143 homicides led the 796 deaths among fathers of one year’s Georgia newborns

Of the 130,267 babies born in Georgia in 2017, 796 had a father who died within the next five years. A Northwestern University team, led by pediatrician Craig Garfield, counted 143 of those deaths as homicides, more than any other single cause, and found that about 60 percent were preventable.

Garfield, a professor of pediatrics and medical social sciences at Northwestern’s Feinberg School of Medicine and a pediatrician at Ann and Robert H. Lurie Children’s Hospital of Chicago, says the numbers expose a gap in how health systems watch families. Maternal mortality review committees examine the deaths of mothers in the year after birth; no comparable system exists for fathers.

What the Georgia records counted

The team linked state birth certificates to state death records, following the fathers named on the certificates of all 130,267 babies born in Georgia in 2017 through 2022. In that window, 796 of those fathers died. The work appeared as “Paternal Mortality During Early Childhood” in JAMA Pediatrics, with Clarissa Simon, Chris Harrison, Michael Woods, Katy Bedjeti and John Carter as co-authors. The researchers say a national version is not currently feasible, since federal compilations of birth and death data strip out personally identifiable information, which breaks the link between a baby and a father. The team’s own PRAMS for Dads survey, which Garfield’s group created and first piloted in Georgia in 2018, grew out of the same concern that fathers’ health after a birth is rarely measured. Earth.com adds that Georgia’s identifiable linked records are what made the analysis possible.

Homicide, accidents, suicide and overdose

The cause-of-death breakdown, as reported from Northwestern’s release, runs as follows: homicide 143, accidental injury 142, suicide 102, overdose 93 and natural causes 296. Homicide edged out accidents by a single death, so the ranking is narrow, but the four non-natural categories together account for 480 deaths, or 60.3 percent by the count HealthExec published, against 37.2 percent for natural causes.

The listed causes add up to 776, not 796, and neither Northwestern’s account nor the trade coverage explains the missing 20 deaths. The 60 percent figure is therefore best read as roughly three in five of the fathers who died, rather than a precise tally of every case.

Who died is also patterned. Fathers who died were more likely to be older, non-Hispanic Black, unmarried, rural residents, or to have had a Medicaid-paid birth, while higher education, Hispanic ethnicity and Tricare coverage were associated with fewer deaths. Non-natural deaths were more common among younger fathers, and Medicaid-paid births and unmarried status were linked with higher homicide risk. These are associations found in one state’s records, and the Northwestern account does not present them as causes of the deaths.

A protective effect nobody can yet explain

The study also produced a result that cuts the other way. Among men aged 30 to 34, the death rate was 120 per 100,000 for fathers against 231 per 100,000 for men who were not fathers, and after age 20 fathers consistently had lower mortality than non-fathers, according to the Northwestern Now story. “Being a father appears to be protective in this particular group of men,” Garfield said. He also said the reason is unknown and “certainly worth further study,” as HealthExec recounted. Earth.com notes that the figures cannot prove fatherhood itself lowers risk, since healthier or more stable men may be more likely to become fathers in the first place.

The missing tracking system

Garfield’s central argument is about measurement. “That’s a huge blind spot,” he said of the lack of systems to understand how such deaths might be prevented, and he put the principle plainly, saying that what goes unmeasured cannot be changed. He added that the issue “affects thousands of children.” The researchers described the preventable deaths as a “huge, missed opportunity.”

His clinical experience shaped the concern. Working in a neonatal intensive care unit, Garfield said, he has seen families lose a father suddenly, and “in my experience, that happens more often than mothers dying.” The authors call paternal mortality a “family and public health crisis,” and argue that integrating fathers into existing maternal mortality review processes “could yield more comprehensive understanding of family health dynamics and needs,” per the HealthExec summary of the paper.

The release stops short of formal policy recommendations. Its implied next steps are for other states to analyze their own linked birth and death records, and for researchers to work toward a national system for tracking paternal deaths. The authors also note that the study covers only one state and excludes fathers who died after leaving Georgia, so the true count may differ at the margins. Coverage of the paper by HealthDay framed the finding as six in 10 deaths being homicide, unintentional injury, suicide or overdose, and Earth.com carried the same cause counts. What remains unanswered is whether other states’ records would show the same pattern, which only the kind of linkage Georgia allowed can test.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by Morning Overview editors prior to publication.

More from Morning Overview