Hundreds of millions of years before dinosaurs, the tallest things on land were not trees or animals but towering, trunk-like organisms that looked like something from science fiction. Around 400 million years ago, these giants rose over mostly barren ground, their true nature so strange that modern researchers still argue over what kind of life they represent. The fossils are known as Prototaxites, and for roughly 150 years they have stood as one of Earth’s most persistent paleontological riddles.
What makes this story more than a quirky fossil footnote is scale. In an era when most land plants barely reached a few inches, these structures stretched as high as a small building, reshaping early ecosystems and forcing scientists to rethink how complex life first colonized the continents. The debate over what Prototaxites was, and how it lived, is now reshaping ideas about the tree of life itself.
The barren world where a giant towered
To understand why Prototaxites is so startling, I start with the landscape it dominated. Before forests spread, Earth’s land surface during the Silurian and Devonian periods was largely empty rock and soil, punctuated by low mats of primitive plants and patches of moss-like greenery. Accounts of those “Silurian and Dev” environments describe a world where most vegetation hugged the ground and true trees had not yet evolved, so anything that rose several meters into the air would have been an unmistakable landmark. Reconstructions of that time show that, Before trees became widespread, Earth’s landscape was dominated by these giant structures called Prototaxites that rose above the sparse plant cover.
In that context, the sheer size of Prototaxites becomes even more dramatic. Descriptions of these fossils say they were “Standing up to 8 meters (26 feet) tall,” making them the largest living things on land during the Silurian and Devonian, when most other organisms barely cleared the ground. Those same reports describe them as most likely fungi, not plants or trees, evoking the image of a colossal prehistoric mushroom towering over ankle-high greenery, a view reinforced by museum exhibits that present Prototaxites as giant prehistoric fungi. One such display notes that these organisms, known as Standing up to 8 meters tall, were the biggest things on land at that time.
A fossil that refused to fit the rules
The mystery began in the nineteenth century, when early fossil hunters realized they had found something that did not match any known plant or animal. Canadian geologist Canadian John William Dawson studied some of the first specimens from Gaspé Bay and initially described the organism in 1859 as a kind of conifer-like tree, then later argued it might be a marine alga that had washed ashore. In a later reassessment, Dawson, also referred to as Dawson and John William Dawson, suggested the strange trunks might be primitive conifers with fungal growths, a sign of how hard it was to classify something so unlike modern life.
Over time, the fossils were grouped into a genus named Prototaxites, but the confusion did not end. Researchers have spent roughly 150 years arguing over whether these towering cylinders were plants, fungi, algae, or something else entirely, a debate captured in modern discussions that note scientists have been scratching their heads over the organism for over 150 years. One museum summary describes Prototaxites loganii, first described in 1859 by geologist John Dawson, as a giant from the Devonian Era that has sparked more than a century of research and debate among scientists, underscoring how stubbornly this fossil has resisted easy categorization.
Giant mushroom, strange eukaryote, or lost branch of life?
As techniques improved, researchers began slicing into Prototaxites fossils and examining their internal structure, and the picture grew stranger. Some analyses found that the organism was composed of interwoven tubes, giving it a superficial resemblance to fungi, but the similarities seemed to end there. One detailed study notes that Prototaxites was made of these tube networks, but the anatomy did not match known plants or fungi preserved alongside it, leading to the suggestion that it might represent a newly discovered kind of multicellular life.
Other lines of evidence have pushed the debate in different directions. A 2026 paper on fossils from the Prototaxites specimens in the Rhynie chert reported that their chemical composition was distinct from other organisms in the same rock, and that they contained chitin, a key structural element in extant fungi, which supports the idea that they were at least fungus-like. Yet other researchers argue that, according to scientists, it may not have been a fungus either but something far stranger that disappeared from the face of the Earth hundreds of millions of years ago, a view reflected in reports that describe how Earth once hosted giant treelike forms that defy modern categories.
Recent syntheses go further, proposing that Prototaxites was an extinct lineage of multicellular terrestrial eukaryotes that does not belong to any living branch. One astrobiology-focused analysis describes Prototaxites as the first giant organism to live on land, part of an extinct lineage of multicellular terrestrial eukaryotes whose relationships have been debated for over 165 years. Popular accounts echo this sense of otherness, calling the organism the “Godzilla of” fungi and noting that it was once thought to be a conifer before internal analysis suggested a very different biology, with one summary explaining that the unusual organism, Known as Prototaxites, has mystified scientists for more than 150 years.
Reconstructing a 26‑foot tower in a 400 m year‑old world
Piecing together how Prototaxites actually looked and lived requires combining fossil measurements with reconstructions of the broader ecosystem. Reports on ancient Earth note that these organisms could reach about 26 feet in height, matching the “Standing up to 8 meters (26 feet)” descriptions and aligning with coverage of an extinct species that measured 26 feet in length and inhabited the Earth 400 m years ago, when most land plants barely reached a few inches. Visual explainers describe how there is something eerie but cool about these giant fungi that existed on Earth during the “Siluran Deo” interval, with one short video on Siluran Deo landscapes emphasizing how they dominated the surface before forests.
Fossil slabs from silica-rich rocks help fill in the fine details. One description of such a rock notes that it preserves an ancient mysterious organism known as Prototaxites as a grayish blob filled with black speckles, and adds that, however sparse the global vegetation, local areas of flourishing plants were probably enough to support the massive growth structures of However Prototaxites. Other reconstructions suggest that by forming large translocation networks, Prototaxites may have connected isolated patches of plant life across the patchy vegetated landscapes of the Early Devonian period, effectively acting as a nutrient highway between richer and poorer soils.
Why this ancient puzzle still matters
For modern scientists, Prototaxites is more than a curiosity; it is a stress test for how we classify life and reconstruct deep time. One social media explainer notes that Scientists found a fossil of a bizarre, towering life form unlike anything alive today and have struggled to figure out what it was, suggesting it is possibly the first giant organism in the history of evolution. Another museum post describes how the image of Prototaxites as a giant prehistoric mushroom has fueled ongoing research and debate among scientists, reflecting how each new analysis forces a rethink of long-held assumptions.
More from Morning Overview
