Pickup trucks span everything from compact lifestyle haulers to heavy-duty workhorses, and Edmunds scores them all on a ten-point scale. Its ratings blend comfort, capability and value, so a modest score can still describe a very capable truck. Here are fourteen of those pickups, running from the lowest Edmunds score to the highest.
Help yourself and the planet: The Cool Down makes it easy to help yourself while helping the planet, with smart, simple changes to save more and waste less in your everyday life.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Nissan Frontier: Frontier Brings Up the Rear
Edmunds rates the 2027 Nissan Frontier last among midsize trucks at 5.6 out of 10, citing “a somewhat cramped back seat”. It is also the lowest score anywhere in this list of fourteen.
The Frontier is a straightforward midsize pickup, so shoppers who rarely carry rear passengers may care less about the criticism. Anyone planning regular crew-cab duty should test the back seat before signing. That makes it a fair pick for single drivers and couples, less so for families who often carry three adults in back.
2. Jeep Gladiator: Gladiator Trades Comfort
Edmunds rates the 2026 Jeep Gladiator 5.7 out of 10, warning of “considerable compromises” to everyday comfort. It is the only truck here with the open-air, Wrangler-style character.
That character comes at a cost in ride and refinement, which the rating reflects. Buyers who want a pickup mainly for trails and weekends can accept the tradeoff, while commuters may find it wearing. Few other pickups on this list ask owners to accept that kind of trade for the sake of capability and fun.
3. Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD: 2500HD Falls Short on Polish
Edmunds rates the 2026 Silverado 2500HD 5.9 out of 10, calling it “far less upscale than other HD pickups”. It is the first heavy-duty truck to appear in this ranking.
The score does not question the truck’s work ability so much as its cabin refinement next to rivals. Owners who buy for hauling and towing rather than luxury trim may care little about that gap. For fleet and farm buyers the rating is a reminder to compare interiors in person rather than rely on towing figures alone.
4. GMC Canyon: Canyon Pays for Polish
Edmunds rates the 2026 GMC Canyon 6.4 out of 10, saying “Only a high price keeps it from being a class leader”. That is the clearest value warning in the group.
The Canyon is the upscale midsize cousin of the Chevrolet Colorado, with a more premium feel. Shoppers should look at actual transaction prices, since the critique is about cost rather than quality. It is a reminder that a strong truck can still lose points when the sticker price asks too much.
5. Chevrolet Colorado: Colorado Sits Fourth
Edmunds rates the 2027 Chevrolet Colorado 6.5 out of 10, fourth among midsize trucks. That puts it one step ahead of the GMC Canyon on the Edmunds midsize table.
Colorado and Canyon share their basic engineering, and the rating gap between them is small. Buyers who do not need the Canyon’s upmarket touches can treat the Colorado as the simpler choice. For shoppers sorting through midsize rivals, the placement helps narrow the field to a handful of serious contenders.
6. Toyota Tacoma: Tacoma Built for Adventure
Edmunds rates the 2026 Toyota Tacoma 6.8 out of 10, calling it “a smart choice for adventuring”. The score is a notable step up from the three trucks just below it.
The Tacoma has long been a standard-bearer among midsize pickups for outdoor use. The rating suggests it earns that reputation, though it still trails two rivals in the midsize category. Buyers weighing it against the Colorado and Canyon will find the Tacoma clearly ahead on the Edmunds scale.
7. Honda Ridgeline: Ridgeline Takes Second
Edmunds rates the 2026 Honda Ridgeline 6.9 out of 10, second among midsize trucks. Only one midsize pickup in the Edmunds table scores higher.
The Ridgeline is a car-like pickup with a unibody design, unlike most trucks here. Buyers who want comfort and everyday ease rather than traditional truck toughness may find it matches their needs. Shoppers who want a family-friendly pickup with a car-like cabin may rate that ahead of bed size or towing numbers.
8. Toyota Tundra: Tundra Drinks Fuel
Edmunds rates the 2026 Toyota Tundra 7.0 out of 10, though “real-world fuel economy is disappointing”. The score lifts it into the first full-size company in this ranking.
The Tundra offers a full-size body with Toyota’s reputation attached, and the rating reflects that appeal. Owners who expect a big truck’s capability should plan on a big truck’s fuel bills. Buyers who rarely tow or haul may prefer a smaller truck to avoid paying that cost at the pump every week.
9. Ford F-250 Super Duty: F-250 Leads on Capacity
Edmunds rates the 2027 Ford F-250 Super Duty 7.0 out of 10 for “massive towing and payload capability”. It ties the Tundra and is the highest-rated heavy-duty truck among those listed.
The Super Duty is built for work, and the score puts it ahead of the Silverado 2500HD in this table. Buyers who need maximum hauling can reasonably prioritize it over softer-riding half-ton trucks. Owners rarely pick a three-quarter-ton truck for fuel economy or finesse, so the rating weighs capability above all else.
10. Ford Ranger: Ranger Wins Midsize
Edmunds rates the 2026 Ford Ranger 7.1 out of 10, the No. 1 midsize truck. It beats the Honda Ridgeline, the Toyota Tacoma and all of the other midsize competitors.
That top spot makes the Ranger the benchmark for buyers in this size class. A score above several larger pickups also shows that midsize does not have to mean compromise. Midsize buyers who want a manageable footprint without losing the benefits of a bed have a clear first stop here.
11. Ram 1500: Ram 1500 Balances Duties
Edmunds rates the 2026 Ram 1500 7.5 out of 10, with strong daily-driving manners and light towing duties. The score is higher than the Tundra’s and sits one step under the Maverick.
The score suggests the Ram suits buyers who use a pickup as a primary vehicle, not only for work. Those who need heavy towing should look at the heavy-duty options farther down the list. For many households, a half-ton truck like this one is the practical middle ground between midsize and heavy-duty pickups.
12. Ford Maverick: Maverick Keeps It Cheap
Edmunds rates the 2026 Ford Maverick 7.6 out of 10, from a $28,145 starting price. The rating sits just one tenth below the top score in this list.
The Maverick is a small pickup that brings truck utility to buyers on a tight budget. A score that high at that price gives it a clear value argument against much larger trucks. Anyone cross-shopping a used car or crossover against a truck will find this the most approachable entry on the list.
13. Hyundai Santa Cruz: Santa Cruz Feels Upscale
Edmunds rates the 2027 Hyundai Santa Cruz 7.6 out of 10, calling it “upscale and fun to drive”. It ties the Ford Maverick for second place among the fourteen.
The Santa Cruz is a compact crossover-style pickup with a more car-like personality than most trucks. Buyers who want a bed but not a big truck’s bulk will find it a natural alternative. It offers a distinct alternative to the standard body-on-frame trucks that fill most of the rest of this ranking.
14. Ford F-150: F-150 Tops the Chart
Edmunds rates the 2026 Ford F-150 7.7 out of 10, the highest of any pickup it lists, for “class-leading towing and payload”. That makes it the best of all fourteen trucks here.
The F-150 has long been a leading name in full-size pickups, and the score reinforces that standing. Buyers weighing the usual rivals will likely want to use it as the reference point. It also arrives with the broadest model range here, which helps buyers match the truck to their budget and workload.
Help yourself and the planet: Get The Cool Down →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- Two passengers died at an Ohio toll plaza, and the NTSB now wants the cash lanes shut
- Long use of a common prostate pill is tied to a higher chance of glaucoma
- Ford is recalling 223,472 F-150 pickups because the fuel tank can leak or detach
- Hybrids have 15% fewer problems than gas cars, while EVs and plug-in hybrids have about 80% more, Consumer Reports finds
