Skip to main content

Morning Overview

A Science study at COP31 finds Earth’s ice, snow and permafrost beyond a safe limit

Glacier-fed rivers in the Canadian prairies, ice roads in the Arctic, coastal towns that depend on the ice sheets staying put: all of them sit downstream of one assumption, that Earth’s frozen places can still be kept inside a range the climate can tolerate. A team of more than 30 scientists says that assumption has already failed.

Read next on Morning Overview: Ocean mud suggests Cascadia and the San Andreas fault have broken within hours of each other

Their paper in the journal Science, released on Nov. 12, 2026 during the COP31 climate summit, concludes that the cryosphere, meaning Earth’s ice, snow and permafrost, has moved beyond its safe operating space. The study was led from the Stockholm Resilience Centre at Stockholm University.

Four frozen components, one verdict

The paper is titled “The Cryosphere Beyond a Planetary Safe Operating Space.” According to the EurekAlert release, its team came from the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Tsinghua University, Beijing Normal University, the Earth Commission, the International Association of Cryospheric Sciences, the WCRP Climate and Cryosphere Project, the Third Pole Environment Programme and the WWF Arctic Programme.

The study examines land ice, sea ice, snow cover and permafrost, and finds that all four have passed safe levels. Lead author Bo Su, who works at the Stockholm Resilience Centre and Beijing Normal University, said, “The cryosphere has already exceeded its planetary safe operating space,” and described the result as a threat to the frozen foundations of the planet.

The release does not publish numerical thresholds for the four components in its text. A status dashboard graphic accompanies the paper, but its values are not reproduced in the press material.

A boundary drawn from 11,700 years of stable climate

The “safe operating space” is a set of precautionary boundaries for frozen areas, and the reference point is the Holocene, the past 11,700 years, a period of relatively stable global climate. The Stockholm Resilience Centre’s account says current changes, including those already committed by past emissions, push the cryosphere further from those conditions.

That commitment matters for the verdict. Stockholm University’s news article, which describes the findings as presented on Nov. 13 at the summit, says the degradation risks a self-reinforcing cycle that makes reversal harder. Ice, snow and permafrost take part in the planet’s energy, water, carbon and methane cycles, so losing them feeds back into the same warming that drives the loss.

The authors name the main driver as human-caused climate change from greenhouse gas emissions, along with regional pressures such as black carbon emissions and the expansion of industry and infrastructure.

Risks the authors flag for polar, mountain and coastal regions

The Stockholm Resilience Centre lists faster global warming, sea level rise, ecosystem degradation, and more catastrophic floods and droughts among the consequences, with polar, high-mountain, coastal and low-lying regions facing the greatest threat. The release does not put a number on how many people live in those regions.

Johan Rockström, director of the Potsdam Institute and co-chair of the Earth Commission, said, per Stockholm University, that cryosphere risks are already unfolding, most recently with floods and landslides in Nepal, and called the report’s arrival at COP31 an important reminder of the significance of cryosphere governance.

John Pomeroy, a University of Saskatchewan professor who chairs the strategic management committee of the UN Decade of Action for Cryospheric Sciences, ties the finding to Canadian stakes. Pomeroy also holds the UNESCO Chair in Mountain Water Sustainability. A University of Saskatchewan article links cryosphere change to freshwater security, glacier-fed river systems, prairie water supplies and Arctic and northern communities. He called the paper a “timely, integrated update on the state of cryosphere decline” and said it reinforces the need for coordinated international action on preserving frozen regions beyond COP31 as well. The study, in his words as released, “issues a clear warning on the emergency of cryosphere collapse that global policymakers must heed at COP31.”

Requests aimed at climate negotiators

The recommendations are specific in kind if not in number. Policymakers should use the safe operating space as a scientific basis for precautionary targets and strategies, limit greenhouse gas and black carbon emissions, and reduce local human disturbances such as industrial and infrastructure expansion, according to the Climate and Cryosphere Project’s summary.

The team also proposes that the cryosphere be considered for addition to the planetary boundaries framework, the set of limits that has so far been used to describe the safe operating space for Earth as a whole. The paper is framed as a scientific basis for action during the UN Decade of Action for Cryospheric Sciences, which runs from 2025 to 2034.

COP31 itself ran from Nov. 9 to 20 in Antalya, Türkiye, so the paper reached delegates in the middle of the negotiations. Whether any text that comes out of the summit adopts the cryosphere boundary is not something the study’s release materials address, and the authors’ own request, to consider adding the cryosphere to the planetary boundaries framework, remains a proposal.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.


More from Morning Overview

Morning Overview is reader-supported. Some links in our articles are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.