Owner-reported data shows that expensive engine trouble does not always wait for high mileage. Seized motors, oil-hungry designs, cracked heads and sludge have all been logged on popular cars and SUVs well short of the six-figure mark. Here are twelve models where the reported repair bills and odometer readings tell a cautionary story.
The day in tech, in one email: TLDR is the daily newsletter with links and TLDRs of the most interesting stories in startups, tech and programming.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Jaguar XF: Seized Engine, Steep Bill
The Jaguar XF has 24 complaints on CarComplaints for the XF, and its 2014 model year is rated worst for an engine that seized. Owners reported an average repair cost of $25,000 at 49,000 miles, the largest figure in this group.
A bill of that size can exceed what an older luxury sedan is worth. Anyone considering a 2014 XF should ask for complete service records and weigh a specialist inspection before buying.
2. Porsche Macan: Cracked Head Near The Plugs
Among 22 complaints on file, a 2018 Porsche Macan problem listed as a cracked head near the spark plugs averaged $7,500 to fix at 62,000 miles, according to CarComplaints owner reports. The site rates 2015 as the worst model year overall.
The two dates point to different issues in different years, so shoppers should not assume that skipping 2015 avoids trouble. A pre-purchase inspection that looks at the engine is sensible on any Macan.
3. Audi A6: Thirsty For Oil
The Audi A6 has 121 complaints, and a 2013 excessive oil consumption problem averaged $6,200 to fix at 87,000 miles, as shown on CarComplaints Audi A6 data. The site rates the 2000 model year worst overall, so the oil issue is a separate entry.
Owners of a 2013 A6 can keep a log of how much oil is added between changes, which gives a dealer something concrete to review. Falling oil level between services is the symptom worth tracking, and it is easy to check at home.
4. Chevrolet Suburban: Burning Oil In A Big SUV
The Chevrolet Suburban has 1,270 complaints on file, and its 2009 model year is rated worst for excessive oil consumption. The average fix cost $5,000 at about 55,000 miles, according to owner complaints on CarComplaints.
Fifty-five thousand miles is early for a full-size truck-based SUV. Buyers of a 2009 Suburban can check the dipstick on a cold engine and ask the seller how often oil has been topped off. Records of any engine work are worth requesting too.
5. Chevrolet Equinox: Oil Consumption Hits Early
The Chevrolet Equinox has 2,843 complaints on file, with 2013 rated worst for excessive oil consumption. Owners reported an average repair cost of $3,100 at 76,000 miles, per CarComplaints Equinox listings.
That repair figure is the lowest in this group, yet still a sizable expense on a compact crossover. Checking oil level regularly is cheap insurance for anyone who already owns a 2013 Equinox. A noticeable drop on the dipstick between changes is worth raising with a mechanic early.
6. GMC Terrain: Oil Use At 93,000 Miles
The 2011 GMC Terrain is rated its worst year among 692 complaints, with excessive oil consumption averaging $5,100 to fix at 93,000 miles. The numbers come from CarComplaints Terrain reports.
This one falls just inside the sub-100,000-mile window, so a Terrain near that odometer reading is worth a careful look. Maintenance records showing consistent oil changes are a good sign, though not a guarantee. Because the reported mileage sits so close to 100,000, any Terrain approaching that figure is worth inspecting.
7. Chevrolet Traverse: Engine Failure In A Family Hauler
The Chevrolet Traverse has 762 complaints on file, and its 2011 model year is rated worst for engine failure. The average repair cost was $5,200 at about 88,000 miles, based on CarComplaints Traverse data.
Three-row crossovers often rack up miles on school runs and road trips, so mileage on a used 2011 Traverse can climb quickly. A compression or leak-down check by a mechanic is a reasonable step before purchase.
8. Chrysler 300: Sludge Takes The Motor
The Chrysler 300 has 643 complaints on file, and 2006 is rated worst. Engine failure due to oil sludge that year averaged $6,000 to fix at 85,000 miles, as listed in CarComplaints 300 records.
Sludge usually points to neglected oil changes, so service history carries extra weight on a 2006 example. A seller who cannot show records leaves the buyer guessing about how the engine was treated. Oil condition under the filler cap can also offer a hint.
9. Hyundai Sonata: Seized Near 96,000 Miles
The Hyundai Sonata has 2,543 complaints on file, with 2011 rated worst for an engine that seized. Owners reported an average repair cost of $5,100 at 96,000 miles, according to CarComplaints Sonata ratings.
With 96,000 miles on the clock, this failure arrives just before the six-figure mark that many buyers treat as safe. Used 2011 Sonatas deserve a close look at records and a thorough test drive. Listening for unusual noises on a cold start is a simple habit.
10. Jeep Cherokee: Shutdown At 17,000 Miles
The Jeep Cherokee has 2,200 complaints, and a 2019 engine shutdown tops Jeep’s list at an average $6,000 and 17,000 miles, based on CarComplaints Jeep listings. That is the earliest mileage of any entry in this group.
A shutdown at low mileage can land within a warranty period, so owners of a 2019 Cherokee may want to ask a dealer what coverage still applies. Keeping repair paperwork helps if the problem recurs. Ordering a warranty check by VIN is a simple first step.
11. Ford Flex: Early Failure In A Wagon-Style Crossover
The Ford Flex has 326 complaints, and engine failure in its 2010 model year averaged $5,000 to fix at 62,000 miles, per CarComplaints Flex complaints. The data comes from owner submissions, not a controlled study. A single complaint count cannot say how many Flex owners were affected overall.
Shoppers eyeing a Flex for its boxy practicality can ask for a full service history and a mechanic’s inspection. Owner-reported averages describe what some drivers paid, not what every example will face.
12. Chevrolet Tahoe: Oil Burning In A Tahoe
The Chevrolet Tahoe has 1,329 complaints; 2015 is rated worst with 231, and excessive oil consumption in a 2009 Tahoe averaged $5,500 to fix at about 96,000 miles. Details appear in CarComplaints Tahoe records.
The worst-rated year and the oil-burning year differ here, so a 2009 Tahoe should be judged on its own record. Asking about oil top-offs and reviewing service paperwork is a practical first step. A complaint count of 1,329 across all years suggests owners have plenty of experience to compare.
The day in tech, in one email: Get TLDR →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks
- 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
- Two Kentucky residents died when a small plane crashed at Missouri’s Lake of the Ozarks, and the NTSB is investigating
- A handful of car transmissions are so tough that mechanics say they almost never die
