Home renovation expert Mike Holmes has long advised homeowners to do their homework before any major upgrade, and heat pumps are no exception. As more households consider switching to heat pump systems for both heating and cooling, Holmes stresses that choosing the right unit requires more than picking a brand name off a shelf. The difference between a well-matched system and a poor one can mean years of inflated energy bills and uncomfortable indoor temperatures.
Efficiency Ratings That Actually Matter
One of the biggest mistakes homeowners make, according to Holmes, is ignoring the technical specifications that determine how hard a heat pump will work and how much energy it will consume. Three metrics stand out on any spec sheet for residential air-source heat pumps: SEER2, which measures cooling efficiency; HSPF2, which measures heating efficiency; and EER2, which captures overall energy performance. These are not marketing buzzwords. They are standardized ratings that allow direct comparison between units.
The ENERGY STAR program, administered by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, sets minimum thresholds that certified air-source heat pumps must meet for each of these metrics. Homeowners shopping for a new system should look for units that carry the ENERGY STAR label, which signals compliance with key product criteria for SEER2, HSPF2, and EER2. A unit that falls below those thresholds may cost less upfront but will almost certainly cost more to operate over its lifespan.
Holmes recommends that homeowners ask their HVAC contractor to walk through these numbers before signing any contract. If a contractor cannot explain what SEER2 or HSPF2 means for a specific home, that is a red flag worth acting on.
Cold Climate Performance Is a Separate Standard
Standard heat pumps can struggle when temperatures drop well below freezing. This is where many installations go wrong, particularly in northern states and parts of Canada where Holmes has worked extensively. A system rated for mild winters may lose a significant share of its heating capacity once the thermometer plunges, forcing homeowners to rely on expensive backup heating sources like electric resistance coils or propane furnaces.
ENERGY STAR addresses this gap with a distinct Cold Climate designation. Units that earn this label must demonstrate they can maintain full heating output at extremely low outdoor temperatures. The EPA, which oversees the ENERGY STAR program, treats the Cold Climate category as a separate tier precisely because the performance demands are so different from standard conditions.
For homeowners in regions that regularly see single-digit or sub-zero temperatures, Holmes argues that a standard ENERGY STAR label is not enough. They should specifically confirm that the unit carries the Cold Climate designation before committing to a purchase. Skipping this step is one of the most common and costly oversights in heat pump installations, because a system that cannot keep up in deep winter defeats the purpose of switching away from a traditional furnace.
Why Sizing Depends on Local Design Temperatures
Even the most efficient heat pump will underperform if it is the wrong size for the home and climate where it operates. Holmes frequently warns against the tendency to oversize equipment, a habit that persists among some contractors who believe bigger always means better. An oversized unit cycles on and off too frequently, which wastes energy, increases wear on components, and fails to properly dehumidify indoor air during cooling season.
Proper sizing starts with understanding the local outdoor design temperature, not the average winter temperature. The distinction matters. Average temperatures smooth out the coldest days, but a heating system must be able to handle the extremes. ENERGY STAR publishes a design temperature limit reference guide that HVAC professionals use when preparing National HVAC Design Reports for residential new construction. That guide specifies the low-temperature benchmarks for different geographic areas, and those benchmarks should drive the sizing calculation for any heat pump installation.
Holmes points out that many homeowners never see this data because their contractor handles the calculation behind the scenes. He encourages homeowners to ask for the design temperature used in their sizing report and to verify it against the published reference guide. If the numbers do not match, the system may be oversized or undersized, and either outcome erodes the energy savings that motivated the switch to a heat pump in the first place.
The Gap Between Spec Sheets and Real-World Results
One area where available data remains thin is long-term, real-world performance tracking. While ENERGY STAR ratings provide a reliable baseline for comparing units at the point of sale, there is limited publicly available research on how heat pump efficiency degrades over five to ten years across different U.S. climate zones. Holmes has spoken about seeing systems that performed well in their first two winters but lost noticeable capacity by year five, particularly in homes where maintenance was deferred.
This gap in institutional data means homeowners cannot easily calculate a precise return-on-investment timeline before installation. Federal incentives, including tax credits tied to the Inflation Reduction Act, have accelerated heat pump adoption across the country. But those rebates reward the purchase decision, not the long-term outcome. A poorly matched or improperly installed system may qualify for the same rebate as a perfectly engineered one, yet deliver far less value over its operating life.
Holmes suggests that homeowners treat the installation as a long-term investment rather than a one-time transaction. That means budgeting for annual maintenance, keeping filters clean, and scheduling professional inspections at least once a year. It also means choosing a contractor who will stand behind the work and who can demonstrate familiarity with ENERGY STAR guidelines and local building codes.
What Contractors Should Prove Before You Sign
Holmes has been blunt about the quality gap in the HVAC contracting industry. Not every installer has the training or incentive to match equipment to a specific home’s needs. Some default to whatever brand they carry in stock. Others skip the load calculation entirely and estimate based on square footage alone, which ignores insulation quality, window orientation, ductwork condition, and a dozen other variables that affect heating and cooling demand.
Before agreeing to an installation, homeowners should ask their contractor to provide three concrete items. First, a written load calculation report that documents how the heat pump size was determined, including the outdoor design temperature used. Second, a layout or description of how existing ductwork will be evaluated and, if necessary, sealed or modified to handle the new system’s airflow requirements. Third, proof of training or certification related to modern heat pump installation, especially for cold climate models.
Holmes also recommends asking who will be responsible for commissioning the system on the day it is turned on. Proper commissioning includes checking refrigerant charge, verifying airflow, confirming thermostat settings, and ensuring the backup heat source is configured correctly. Skipping these steps can leave even a high-end unit operating below its rated efficiency from day one.
Accessibility, Documentation, and Homeowner Records
Because heat pump technology and incentive programs continue to evolve, keeping clear records matters. Homeowners should maintain a file with the model and serial numbers, the efficiency ratings, copies of the load calculation, and any rebate or tax credit documentation. That file will be invaluable if questions arise about performance, warranty coverage, or future resale disclosures.
Holmes notes that homeowners increasingly rely on online resources from agencies like the EPA to understand energy-efficient equipment. Those sites, including the agency’s accessibility statement, are designed to make technical guidance more usable for people with different needs and abilities. Taking the time to review official guidance can help homeowners ask sharper questions and avoid misunderstandings with contractors.
In the end, Holmes’s advice on heat pumps echoes his broader philosophy on home improvements: the right product, installed the right way, for the right house. That means prioritizing verified efficiency ratings, confirming cold climate performance where needed, insisting on proper sizing based on design temperatures, and demanding clear proof of competence from any contractor. For homeowners willing to do that homework, a well-chosen heat pump can deliver comfortable rooms and lower energy bills for many winters and summers to come.
More from Morning Overview
*This article was researched with the help of AI, with human editors creating the final content.
