For more than a century, the idea that life might have arrived on our planet from elsewhere in the cosmos sat at the fringes of science. Now a mix of genetic clues, asteroid samples and tough little microbes is pushing some researchers to test whether Earth’s first organisms were, in a sense, immigrants. The once‑taboo “starseed” notion is being pulled into the lab, where it is meeting both hard data and hard skepticism.
At stake is not just where life began, but what it means to call Earth our home. If the earliest cells or even the raw chemistry of biology came from beyond our world, then every tree, bacterium and human would carry an extraterrestrial legacy in its DNA.
From fringe speculation to testable hypothesis
In its modern form, panspermia suggests that hardy microbes or their building blocks hitched rides on rocks and dust, then rained down on young planets. According to panspermia, this debris could be blasted off one world by impacts, shield life inside comets or meteors, and eventually seed another system entirely. The concept remains a fringe theory in origin‑of‑life research, but its mechanisms are now being probed with real experiments and space missions rather than left to pure speculation.
Advocates such as Prof Chandra Wickramasinghe, a former colleague of Sir Fred Ho, argue that it is “theoretically plausible” for microbes to survive the journey inside rocks, even if there is still no direct evidence that this actually happened. That cautious balance, possibility without proof, runs through mainstream assessments that treat panspermia as an intriguing but unproven way to move life between planets, as outlined in recent analysis of the idea.
Ancient genes and the timing problem
One reason scientists are revisiting cosmic origins is that life on Earth appears to have started almost as soon as conditions allowed. A recent study pushed back the estimated age of the Last Universal Common Ancestor, or LUCA, to around 4.2 billion years, only a short time after the planet cooled enough for oceans to form. That compressed timeline makes some researchers wonder whether complex chemistry had already been running elsewhere, then arrived here ready to go inside meteorites.
Further work has narrowed the window even more, with new research suggesting the earliest Last Universal Common Ancestor, or LUCA, may date to between 4.09 and 4.33 billion years ago. That places the shared ancestor of all known organisms almost on top of the era when Earth itself was being pummeled by impacts, a coincidence that keeps the door open to the idea that both our planet and its first life were shaped, or even seeded, from elsewhere.
Asteroids, “starseeds” and the chemistry of life
While no one has found a fossil microbe from deep space, the chemistry turning up in asteroids is starting to look uncannily familiar. New findings from NASA and Japan’s space agency show that Bennu, a carbon‑rich asteroid older than any life on Earth, contains complex organic molecules, including some of the constituents of DNA and RNA, according to mission results shared from Bennu. If such chemistry was common in the early solar system, then Earth’s oceans may have been seeded with ready‑made ingredients rather than starting entirely from scratch.
That possibility is reinforced by separate commentary on Bennu samples, which notes that if life’s raw materials exist on Bennu, they could be scattered across the cosmos and trigger life‑friendly chemistry upon arrival on young worlds, a scenario highlighted in mission reactions. In parallel, some researchers talk about “pseudo‑panspermia,” in which molecules such as amino acids and nucleobases form in space and then wash up on planets, a concept that fits with evidence that the basic chemistry shared by all terrestrial life could have been assembled long before it reached Earth, as discussed in recent work on whether life on Earth began among the stars.
Microbes that shrug off space
For panspermia to work, life has to survive a brutal journey: ejection from a planet, years or millennia in vacuum, then a fiery plunge through another atmosphere. That sounds far‑fetched until you look at organisms like Deinococcus radiodurans, a microbe so tough it has been nicknamed “Conan the Bacterium.” Japanese researchers found that Japanese scientists could expose Deinococcus radiodurans to space conditions for up to 8 years and still recover living cells, suggesting that clumps of such microbes could endure long interplanetary trips.
Other experiments have gone further, placing clumps of Deinococcus bacteria outside the International Space Station to see how they cope with radiation and vacuum. Scientists reported that these microbes, which normally live in Earth’s stratosphere, survived as long as three years in outer space, according to tests described by Scientists studying life forms that endure beyond the atmosphere. Together, such results do not prove that life actually traveled between worlds, but they show that at least some organisms are physically capable of surviving the ride.
Space agencies quietly run “starseed” experiments
Governments are now testing pieces of the starseed scenario in orbit and beyond. A Russian satellite operated by Roscosmos recently crash‑landed in a field south west of Moscow while carrying unusual biological cargo, part of an experiment with the Institute of Biomedical Problems (IBMP) to see whether life could spread between planets. The mission’s design, exposing organisms to space and then recovering them on Earth, echoes classic panspermia questions about survival, shielding and reentry.
Earlier work along similar lines suggested that rock and ice in comets and meteors could shield microbes from radiation, allowing them to endure long journeys before being delivered to a new world. Scientists associated with those experiments argued that such natural spacecraft might make interplanetary transfer feasible, even as they stressed that the panspermia hypothesis is still unproven, a point underscored in research summaries of the field.
More from Morning Overview