 award, and in November 2022 NASA announced a second option of about $1.15 billion to develop a Starship lunar lander that can serve missions beyond the first landing, as its contract announcement describes. Lisa Watson-Morgan, who managed the Human Landing System program at Marshall Space Flight Center, said at that time that the work supports sustainable, service-based landers tied to NASA’s requirements.

A tower catch does not by itself put anyone on the lunar surface. Coverage of Flight 15 notes that lunar missions will require further demonstrations, including transferring propellant between spacecraft in orbit, and that no new landing date came out of the flight. SpaceInfo Club adds that the heat shield’s inspection load per flight is still unknown and that no date has been given for Flight 16.

Pre-launch planning documents show how much was riding on Nov. 13. Per the Flight 15 mission summary, SpaceX had announced on Oct. 21 that a simultaneous booster and ship catch would be attempted, and Musk had put the odds of a first-try success at at least 50 or 60 percent in September. SpacePolicyOnline’s coverage of the catch frames the same milestone for policy readers, and the remaining open item is the one the booster just failed: both stages, same flight, same tower.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.