Three daily servings of full-fat dairy did not worsen weight or cholesterol in a 12-week study

Adults who ate three daily servings of full-fat dairy for 12 weeks did not gain more weight or show worse blood cholesterol than adults on a low-dairy, calorie-restricted diet, according to a randomized trial from the University of Toronto. All 74 participants had overweight or obesity. The results were published in The Journal of Nutrition, and ScienceDaily carried the university’s account on Nov. 6.

Stay ahead on AI: Join 600,000+ professionals who read The Deep View, the daily newsletter that keeps you up to date with artificial intelligence.

Subscribe to The Deep View →

We may earn a commission if you sign up.

Harvey Anderson, a professor of nutritional sciences in the university’s Temerty Faculty of Medicine and the lead researcher, said the people eating three servings of dairy did not end up with adverse levels of blood cholesterol or lipids. His advice stayed deliberately plain: keep it simple, eat a variety of foods and not too much of anything. The researchers do not suggest that everyone should switch to full-fat dairy.

Three arms, 74 adults and supplied dairy

The paper, The Effect of Three Daily Servings of Full-Fat Dairy for 12 Weeks on Body Weight, Body Composition, Energy Metabolism, Blood Lipids, and Dietary Intake of Adults with Overweight and Obesity, appears in The Journal of Nutrition, volume 156, issue 4. Participants were randomly assigned to one of three arms. One followed a calorie-restricted diet with little dairy. A second ate three daily dairy servings within an energy-neutral diet, meaning intake meant to match energy expended. The third ate three servings with no specific calorie restriction.

Everyone received guidance based on Canada’s food guide, and the researchers supplied the full-fat dairy products. The Temerty Medicine news release describes the comparison as the low-dairy group against the two three-serving groups, which is how the main findings are framed.

The design matters for how to read the result. Two of the three arms ate the same three servings, one under an energy-neutral plan and one with no calorie restriction, so the trial could ask whether dairy itself changed outcomes when calories were held steady and also when they were not. Both three-serving groups landed in the same place relative to the low-dairy group on weight gain, body composition and cholesterol. Supplying the products also removed guesswork about what participants actually ate, a common weakness in diet research.

Weight, cholesterol and blood pressure results

Compared with the low-dairy group, the three-serving groups showed no meaningful differences in weight gain, body composition or blood cholesterol. ScienceDaily’s version adds that energy metabolism was not harmed and that insulin resistance did not worsen. The dairy groups also showed improved blood pressure and higher intakes of calcium, protein and vitamin D.

No effect sizes accompany those statements. DairyReporter’s coverage, which appeared in August when the paper first drew attention, gives no figures for weight change, body fat or blood pressure readings, and the university materials omit them too. That leaves the size of the blood pressure improvement unknown, and readers should treat it as a direction, not a measured amount.

The dairy matrix hypothesis

Anderson pointed to the dairy matrix hypothesis to explain why saturated fat in dairy may behave differently from saturated fat elsewhere. In his description, dairy contains two proteins, casein and whey, that are bound together with fat and other nutrients, and that physical structure may affect how quickly nutrients are released during digestion. The researchers present this as a possibility. The trial did not test it directly, and the mechanism is not established.

Saturated fat is not described as harmless, and the background matters here. Canadian and other dietary guidelines have long recommended low-fat dairy, mainly because saturated fat can raise LDL cholesterol. A separate study led by Temerty Medicine professor Kozeta Milliku found an association between whole-fat milk consumption and lower childhood obesity risk, which the university cites as supporting evidence. An earlier ScienceDaily post from August covered the same research under a similar framing, so the November item is a second airing of one trial.

For shoppers, the study does not turn cheese into a health food. It says that, for 12 weeks and in this group of adults with overweight or obesity, adding three servings of full-fat dairy did not push weight, cholesterol or insulin resistance in the wrong direction while blood pressure and nutrient intake moved the right way. Whether the same holds for people with existing heart disease, or over years, is not something the trial can speak to.

Funding, size and what 12 weeks cannot show

The study was funded by Dairy Research Cluster 3 under the Canadian Agricultural Partnership AgriScience Program, plus the Mitacs Accelerate program. DairyReporter calls it an industry-backed study, describing the cluster as a joint government and industry initiative. The sources do not say whether the funders had any role in the design or analysis, and that detail is worth checking in the paper itself.

The limits are plain. Seventy-four adults is a small sample, and three months is a short window. The trial did not measure whether years of eating this way prevents or promotes diabetes, heart disease or other chronic conditions, and it enrolled people defined by overweight or obesity, so its findings may not carry over to other groups. Anderson and colleagues say longer and larger studies are needed to show lasting benefits or any effect on cardiovascular disease risk, which is the question guidelines on saturated fat were built to answer.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.

Stay ahead on AI: Subscribe to The Deep View →

We may earn a commission if you sign up.