For older women, the choice between a morning cup of tea or coffee may be doing more than setting the day’s mood. New research tracking thousands of seniors over a decade suggests tea is linked to slightly stronger bones, while heavy coffee intake appears to chip away at bone strength and raise the risk of fractures. The findings sharpen a long running debate over caffeine, calcium and aging, and they hint that a simple switch in mug could matter for osteoporosis prevention.
What the new research actually found
The latest evidence comes from a large, long term project that followed 9,704 women aged 65 and older, examining how their daily coffee and tea habits related to bone mineral density and fracture risk. Researchers found that women who regularly drank tea tended to have slightly higher hip bone mineral density than those who did not, a pattern that held even after accounting for age, weight and lifestyle factors. The same project reported no measurable benefit of coffee for bone strength, and at higher intakes coffee was linked to weaker bones and more fractures.
Across reports on the study, the signal is consistent: tea drinkers had a modest but statistically significant advantage in total hip bone mineral density, while heavy coffee drinkers faced a small but real disadvantage. One summary noted that tea drinkers had a slightly higher total hip BMD compared with non tea drinkers, and another emphasized that Researchers found no positive benefits of drinking coffee on bone mineral density at all. That contrast is what has fueled headlines about tea “protecting” and coffee “harming” bones in older women.
Inside the decade long study design
To understand how much weight to give these findings, it helps to look at how the research was built. The project was described as a decade long study of older women, with repeated assessments of bone mineral density at key skeletal sites such as the hip. Over 10 years, participants reported their coffee and tea consumption, while researchers measured bone density using standard clinical tools and tracked who went on to suffer fractures. That long follow up is important, because bone loss and osteoporosis develop slowly and can be missed in shorter snapshots.
The team analyzed patterns in hip bone mineral density and fracture outcomes in relation to how much tea or coffee women said they drank. One report explained that the Flinders University team analyzed self reported beverage intake alongside bone scans and fracture records, allowing them to see how different drinking patterns played out over time. Previous observational work on caffeine and bone health has often been inconsistent, and one summary noted that Previous findings have rarely followed such a large group across an entire decade, which is why this dataset is drawing so much attention.
Tea’s “gentle advantage” for aging bones
Across the analyses, tea emerged as a quiet ally for bone strength in older women. Women who regularly drank tea had slightly but significantly higher hip bone mineral density than those who did not, a pattern that held even after adjusting for smoking, exercise and other health behaviors. One report framed this as Women who regularly drank tea having higher hip BMD, suggesting that the habit may help preserve bone mass in the very years when it tends to decline fastest.
Another account described tea’s Gentle Advantage for Bone Density, emphasizing that the benefit was modest in size but consistent across the cohort. In practical terms, that means tea is not a magic shield against osteoporosis, but it may tilt the odds slightly in favor of stronger hips and fewer fractures when combined with other bone friendly habits. For older women already at risk, even a small shift in bone mineral density can translate into fewer debilitating falls and hospital stays.
Why coffee looks riskier in this data
On the coffee side, the picture is more concerning, especially at higher doses. The same long term study found no evidence that coffee improved bone mineral density, and instead linked heavy intake with lower hip BMD and more fractures. One summary put it bluntly, noting that What Did This Study Find was that coffee offered no positive benefits for bone mineral density and that excessive intake may be detrimental. Another report echoed that message, stating that excessive intake may be detrimental for bone health.
Researchers and commentators have pointed to caffeine as a likely culprit. Laboratory work has shown that Coffee‘s caffeine content can interfere with calcium absorption and may increase calcium loss in urine, which over years could erode bone density. One analysis noted that many common drinks contain caffeine, but that coffee in particular is consumed at high levels that may push intake into a range where bone effects become measurable. The new findings do not mean every cup of coffee is harmful, but they do suggest that several strong brews a day, over many years, could carry a cost for older women’s skeletons.
How big is the bone density gap?
The differences in bone mineral density between tea drinkers, coffee drinkers and abstainers were not dramatic, but they were statistically significant and clinically relevant. One summary reported that the study found that tea drinkers had a slightly higher total hip BMD than non tea drinkers, underscoring that the advantage is measured in small percentage points rather than sweeping gains. Another account noted that people who reported drinking tea had slightly higher hip bone mineral density than people who did not drink tea, again emphasizing the word “slightly.”Yet in osteoporosis research, small shifts in bone mineral density can have outsized effects on fracture risk, especially at the hip, where breaks are strongly associated with loss of independence and mortality. A related news release stressed that Tea was linked to stronger bones in older women, while coffee may pose risks, and highlighted that hip bone density is strongly associated with fracture risk. When viewed through that lens, a “slight” improvement in BMD from tea, or a “slight” reduction from heavy coffee, can translate into meaningful differences in how many women end up in emergency rooms after a fall.
What might explain tea’s protective edge?
Tea is not just flavored water with caffeine, it is a complex brew of plant compounds that may interact with bone cells and mineral metabolism. Researchers have pointed to polyphenols, flavonoids and other antioxidants in tea as possible drivers of its bone friendly profile, suggesting they may reduce inflammation and oxidative stress that can accelerate bone loss. One report framed this as Tea boosts bone strength in older women, hinting that the drink’s bioactive compounds may help preserve bone structure as estrogen levels fall after menopause.
There is also a behavioral angle. People who drink tea regularly may have different lifestyle patterns than those who favor coffee, including lower alcohol intake or different dietary habits, and the researchers worked to adjust for those factors. One analysis noted that People who reported drinking tea tended to have other health related differences, such as how often they drink alcohol, which the team accounted for in their models. Even after those adjustments, tea’s association with higher hip BMD persisted, which strengthens the case that something in the drink itself, rather than just the lifestyle around it, may be contributing to the observed bone benefits.
Limits, caveats and what remains unverified
As compelling as the tea versus coffee contrast looks, the study is observational, which means it can reveal associations but cannot prove that one drink directly causes stronger or weaker bones. Participants self reported their beverage intake, which introduces the possibility of recall errors or changes in habits over time that were not fully captured. One summary acknowledged that these self report limitations may have weakened the study results, even though the overall patterns remained statistically robust. Unverified based on available sources are more granular details, such as exact fracture counts by beverage category or how different brewing methods might alter risk.
There is also the question of dose. The reports consistently warn about “excessive” coffee intake, but they do not all spell out a precise threshold at which risk begins to climb, and that lack of a clear cutoff can make it harder for individuals to translate the findings into daily choices. One account highlighted that high levels of drinking coffee were associated with more fractures, but did not define those levels in cups per day. Until more detailed dose response data are published, I see these findings as a directional nudge rather than a strict prescription: they suggest that leaning toward tea and away from very heavy coffee is likely wise for bone health, without dictating an exact number of mugs.
What this means for older women and their doctors
For women in their 60s, 70s and beyond, the new evidence adds one more lever to pull in the effort to avoid osteoporosis and fractures. It does not replace core strategies like adequate calcium and vitamin D intake, weight bearing exercise and fall prevention, but it does suggest that the contents of the breakfast cup are not trivial. One report summed it up by noting that Drinking tea strengthens the bones as we age, say scientists, while heavy coffee may weaken them. For clinicians counseling older patients, that is a simple, concrete message that can be folded into broader lifestyle advice.
In practical terms, I would interpret the data as support for encouraging older women who already enjoy tea to keep the habit, and for those who drink several strong coffees a day to consider cutting back or swapping at least some of those cups for tea. A related news release stressed that Tea linked to stronger bones in older women, while coffee may pose risks, and underscored that hip bone density is strongly associated with fracture risk. For a patient who has already had a low trauma fracture or has very low BMD on a scan, that kind of evidence can help make the case that even small, everyday changes, like what goes into the mug, are worth considering alongside medications and supplements.
How the study is reshaping the tea versus coffee narrative
The idea that tea might be kinder to bones than coffee is not entirely new, but this large, long term dataset is giving the comparison fresh urgency and sharper contours. One widely shared summary described how Researchers studied whether daily coffee and tea habits affected bone strength in older women and found a stark divide in bone density between heavy coffee drinkers and regular tea drinkers. Another report, framed as Untitled in its metadata, underscored that the study followed a large cohort over many years, lending weight to the observed patterns.
At the same time, the coverage has tried to avoid oversimplifying the story into a cartoonish “tea good, coffee bad” slogan. One piece, labeled By Talker News, emphasized that the benefits of tea and the risks of coffee are relative and modest, and that overall diet and lifestyle still dominate the bone health equation. Another summary, tagged with Dec in its citation, noted that previous findings have been inconsistent and that this new work helps clarify, but not completely settle, the relationship between caffeine, tea, coffee and bone density. For now, the best reading of the evidence is that tea offers a small protective nudge, heavy coffee a small hazard, and that both effects matter most in the context of aging bones already under strain.
More from MorningOverview