Transmission trouble has a way of surfacing right when a vehicle’s warranty runs out, and owner complaint data shows which nameplates suffer most. Rankings from the Center for Auto Safety, Consumer Reports members and recall filings put particular popular sedans and SUVs under the spotlight. Below, twelve of them are covered, each with the specific figure or failure that put it on the list.
The day in tech, in one email: TLDR is the daily newsletter with links and TLDRs of the most interesting stories in startups, tech and programming.
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
1. Ford Escape: Complaint Champion
Atop the Center for Auto Safety’s 2023 tally, the 2017 Escape stands as the most-complained-about vehicle of the year, and transmission is the leading category among the complaints filed against it. Owners of that model year put it ahead of every other vehicle in the country.
That placement matters for used-car shoppers, since a ranking built on volume of complaints flags where drivetrain trouble clusters. An Escape from this period deserves a close look at shift behavior and service history before any purchase.
2. Ford Fusion: Third Place Trouble
Ranking third on the Center for Auto Safety’s 2023 most-complained list, the 2013 Fusion draws grievances that are mostly about the transmission, according to the 2023 complaint ranking for that year.
The listing makes the midsize sedan a recurring name in discussions of shifting problems on used Fords. Buyers weighing a Fusion of that vintage gain from checking for hesitation or harsh gear changes during a test drive, and from asking for any service records that mention the transmission before agreeing on a price.
3. Chevrolet Malibu: Fourth on the List
Fourth place in the Center for Auto Safety ranking went to the 2018 Malibu, with complaints again concentrated in the transmission category.
A spot this high on a list of the entire market shows how widely the issue was reported by owners of the car. Anyone shopping for a late-model Malibu can use the ranking as a prompt to ask about transmission service records and to listen for hesitation under acceleration.
4. Jeep Cherokee: Sixth Place Shifter
The 2015 Cherokee holds sixth position on the 2023 most-complained list, and the bulk of the grievances behind that rank concern the transmission.
Compact Jeep SUVs from that period therefore sit among the most frequently reported vehicles on this particular list. Prospective owners are best served by judging how a specific example shifts on a long test drive, and by asking whether any transmission work has been performed, since a ranking describes a group of vehicles rather than any single one.
5. Chevrolet Traverse: Early Failure Zone
Consumer Reports members rank the 2013 Traverse first for transmission trouble, with problems typically showing up between 175,000 and 225,000 km, as summarized by The Car Guide’s Consumer Reports roundup.
That mileage window falls well past most warranty periods, so any repair bill would land squarely on the owner. A used Traverse approaching those distances warrants a careful inspection, along with a look at maintenance paperwork, because a ranking built on member reports describes patterns across many vehicles rather than a guaranteed outcome.
6. Nissan Altima: Runner-Up Rank
Second place on the Consumer Reports transmission-problem list belongs to the 2016 Altima, where trouble typically appears at 65,000 to 125,000 km, based on the Consumer Reports member data.
Those figures describe a window much earlier than the one for the leader on the list, which means a relatively young car can already be affected. Shoppers considering an Altima of that year may want to confirm the condition of the drivetrain at modest mileage.
7. Nissan Rogue: Third in Line
Third on the Consumer Reports list is the 2011-2012 Rogue, with problems typically arriving between 150,000 and 240,000 km, per the Car Guide transmission feature.
A range that wide suggests the timing varies a great deal from one vehicle to the next. For owners and buyers of the compact crossover, mileage alone does not settle the question, and a documented service history, along with a test drive that includes stop-and-go traffic, remains the more useful guide.
8. Ford Focus: Trouble Before 100,000
Eighth on the Consumer Reports list, the 2012-2017 Focus can show trouble as early as 50,000 to 100,000 km, according to the Consumer Reports rankings.
Compared with the figures given for the other models in that report, a start of 50,000 km is a fairly early point for symptoms to appear. A Focus from this span merits a pointed test drive and a request for any transmission repair receipts before money changes hands, particularly if the odometer is still low.
9. Jeep Grand Cherokee: Rollaway Record
Federal scrutiny of the 2014-2015 Grand Cherokee shifter produced probe PE15-030 and recall 16V-240, tied to 306 rollaway incidents, 117 crashes and 26 injuries, as SlashGear’s SUV transmission roundup details.
Separate from that rollaway matter, D-clutch failures are reported on 2021-2024 models. The pairing shows two different transmission-related problems across generations of the same nameplate, so the exact model year matters when assessing a used example, and so does confirmation that any open recall work was completed.
10. Nissan Pathfinder: Belt and Shudder
Nissan’s Pathfinder from 2013-2014 is known for CVT belt slip and shudder, and a $277.7 million class-action settlement covers 2015-2018 models, according to a SlashGear transmission report.
The settlement indicates that the trouble extended beyond the earliest years of that generation. Families looking at a used Pathfinder from this range should ask about the continuously variable transmission’s service record and check for any shuddering on the road, since a shift to cheaper parts of the market does not remove the underlying concern.
11. Ford Explorer: Axle Bolt Recall
For 2020-2022 Explorers, recall 23V675 covered 238,000 vehicles after 396 reports of broken rear-axle bolts, and SlashGear’s SUV list adds that CarComplaints logged over 1,000 NHTSA powertrain complaints.
The recall concerns a driveline part rather than the gearbox itself, yet the complaint count points to wider powertrain frustration among owners. Buyers of a recent Explorer can confirm the recall repair was completed, and can review the complaint history for the specific model year, before signing anything.
12. Chevrolet Tahoe: Lockup Recall
Recall 24V-797 covered 461,839 2021 Tahoes and related SUVs for rear-wheel lockup, with 1,888 reports, 11 road incidents and 3 injuries, as SlashGear’s SUV transmission list lays out.
The vehicle count is the figure that stands out, though the incident numbers show how few reports turned into road events. Owners of a 2021 Tahoe can check a vehicle’s identification number against the recall to confirm that the repair was done, and shoppers can request proof of it.
The day in tech, in one email: Get TLDR →
We may earn a commission if you sign up.
More from Morning Overview
- The FBI told the rest of ShinyHunters to surrender after a 24-year-old was arrested
- Two passengers died at an Ohio toll plaza, and the NTSB now wants the cash lanes shut
- Long use of a common prostate pill is tied to a higher chance of glaucoma
- Ford is recalling 223,472 F-150 pickups because the fuel tank can leak or detach
