Knots are not just for shoelaces and sailing lines. In the last decade, physicists have shown that swirling liquids can spontaneously tie themselves into intricate knots, and they are finally starting to pin down the rules that govern when those tangles appear and how they evolve. What once looked like a quirky laboratory stunt is now turning into a framework for predicting and even engineering knotted structures inside flowing fluids.
By tracking how loops of motion twist, stretch, and reconnect, researchers are uncovering a hidden order in what used to be dismissed as messy turbulence. I now see those knots as a kind of topological fingerprint, revealing how energy moves through water, air, and even plasmas, and pointing toward new ways to control flows in technologies that range from microfluidic chips to fusion reactors.
From everyday tangles to topological knots in water
Anyone who has pulled a charging cable from a bag knows that motion alone can create knots, even when no one is trying to tie them. Fluid knots are the same story written in water: as a liquid flows, swirling regions can loop around themselves, forming closed rings and linked structures that behave like invisible pieces of string embedded in the flow. I find it helpful to think of these loops not as material objects but as patterns of motion, where every point in the loop is a parcel of fluid moving in a coordinated dance with its neighbors.
In technical terms, these structures are often described as knotted vortex lines or vortex tubes, where the local rotation of the fluid traces out a closed curve that can twist and link with other curves. Early theoretical work suggested that such knotted vortices should be possible, but for a long time they remained a mathematical curiosity rather than an observed phenomenon. That gap between theory and reality set the stage for a series of experiments that would turn the abstract idea of fluid knotting into something researchers could see, film, and measure in three dimensions, as later detailed in explorations of the mysteries of fluid flow knots.
The first laboratory knots in a flowing fluid
The breakthrough came when a team of physicists figured out how to sculpt a jet of fluid so that it carried a knotted pattern of vorticity from the moment it left the nozzle. Instead of waiting for turbulence to produce a tangle by chance, they engineered the initial conditions so that the flow already contained a looped and linked structure. I see this as the fluid equivalent of tying a knot in a smoke ring before it leaves your lips, then watching how that knotted ring evolves as it drifts through the air.
To do this, the researchers used carefully shaped hydrofoils and pulses of dyed water to imprint a trefoil knot, the simplest nontrivial knot, into the velocity field of the fluid. High speed imaging and three dimensional reconstruction then allowed them to track the knotted vortex as it moved, stretched, and eventually broke apart. The work was widely recognized as the first time such fluid knots were created in the lab, turning a long standing theoretical prediction into a tangible object of study.
Why mathematicians cared long before experimentalists could catch up
Long before anyone could tie water into a knot, mathematicians had been cataloging the ways a closed loop can twist and link with itself. Knot theory, a branch of topology, classifies knots by properties that do not change when the loop is stretched or deformed without cutting. When I look at fluid knots through this lens, I see each vortex loop as a topological object whose essential character survives even as the flow around it becomes wildly complicated.
In fluid dynamics, this topological perspective shows up in the concept of helicity, a quantity that measures how much vortex lines wrap and coil around one another. Helicity is conserved in ideal flows, which means that the total knottedness of the vortex field cannot change unless reconnections occur. That connection between abstract invariants and physical motion is what made the first experimental realization so compelling. It suggested that the same mathematical tools used to classify knots on paper could help explain how real fluids store and transfer energy, a theme that runs through later discussions of topological structures in fluid flows.
How physicists actually tied water into knots
Turning those ideas into a real experiment required a clever piece of fluid engineering. The team that first demonstrated knotted vortices used a shaped winglike object, submerged in water, and then drove a short, sharp motion that shed a vortex loop from the trailing edge. By designing the shape of the object and the timing of the motion, they could force the shed vortex to wrap around itself in a prescribed pattern. I think of the hydrofoil as a kind of three dimensional stamp, imprinting a knotted pattern into the flow each time it is flicked.
Once the knot was created, the challenge was to see it. The researchers seeded the water with tiny tracer particles and used laser sheets and cameras to reconstruct the three dimensional velocity field, effectively building a digital model of the vortex lines frame by frame. This allowed them to watch the trefoil knot propagate, deform, and eventually undergo reconnections that changed its topology. Detailed accounts of how the first fluid knots were created emphasize that the experiment was as much an imaging triumph as a theoretical one, since without that reconstruction the knot would have remained invisible.
What happens when a fluid knot starts to unravel
Once a knotted vortex is set loose in a fluid, it does not simply drift intact. The loop stretches, thins, and contorts under the influence of its own induced velocity and the surrounding flow. Eventually, segments of the vortex line approach each other closely enough that viscosity and small scale dynamics trigger reconnection events, where the topology of the vortex field changes. I see these reconnections as the key moves in the story, the moments when the knot can simplify, split, or transform into a different linked structure.
In the trefoil experiments, high resolution measurements showed that the initial knot did not vanish in a single dramatic snap. Instead, it went through a sequence of reconnections that produced a cascade of simpler loops and links, each carrying away a portion of the original helicity. That stepwise simplification provided a rare, direct view of how topological complexity is redistributed in a real fluid. Narratives that describe how physicists tied water into knots highlight this gradual untying as one of the most striking aspects of the work, because it connects the visual evolution of the knot to deeper conservation laws.
Why knotting matters for turbulence and energy transfer
At first glance, knotted vortices might look like a laboratory curiosity with little relevance to the chaotic flows in a storm cloud or a jet engine. I have come to see them differently. In turbulence, energy cascades from large scales to small scales through a hierarchy of eddies and vortices. If those vortices are linked and knotted, then the topology of the vortex field becomes part of the bookkeeping for how energy and momentum move through the fluid. Knots are not just decorative; they are a structural feature of the flow.
Helicity, which captures the degree of linkage and twist, has long been suspected to influence the stability and evolution of turbulent flows. The controlled creation and decay of knotted vortices gives researchers a clean way to test those ideas, by starting with a known topological configuration and watching how it breaks down. Analyses of physicists twisting water into knots emphasize that understanding this process could refine models of turbulence, especially in systems where rotation and swirl play a dominant role, such as atmospheric vortices and swirling industrial mixers.
Visualizing knots: from lab videos to intuitive understanding
One of the reasons fluid knots have captured so much attention is that they are unusually visual. When I watch experimental videos of a knotted vortex drifting through a tank, I am not just seeing a scientific data set; I am seeing topology come to life. The dyed core of the vortex traces out a luminous loop that twists and folds in three dimensions, making abstract concepts like linking number and reconnection feel almost tangible.
These visualizations are not just for outreach. They help researchers build intuition about how local curvature, tension along the vortex line, and interactions between nearby segments drive the evolution of the knot. Slow motion footage of fluid knots in motion reveals patterns that can then be quantified and compared with simulations, closing the loop between theory, experiment, and computation. In my view, that feedback is crucial, because it turns a one off demonstration into a platform for systematically probing the physics of knotted flows.
Hidden physics: spontaneous knotting and self organization
While the first experiments focused on deliberately tied knots, researchers are increasingly interested in how knotting can emerge spontaneously in complex flows. In many systems, from stirred tanks to biological fluids, vortex lines are constantly being stretched and folded. Under the right conditions, that folding can produce loops that thread through each other without any external choreography. I see this as a form of self organization, where the flow naturally explores topologically complex configurations as it evolves.
Recent work by a Rice University team has pushed this idea further by identifying mechanisms that favor the formation and persistence of knotted structures in certain hydrodynamic regimes. Their analysis suggests that by tuning parameters like shear, rotation, and confinement, it is possible to bias a flow toward states where knotting is common and long lived. In their words, “By learning how to harness this natural process, we can imagine new technologies that leverage hydrodynamics and self”, a statement that captures both the fundamental and applied stakes of understanding fluid knotting.
From curiosity to potential applications
As the physics of fluid knotting becomes clearer, potential applications are starting to come into focus. In microfluidic devices, for example, engineers struggle to mix reagents efficiently at small scales where turbulence is hard to achieve. If knotted vortices can be generated and controlled inside tiny channels, they could provide a new way to stir and homogenize fluids without moving parts. I can imagine lab on a chip systems that rely on carefully programmed pulses of flow to tie and untie microscopic knots, using topology as a design parameter.
Beyond microfluidics, the same principles could inform strategies for managing vortices in larger scale systems. In aerodynamics, controlling the formation and shedding of vortex loops around wings and turbine blades is key to reducing drag and noise. Insights from knotted vortex experiments might inspire new geometries or actuation schemes that steer those structures away from harmful configurations. Even in astrophysical and fusion plasmas, where magnetic field lines can form knotted and linked structures, the language and tools developed for fluid knots may help clarify how energy is stored and released in topologically complex fields.
What comes next for the science of knotted flows
The story of knots in flowing liquids is still in its early chapters. So far, most experiments have focused on relatively simple knots in controlled laboratory settings, often using water in small tanks. The next steps will likely involve more complex topologies, different fluids, and flows that are closer to real world conditions. I expect to see experiments that combine multiple knotted vortices, probing how they interact, merge, or annihilate, as well as studies that embed knots in background turbulence to see how robust they remain.
On the theoretical side, researchers are working to connect the detailed dynamics of individual knots to statistical descriptions of whole flows, so that knotting can be incorporated into models of turbulence, mixing, and transport. As that bridge is built, the once esoteric idea of a knotted vortex may become a standard part of the vocabulary for describing complex motion in fluids. For now, the key insight is that knots are not accidents in a chaotic medium; they are structured, quantifiable features that reveal how motion, geometry, and topology intertwine in the hidden architecture of flowing liquids.
More from MorningOverview