Conventional automatic gearboxes have a reputation for lasting, yet owner complaint records show plenty of exceptions among family favorites. Sedans, crossovers and minivans from several brands appear with failed transmissions that cost thousands to repair. Here are twelve models where the reported bills and mileage give used-car shoppers something concrete to weigh.
Help yourself and the planet: The Cool Down makes it easy to help yourself while helping the planet, with smart, simple changes to save more and waste less in your everyday life.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Honda Accord: Accord Gearbox Trouble
The Honda Accord has 12,906 complaints on CarComplaints Accord records, and its worst model year, 2003, is led by transmission failure. Owners reported an average repair bill of $2,700 at 98,000 miles.
Such a large complaint pool makes the Accord a useful benchmark. Shoppers eyeing an early-2000s example can ask for proof of transmission servicing and listen for slipping or harsh shifts on a test drive. Checking recall status by VIN at NHTSA costs nothing and takes a minute.
2. Honda Civic: Civic Transmission Failure
The Civic has 6,985 complaints, and its worst model year, 2001, is led by transmission failure averaging $2,300 at 105,000 miles, according to owner reports on CarComplaints.
Mileage here runs past the 100,000 mark, which suggests that many failures arrive late in a car’s life. A well-documented service history still counts for a lot on a car this old. Comparing the asking price with a possible repair bill of that size is a sensible exercise.
3. Honda Pilot: Pilot At 123,000 Miles
The Honda Pilot has 1,735 complaints, and its 2003 model year is rated worst for transmission failure averaging $3,400 at 123,000 miles. The figures appear in CarComplaints Pilot data.
That is the highest mileage in this group, so a first-generation Pilot is not an obvious early-failure case under these figures. Fluid change records are still worth asking about. Prospective buyers can also confirm recall status by VIN at NHTSA before committing.
4. Honda Odyssey: Odyssey Tops Its List
The 2002 Honda Odyssey is rated worst, with transmission failure averaging $3,400 at 98,000 miles, among 2,964 complaints logged on CarComplaints Odyssey listings.
Minivans tend to carry heavy loads and see plenty of stop-and-go use. Anyone shopping for an older Odyssey can check how the transmission shifts when cold and ask whether it has ever been repaired. Those figures describe reported averages, not a promise about any single minivan on a used lot.
5. Chrysler Pacifica: Costly And Early
The Chrysler Pacifica has 926 complaints, and transmission slipping and jerking in its 2018 model year, the worst, averaged $9,000 to fix at 36,000 miles. That is the biggest bill in this group, per CarComplaints Pacifica data.
Only 36,000 miles means the problem can surface while a warranty may still apply. Owners of a 2018 Pacifica who notice jerking or slipping can document it and raise it with a dealer promptly. Owner-reported figures vary, but a bill near that level is the scale to keep in mind.
6. Ford Explorer: Explorer Gives Out
The Ford Explorer has 13,452 complaints, and a 2002 transmission failure averaged $2,800 to fix at 94,000 miles, according to CarComplaints Explorer entries. The site rates 2006 as the worst model year overall.
The transmission entry and the worst-rated year are not the same model year. A 2002 Explorer should be judged by its own record, with a test drive that includes both gentle and firm acceleration. Complaint data reflects what owners chose to report, so it is a guide rather than a verdict.
7. GMC Terrain: Terrain Transmission Bill
The GMC Terrain has 692 complaints, and a 2010 transmission failure averaged $3,600 to fix at 86,000 miles, as listed in CarComplaints Terrain reports. The worst model year overall is 2011.
Because the cited failure belongs to 2010 while 2011 carries the worst rating, shoppers should look at both years. Service records and a careful test drive can reveal hesitation or flaring between gears. Checking recall status by VIN at NHTSA is a quick extra step before buying.
8. Nissan Maxima: Maxima Not Shifting Right
The Nissan Maxima has 1,427 complaints; 2004 is rated worst, and a 2005 transmission that was not working correctly averaged $3,000 at 97,000 miles, based on CarComplaints Maxima ratings.
Two adjacent model years appear in the data, so a Maxima from either year warrants attention. A mechanic can check fluid condition and scan for stored codes before a purchase is finalized. Written estimates from an independent transmission shop can help put a figure on the risk.
9. Acura TL: Acura TL At 114,000 Miles
The Acura TL has 414 complaints, and a 2003 transmission failure averaged $2,800 to fix at 114,000 miles, per CarComplaints TL data. The site’s worst model year overall is 2010.
High mileage before failure is a mark in the car’s favor, though the repair bill remains substantial. Checking that the 2003 car has had regular fluid service is a reasonable precaution. Complaint counts show what owners reported, not how many cars were sold.
10. Buick Enclave: Enclave Transmission Failure
The Buick Enclave has 665 complaints, and its worst model year, 2008, is led by transmission failure averaging $3,600 at 92,000 miles. Details are on CarComplaints Enclave pages.
A large three-row crossover puts extra strain on its drivetrain when loaded with passengers. Buyers of a 2008 Enclave can test it under load and ask whether any transmission work has been done. Negotiating with the likely repair cost in mind is a reasonable approach.
11. Chevrolet Venture: Venture Van Fails
The Chevrolet Venture has 402 complaints; a 2000 transmission failure averaged $2,100 at 87,000 miles, according to CarComplaints Venture records. The site lists 2003 as the worst model year overall.
Older minivans can be tempting because of low asking prices, yet a transmission failure can dwarf the savings. A thorough test drive and a mechanic’s look are worth the effort. A pre-purchase inspection by an independent mechanic costs far less than a rebuild.
12. Ford Taurus: Taurus Tops The Complaints
The Ford Taurus has 2,656 complaints, and its top-ranked problem is transmission failure in the 2003 model, averaging $1,900 at 93,000 miles. The figures come from CarComplaints Ford listings.
This is the lowest repair bill in the group, though it still represents a significant outlay on an aging sedan. Prospective buyers can ask for service records and check for delayed engagement when shifting into drive. Asking when the fluid was last changed is a simple question that can reveal a lot.
Help yourself and the planet: Get The Cool Down →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating
- A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die
- Melting permafrost is setting off a newly identified kind of catastrophic landslide, scientists say
