Long before forests of tall trees covered the planet, Earth was ruled by something stranger: towering, trunk like organisms that rose roughly 26 feet into the air. New analysis of exquisitely preserved fossils from Scotland now suggests these giants did not belong to any familiar group of plants, fungi, or animals, but instead represent a completely new branch of life that has no living descendants. The work reframes one of the most puzzling fossils in paleontology and turns a quiet patch of countryside near Aberdeen into the site of a profound biological discovery.
The enigmatic organism, known as Prototaxites, formed massive columns that dominated early land ecosystems and have baffled scientists for more than a century. By reexamining its internal structure and chemistry, researchers argue that these 8 meter towers were neither tree nor mushroom, but a distinct macroscopic eukaryote that sat apart from the kingdoms that structure modern biology.
Unearthing giants near Rhynie
The latest breakthrough began with fossils recovered from a sedimentary deposit near Rhynie in Aberdeenshire, an area already famous among geologists for preserving some of the earliest land ecosystems in remarkable detail. In reports on the new work, the organisms are described as standing around 26 feet tall, with wide, branchless trunks that would have loomed over the low vegetation of the time, a scale that helps explain why early researchers assumed they must be primitive trees. Coverage of the find notes that the discovery site lies roughly an hour’s drive from Aberdeen, underscoring how an apparently ordinary landscape can conceal the remains of a radically unfamiliar life form, and it is in this context that the fossils have been described as a new form of life.
These fossils belong to the genus Prototaxites, which has been known from sites around the world but rarely in such pristine three dimensional preservation. Earlier this year, researchers working on material from the Rhynie area described 8 meter tall, cylindrical organisms that were wide and branchless, forming towers that defied easy identification and stood out among the smaller plants and early arthropods preserved alongside them. Accounts of the work emphasize that these wide and towering structures were unlike anything else in their environment, reinforcing the sense that scientists were dealing with something fundamentally different from familiar tree trunks or fungal fruiting bodies.
A fossil that refused to fit
For more than a century, Prototaxites has been a scientific chameleon, repeatedly reassigned as new evidence emerged. Early paleontologists interpreted the fossils as conifer like trees, largely because of their size and columnar form, but later work on their internal texture and chemistry suggested a closer resemblance to fungi. Even that interpretation never fully settled the debate, since the microscopic structure of the tissues and the way the organism grew did not match any known fungal group, leaving Prototaxites as a persistent outlier in textbooks and museum collections. A recent synthesis of the evidence describes it as a bizarre ancient life form that was considered the first giant organism to live on land, and notes that it may belong to a totally unknown branch of life rather than fitting neatly into plants or fungi, a view supported by new analyses of its fungus like features.
The new Scottish material has allowed researchers to go further, examining a species named Prototaxites taiti from the Rhynie deposits in close detail. By studying the fossilized remains of this species, preserved alongside some of the earliest known land plants and animals in Scotland, scientists could compare its anatomy and chemistry with those of modern organisms. Reports on the work explain that the team focused on the internal fabric of the trunk and the way its tissues were organized, and that the Rhynie fossils of Prototaxites taiti were found in association with early terrestrial ecosystems near Rhynie, giving crucial context for how the organism lived.
Evidence for a “whole new kind” of life
The most striking conclusion from the new analyses is that Prototaxites does not behave like a fungus when its growth patterns and internal structure are reconstructed. A 2026 paper on the genus concluded that its tissues show a complex organization and growth strategy that does not match fungal hyphae, and that the way it built its massive trunk points to a trait not found in fungi at all. In that work, Prototaxites is described as an extinct macroscopic eukaryote that lived from the Late Silurian until the Late Dev, a time when true trees had not yet evolved, and the authors argue that its unique characteristics justify treating it as a separate branch of the eukaryotic tree of life, a view summarized in updated entries on Prototaxites.
Other researchers have framed the same conclusion in more accessible terms, describing these fossils as “mysterious giants” that may represent a whole new kind of life that no longer exists. That phrase captures the unsettling implication of the data: if Prototaxites is neither plant, animal, nor fungus, then Earth’s early land ecosystems included a major lineage that has since vanished without leaving any obvious modern relatives. Analyses of the limited fossil evidence emphasize how little is known about this group, and discussions of these mysterious giants stress that scientists are reconstructing an entire branch of life from a handful of petrified trunks.
How a 26 foot column reshapes early Earth
To grasp the ecological impact of Prototaxites, it helps to picture the world it inhabited. During the Late Silurian and into the Late Dev, land surfaces were mostly covered by low, moss like plants and small vascular species that rarely rose more than a meter or two above the ground. In that setting, a column up to 8 meters tall and up to 1 meter in diameter would have towered over everything else, creating the first true vertical structure on land. Descriptions of the genus note that Prototaxites reached these dimensions consistently, with a diameter of up to 1 meter and a height of up to 8 meters, making it the largest known land organism of its time and a dominant feature of early terrestrial landscapes, as summarized in detailed entries on its size and age.
That scale matters because it suggests Prototaxites played a central role in shaping early soils, microclimates, and nutrient cycles. Reports on the new Scottish discovery describe it as Earth’s first giant land dwelling organism, towering over all other life forms of its age and likely influencing how water and carbon moved through those primitive ecosystems. The same accounts emphasize that the fossils from near Aberdeen show Prototaxites embedded in communities of early plants and arthropods, reinforcing the idea that these trunks acted as structural pillars in the landscape, a role captured in descriptions of Earth’s first giant.
The long debate over what it was
Even as the new work points to a separate branch of life, the debate over Prototaxites has left a long paper trail that helps explain why the fossil was so hard to classify. Earlier isotopic studies suggested that the organism fed in a way that resembled fungi, drawing on a mix of organic sources rather than photosynthesizing like a plant, and for years many specialists treated it as a giant fungus. Commentaries on the fossil note that subsequent studies revealed a complex internal structure that looked fungal enough to support that view, and that for a time the consensus was that Prototaxites was a giant fungus, a position laid out in accessible explainers that walk through the evidence for a giant fungus.
More recent analyses, however, have forced a rethink. Researchers now argue that while assuming it was a fungus helped frame earlier work, the full suite of anatomical and chemical data does not fit any known fungal lineage. One synthesis notes that Prototaxites has always been a unique mystery and that, after comparing its features with modern groups, the scientists concluded that Prototaxites should be treated as a distinct type of organism rather than shoehorned into fungi, a shift in perspective captured in detailed discussions of its whole new status.
More from Morning Overview