Transmission failures can turn an inexpensive used car into a four-figure headache, and the owner data shows it happening early. These small and midsize models span automatics, dual-clutch units and CVTs from several automakers. Here are ten that earned a reputation for gearboxes giving out well before their time.
1. 2013 Chrysler 200: Slipping at 39,000 Miles
Owner reports at CarComplaints rank transmission slipping as the number three worst problem for this sedan, with repairs averaging $4,000 and arriving at just 39,000 miles. That is the lowest mileage in this lineup, well inside a typical powertrain warranty, and a steep bill for a family car whose resale value was never high.
Shoppers weighing a used example should insist on a long test drive, watching for delayed engagement and flare between gears. Service records showing fluid changes carry real weight, and a seller without them gives reason to negotiate hard.
2. 2013 Dodge Dart: Worst Problem, Early Failure
In owner reports, the transmission stopped working complaint sits at the top of this compact sedan’s problem list, ahead of every engine, electrical and body issue. Typical repairs cost $3,400 and show up around 43,000 miles.
Anyone eyeing a used copy should treat a missing service history as a warning sign and ask directly whether the gearbox has been replaced. Because the gearbox heads the complaint list rather than trailing it, a test drive that includes stop-and-go traffic and a few hard accelerations from rest is a sensible minimum before any money changes hands.
3. 2011 Chevrolet Cruze: A $3,300 Failure at 65,000 Miles
Owner submissions on the Cruze complaints page show transmission failure averaging $3,300 to fix, with the breakdown arriving around 65,000 miles. That mileage sits beyond a basic warranty but well short of the 100,000 miles a compact car’s gearbox is normally expected to reach.
For a used buyer, the figure works as a ready-made budget line: a Cruze from this year with mileage near that range deserves a discount or a recent service record. Owners already past 60,000 miles may want to keep an eye on shift quality, since catching trouble before total failure can sometimes soften the eventual bill.
4. 2011 Ford Fiesta: Transmission Tops the Complaints
Transmission trouble is the single worst complaint category for this subcompact hatchback, and CarComplaints data puts the average failure at $3,400 and 67,000 miles. A bill that size is a considerable share of what a small, inexpensive car is worth by then.
Buyers shopping the used market for an affordable runabout should read that as a prompt to look hard at maintenance paperwork. A car that has cleared 67,000 miles with no gearbox repair on record may be a better bet than one that is lower on the odometer but short on documentation, though neither is guaranteed to escape the problem.
5. Ford Focus (third generation): Dry-Clutch Shudder
Its dual-clutch automatic drew shuddering complaints and lemon-law claims after a seal leaked fluid onto the dry clutches, as the Focus generation article documents. Ford went through at least six clutch and module revisions, yet no recall was issued.
That combination of repeated fixes and no formal recall leaves owners dependent on dealer goodwill and warranty status. Prospective buyers of a used hatchback or sedan from this generation should confirm which transmission is fitted, ask what software or hardware updates have been applied, and test for hesitation and judder when pulling away from a stop.
6. 2014 Fiat 500L: Complaints Cluster in One Year
Of the 38 complaints on file for this boxy hatchback, 35 come from the 2014 model year, and the CarComplaints 500L page lists the transmission as the worst category. A sample that small is thin, but the concentration points at one year rather than the model as a whole.
Used-car shoppers can take from that a simple lesson: model year matters as much as nameplate. A 2014 example calls for extra scrutiny of shifting behavior and service paperwork, while later years in this short-lived line have far fewer reports, though the small data set leaves any firm conclusion open.
7. 2014 Nissan Altima: CVT Repairs Near 75,200 Miles
Across 73 owner complaints, the CVT in this midsize sedan averaged $3,860 to repair, failing at about 75,200 miles, according to Jalopnik’s Nissan CVT roundup. It sits among the better-known examples of the problem.
At roughly $3,860, a repair can approach the value of an older sedan, so buyers need to know whether the unit has already been replaced. Whining, shudder or a sudden loss of power under acceleration are common warning signs, and a seller’s willingness to hand over fluid-service receipts says a good deal about how the car has been treated.
8. Nissan Sentra (2007-2019): Belt Slip and Overheating
Jalopnik names this compact sedan among Nissans with unreliable CVTs, and its CVT list describes belt slip causing shudder, overheating and a loss of power. The listing covers 2007 to 2019, so the exposure spans more than a decade of production.
For used shoppers, that wide range means checking the specific car rather than assuming a later year is safe. A test drive that includes steady highway cruising and gentle hill climbs can reveal a shudder or a whine, and an overheating warning or reduced-power mode in the history is reason enough to pass.
9. Nissan Versa (2007-2019): Class Actions and Extended Warranties
This subcompact appears on Jalopnik’s list of Nissans with unreliable CVTs, a problem backed by class actions and warranty extensions. The span runs from 2007 to 2019, taking in nearly every generation sold before the latest redesign.
The legal action and extended coverage matter to anyone buying used, because eligibility depends on the car’s age and mileage, and the terms can change by model year. Before purchase, a VIN check with a dealer can show whether any extension still applies, and written proof of past CVT service is worth requesting.
10. Nissan Maxima (2007-2019): Extended Coverage for CVT Trouble
The large sedan joins the same group of Nissans listed for CVT trouble, and Jalopnik’s piece notes that Nissan extended CVT coverage from 5 years or 60,000 miles to 7 years or 84,000 miles. An extension like that quietly concedes the original warranty ran out too soon.
Owners should check the VIN against the longer coverage terms, since a transmission repair that falls inside seven years and 84,000 miles may cost nothing. Used buyers should confirm that the car is still within that window, because the added protection ends on the same schedule for every owner who comes after.
More from Morning Overview
- Verizon just moved to cut landline phone service in 9 states within weeks
- Tropical Storm Rachel is dumping up to 12 inches on four Mexican states on its way to major hurricane strength
- The NSA is again telling phone owners to switch off one location setting
- Card skimmers hidden on gas pumps and ATMs are draining accounts, and here’s the tell
