A transmission failure is among the costliest surprises a family SUV can deliver, and a few models have collected a paper trail to prove it. The evidence here ranges from owner surveys to lawsuits, federal recalls and an extended warranty. Here are twelve SUVs whose gearboxes earned the worst reputations.
Save more, waste less: The Cool Down’s newsletter sends smart, simple changes that help you and the planet in your everyday life.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Nissan Pathfinder: Nissan’s CVT Problem
Owners surveyed by Consumer Reports reported transmission replacements on the 2014 Pathfinder between 58,000 and 108,000 miles, and the Consumer Reports transmission list says Nissan’s CVTs dominated the findings.
A wide mileage window means some failures came early and others later, but all arrived well before the typical end of a vehicle’s life. Shoppers considering a used Pathfinder should look for service records and any extended coverage that might remain. Survey data reflects owner experience and cannot predict any single vehicle, but the pattern is hard to ignore.
2. Nissan Murano: A Very Costly Bill
Murano owners told Consumer Reports that transmission replacement was needed at 84,000 to 119,000 miles, and the same owner survey notes that one paid $5,000 for the work.
One bill is an anecdote, not an average, yet it gives a sense of the exposure when a modern automatic fails outside warranty. The Murano shares its continuously variable design with other Nissan products on this list. Checking for fluid service records and any available extended coverage is sensible before buying one.
3. Infiniti QX60: Luxury Badge, Same Gearbox Worry
Infiniti’s QX60 from 2014 sits in Consumer Reports’ repair findings, where owners reported transmission replacement at 92,000 to 95,000 miles, a narrow window that points to a consistent weakness.
A premium badge does not guarantee a premium gearbox, and the QX60 is a reminder that corporate siblings often share the same trouble. Buyers should weigh the cost of a replacement against the price of a used luxury crossover. Ask the seller whether the unit has been replaced already, as a newer gearbox changes the risk picture.
4. Chevrolet Traverse: A General Motors Outlier
Not every entry is a CVT, and the CR survey table shows 2013 Traverse owners reporting transmission replacement at 110,000 to 135,500 miles, a later failure point than the Nissan group.
That higher range is less alarming but still significant on a family hauler that many owners expect to keep for a decade. The Traverse earns its place as a reminder that conventional automatics have problems too. Shoppers can use that gap as a negotiating point or as a reason to compare alternatives from other brands.
5. Nissan Rogue: Complaints by the Thousand
The Nissan Rogue has 1,390 complaints on file, according to the CarComplaints Rogue page, with a loss-of-acceleration repair averaging $3,200 at 76,000 miles, and the 2013 model drew the most at 209.
The Rogue sells in large numbers, so complaint totals are partly a function of volume. Even so, a pattern in model year concentration suggests owners of 2013 examples should be especially careful about checking maintenance records. Cross-checking a specific vehicle identification number against recall databases takes only moments and is free.
6. Nissan Juke: Worst Year Brings a Big Fix
Among compact crossovers, the Juke has the clearest verdict, because a CarComplaints Juke rating calls the 2013 model worst, with transmission failure averaging $4,000 to repair at 59,000 miles.
That mileage is low enough that many owners may still have been within a warranty or extended coverage period. The Juke is also a niche model, which can make parts and specialist help harder to find outside big cities. Owners of other model years should not assume they are safe, but should also not assume they are affected.
7. Hyundai Tucson (2016-2017): Dual-Clutch Doubts
Hyundai’s 2016-2017 Tucson is named in a class action described by a CarComplaints lawsuit report, which claims the dual-clutch transmission control modules can cause the SUVs to stop moving.
The claim concerns the control module rather than the mechanical gearbox, and the lawsuit does not settle whether the allegations are true. Owners who notice hesitation or sudden loss of drive should report it to a dealer promptly. Buyers should ask for documentation of any dealer visits for hesitation or lost drive, because that history reveals how the unit has behaved.
8. GMC Yukon: Valve That Can Lock the Rears
GM’s full-size SUVs get a federal spotlight, since an NHTSA recall record shows 43,743 2022 Yukon, Tahoe, Suburban and Escalade models were recalled in February 2026 because a transmission control valve can fail and lock the rear wheels.
Locked rear wheels at speed are a clear safety hazard, which is why regulators treat this as a recall instead of a customer-satisfaction matter. Owners should confirm repair status on the vehicle identification number. Free repairs are the key benefit, so any owner whose SUV has not been checked should schedule the work soon.
9. Jeep Cherokee: Neutral at the Wrong Time
The 2014 Jeep Cherokee’s nine-speed automatic drew two NHTSA recalls, numbered 16V529 and 19V447, and the NHTSA vehicle recall listing describes software that may shift the transmission to neutral unexpectedly.
Two campaigns over several years imply that the first remedy did not close the matter. The nine-speed was an early example of a complicated gearbox, and its record helped fuel skepticism about adding gears for their own sake. Anyone considering a used Cherokee should confirm both campaigns were completed, since a skipped update leaves the original risk in place.
10. Subaru Forester: Coverage Doubled for Foresters
Subaru acknowledged CVT concerns when it doubled coverage for 2016-17 Foresters from 5 years or 60,000 miles to 10 years or 100,000 miles, according to a federal service bulletin dated September 2018.
An extended warranty is not a recall, but it tells shoppers the company expected enough claims to justify the cost. For used buyers, checking that the extended coverage still applies can be worth a lot of money. Used buyers should confirm that the extension is documented and transferable, since terms can differ by owner and market.
11. Honda Pilot: Pilot’s Nine-Speed Software
Honda’s 2016-2022 Pilot is named in a 2024 class action, and a CarComplaints lawsuit story says the ZF nine-speed’s software causes rough, delayed shifting and loss of power, according to the plaintiffs.
These are allegations and Honda has not been found at fault. Software fixes can change how a transmission behaves, so owners who notice rough shifts should ask a dealer about updates before assuming hardware has failed. Owners dealing with such symptoms should keep a written log of dates and incidents, which helps both warranty claims and any later legal action.
12. Chevrolet TrailBlazer: An Old GM Standby Fails
The 2002 TrailBlazer rounds out the list because CarComplaints’ TrailBlazer page rates it worst, led by 4L60E transmission failure averaging $2,200 to fix at 100,000 miles.
This is the most modest repair bill in the group and the oldest model, which reflects both a different era and a much simpler SUV. It still shows that the problem of gearbox reputations stretches back decades before the CVT arrived. Age matters here, so any survivor on the market deserves a careful inspection and a skeptical look at its maintenance history.
Save more, waste less: Subscribe to The Cool Down →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- NOAA now gives this winter a 75% chance of the strongest El Nino since 1950
- Doctors warn a silent liver disease now affects one in three American adults
- The FBI told the rest of ShinyHunters to surrender after a 24-year-old was arrested
- Two passengers died at an Ohio toll plaza, and the NTSB now wants the cash lanes shut
