Small and affordable cars are supposed to keep ownership costs low, but some of them come with repair bills that wipe out the savings. On CarComplaints.com, the top problem for each of these models carries an average cost owners would rather not see. Here are seventeen small cars whose top problem costs a bundle, ranked from the steepest average bill.
Read next on Morning Overview: 11 engines built to run well past 200,000 miles
1. Hyundai Accent: An Oil Problem Worth $5,200

The 2016 Hyundai Accent’s top problem on its CarComplaints.com page is excessive oil consumption, with owners reporting an average cost of about $5,200 near 111,000 miles. The site rates 2016 as the Accent’s worst year.
That is a large bill for a budget subcompact. Transmission failure on the 2004 averages about $2,200, and engine stalling on a 2002 about $3,500. The 2013 drew the most complaints of any year, 42, and engine trouble is the model’s worst category.
2. Chrysler Sebring: Sludge in a Midsize Chrysler

The 2002 Chrysler Sebring’s worst problem on its complaint file is oil sludge that led to engine failure, averaging about $4,000 near 94,000 miles. The 2001 and 2002 drew 340 and 307 complaints, the most of any years.
The 2001 shows the same sludge failure at about $4,800. The Sebring’s file totals roughly 1,550 complaints, and oil sludge appears in all three of its top listed problems, which makes oil-change history the first thing to check.
3. Nissan Leaf: Brakes on an Early EV

The 2015 Nissan Leaf’s top problem on CarComplaints.com is brakes not working properly, with owners reporting an average cost of about $4,000 near 8,000 miles. The site rates 2015 as the electric hatchback’s worst year.
Dramatically reduced range in low temperatures on the 2013 also averages about $4,000, and a failure of the electric motor, inverter and main chip on the 2012 averages about $13,000. Electrical problems are its worst category.
4. Chevrolet Bolt: A Rear Axle Failure

The 2017 Chevrolet Bolt leads its CarComplaints.com record with rear axle failure, averaging about $4,000 near 37,000 miles. The 2017, the Bolt’s first year, drew the most complaints of any year.
Its most-reported issue that year was a “propulsion power reduced” warning that told owners to seek service immediately. Electrical problems are the Bolt’s worst category, and its complaint file is still small, at about 30 reports.
5. Subaru Impreza: Acceleration and Transmission Bills

The 2012 Subaru Impreza’s top problem on its complaint page is sudden unintended acceleration, with owners reporting an average cost of about $4,000 near 40,000 miles. The site rates 2012 as the worst year.
Transmission failures on the 2007 and 2006 average about $4,500 and $2,300, both reported at very low mileage. The 2008 drew the most complaints, 56, most often for a film forming on the windshield and windows.
6. Toyota Matrix: Engine Failure in a Practical Hatch

The 2003 Toyota Matrix leads its CarComplaints.com listing with engine failure, averaging about $3,400 near 103,000 miles. The site rates 2003, the model’s first year, as its worst.
Transmission failure on the 2004 averages about $2,200 near 107,000 miles. The 2009 drew the most complaints, 79, mostly for excessive oil consumption, and engine trouble is the Matrix’s worst category. The 2003 drew 42 complaints.
7. Subaru Legacy: Oil Consumption in a Subaru Sedan

The 2013 Subaru Legacy’s worst problem on its complaint record is excessive oil consumption, averaging about $3,200 near 61,000 miles. Engine failure on the 2009 averages about $5,000 near 71,000 miles.
A battery that constantly drains on the 2016 averages about $1,400. The 2015 drew the most complaints, 67, while headlights that kept burning out were the 2011’s most-reported problem.
8. Kia Rio: A Seized Engine

The 2004 Kia Rio tops its CarComplaints.com page with engine seizure, averaging about $3,200 near 79,000 miles. Engine failure on the 2013 averages about $5,800, and an engine knock on the 2014 about $6,000.
Those later figures are steep for one of the least expensive cars on the market. Engine problems are the Rio’s worst category, and the 2013 drew the most complaints, 31.
9. Hyundai Veloster: A Connecting Rod Failure

The 2013 Hyundai Veloster’s top problem on its complaint file is connecting rod failure, averaging about $3,000 near 64,000 miles. The site rates 2013 as the worst year.
Loss of power on the 2015 also averages about $3,000. The 2013 drew 57 complaints, the most of any year, though its most-reported issue was simply poor speakers. Engine problems are the model’s worst category.
10. Chrysler 300: A Clacking Engine

The 2006 Chrysler 300’s worst problem on CarComplaints.com is a loud clacking engine noise, averaging about $2,500 near 81,000 miles. Engine failure due to oil sludge on the 2006 averages about $6,000.
A blown engine on the 2010 averages about $3,500. The 2006 drew 161 complaints, the most of any year, with stalling while driving as its most-reported problem. Engine trouble is its worst category.
11. Chevrolet Aveo: Timing Belts That Snapped

The 2004 Chevrolet Aveo leads its CarComplaints.com record with timing belt failure, averaging about $2,200 near 73,000 miles. The 2005 shows the same failure at about $2,500.
A broken idler pulley on the 2005 averages about $2,000. The first-year 2004 drew 120 complaints, the most of any year, and engine trouble is the Aveo’s worst category. The 2005 drew 81 complaints.
12. Honda Insight: An Oil-Thirsty Hybrid

The 2012 Honda Insight’s top problem on its complaint page is excessive oil consumption, averaging about $2,000 near 64,000 miles. The 2012 drew 88 of the model’s roughly 160 complaints.
The 2013 shows the same problem at about $3,300, and the 2011 at about $6,000 near 87,000 miles. All three of its top problems involve oil consumption, an unwelcome cost for a car bought to save money.
13. Buick Lucerne: Broken Struts

The 2007 Buick Lucerne leads its CarComplaints.com listing with broken struts, averaging about $1,800 near 64,000 miles. The site rates 2007 as the worst year.
A melted fuse block on the 2009 averages about $500, and an engine that would not turn over on the 2008 about $700. The 2008 drew the most complaints, 41, and electrical problems are its worst category.
14. Buick Verano: A Worn-Off Finish

The 2014 Buick Verano’s top problem on its complaint record is clear coat that wore off, averaging about $1,700 near 54,000 miles. The site rates 2014 as the worst year.
The 2013 drew the most complaints, 74, and oil consumption was the 2012’s most-reported issue. Engine problems are the compact sedan’s worst category, and its file holds about 186 complaints in all.
15. Mercury Grand Marquis: An Intake Manifold Failure

The 1997 Mercury Grand Marquis tops CarComplaints.com with intake manifold failure, averaging about $1,700 near 76,000 miles. A valve that dropped through the engine of a 2007 averages about $3,300.
Headlights that did not work properly were the 2005’s most-reported issue, at about $500. The 2003 drew the most complaints, 44, and lights are the model’s worst category. Its file holds about 296 complaints.
16. Toyota Yaris: Peeling Paint

The 2008 Toyota Yaris leads its CarComplaints.com page with clear coat and paint peeling, averaging about $1,500 near 64,000 miles. The 2007 shows clear coat peeling at the same average cost.
A 2008 report of losing control at highway speed averages about $8,000. The 2007 drew the most complaints, 94, and body and paint issues are the Yaris’s worst category.
17. Acura TSX: Power Steering Failure

The 2012 Acura TSX’s worst problem on its complaint file is power steering failure, averaging about $1,500 near 69,000 miles. A “Check Power Steering” warning on the 2011 averages about $3,000.
Transmission failure on the 2004 averages about $3,000 near 102,000 miles. The 2010 and 2009 drew the most complaints, 35 and 34, mostly for excessive oil consumption. Engine trouble is its worst category.
More from Morning Overview
- A $1 billion gas plant planned for Superior, Wisconsin, has been abandoned
- Shaq spent $1.3 million on three Rolls-Royce Phantoms to prove a point to a salesman
- The Justice Department asked courts to undo approvals for three offshore wind farms, one already making power
- Over 20 trillion gallons of rain fell on the Four Corners states and Nevada in two weeks