Far below the reach of sunlight, in water cold enough to freeze most life in its tracks, scientists have found oxygen being made in the dark. At more than 13,000 feet beneath the Pacific, where no plants or algae can survive, the seafloor itself appears to be splitting seawater and releasing fresh O₂ into the abyss. The discovery hints at a hidden planetary life-support system that operates without photosynthesis and forces a rethink of how oceans, and perhaps other worlds, stay habitable.
Instead of forests or phytoplankton, the key players are potato sized lumps of metal scattered across the deep seabed. These polymetallic nodules behave like tiny batteries, generating enough voltage to tear apart water molecules and create what researchers are calling “dark oxygen.” The finding is scientifically thrilling, but it also collides head on with industrial plans to mine those same nodules for electric vehicle metals.
From faulty sensor scare to “dark oxygen” shock
The story began with a puzzle. While monitoring the deep Pacific seafloor, Scientists detected oxygen levels rising more than 13,000 feet below the surface, in a region where sunlight never penetrates and photosynthetic life is absent. At first, the team suspected a glitch, the kind of mundane equipment failure that often haunts deep sea expeditions. Yet repeated measurements kept pointing to the same improbable result, suggesting that something on or in the seabed was actively producing oxygen in total darkness.
To probe the mystery, researchers turned to careful Sampling the seafloor, collecting water and sediment around the metallic nodules that carpet parts of the abyss. Lead scientist Andrew Sweetman and colleagues saw that oxygen spikes were tightly linked to these nodules, not to drifting plankton or currents from the surface. The pattern matched a growing body of work suggesting that the deep ocean is not just a passive sink for surface oxygen, but a place where new O₂ can be generated in situ, in defiance of long held assumptions about how Earth’s atmosphere is maintained.
Metallic “geobatteries” that split seawater
The key to the phenomenon lies inside the nodules themselves. These polymetallic clumps, rich in manganese, nickel, cobalt and other elements, appear to act as Hidden “geobatteries,” with different minerals creating natural electrical potentials across their surfaces. Voltage measurements on individual nodules showed that they carry as much as 0.95 volts, a result described as “Amazingly” high by Sweetman, given that an AA battery carries about 1.5 volts. When multiple nodules sit together, their combined potential rises even further, behaving like a cluster of wired cells on the seabed.
That electrical charge is enough to split Seawater into hydrogen and oxygen, a process that in the lab requires about 1.5 volts and underpins technologies from hydrogen fuel production to metal refining. In the deep Pacific, the nodules’ surfaces provide the electrodes, the surrounding brine supplies the molecules, and the natural voltage does the work. Experiments showed that when nodules were immersed in salt water, they generated oxygen without any light, confirming that the same reaction could be happening continuously on the ocean floor. When several nodules were linked, 1.5 volts or more were reached, like a string of batteries powering a hidden electrochemical factory.
Rethinking who makes Earth’s oxygen
For generations, schoolbooks have taught that almost all of Earth’s oxygen comes from photosynthetic organisms at the surface, especially marine plants and algae. The new work does not overturn that basic picture, but it does show that the deep ocean contributes in ways scientists had not appreciated. A research summary noted that the findings challenge the idea that only plants and algae generate Earth’s oxygen, by revealing a parallel, non biological pathway operating in the dark. The amounts of O₂ produced around each nodule are small and quickly consumed by nearby microbes and animals, but across vast nodule fields the cumulative effect could be significant for local ecosystems.
That is why some Scientists and commentators have started to talk about “dark oxygen” as a missing piece in the global oxygen budget. One analysis argued that the deep sea may be “pumping” oxygen from its abyss, providing an alternative production mechanism that could have helped life persist before photosynthesis evolved, and might still buffer marine environments today. That perspective, laid out in detail by researchers examining how the oceans could sustain life without sunlight, suggests that the seafloor’s electrochemical activity is not a curiosity but a fundamental part of how the planet breathes.
Clues to life’s origins and to oceans on other worlds
The discovery also reaches far beyond Earth’s present day climate system. The nodules sit about 13,000 feet, or roughly 4,000 m, below the waves, in conditions of crushing pressure, near freezing temperatures and perpetual darkness. Those conditions, one group of scientists noted, are analogous to environments expected in subsurface oceans on icy moons and dwarf planets. A separate analysis argued that such deep sea settings could illuminate where life began on Earth, and how it might have persisted before the rise of photosynthesis, by relying on chemical energy and non biological oxygen sources.
That logic naturally extends to other worlds. Planetary scientists already suspect that Pluto hides a water ocean beneath its ice, similar to those on Jupiter’s moon Europa and Saturn’s moon Enceladus. If metallic minerals in those alien oceans generate electricity in the same way as Earth’s nodules, they could also split water and create oxygen rich microhabitats, even without sunlight. Researchers at one university framed the deep sea findings as a template for thinking about extraterrestrial life, arguing that the combination of depth, pressure and aquatic chemistry on Earth provides a natural laboratory for understanding how habitable niches might arise elsewhere in the solar system.
Deep sea mining collides with a hidden life support system
The scientific excitement comes with an uncomfortable twist. The same polymetallic nodules that behave like geobatteries are also coveted as a source of nickel, cobalt and other metals for electric vehicles and renewable energy infrastructure. An international team reported that these potato shaped nodules lie thousands of feet below the surface of the Pacific, in areas now being surveyed by companies that hope to vacuum them up at industrial scale. One children’s science explainer even showed images from an ROV called KIEL 6000, deployed from the research vessel SONNE, to illustrate how the nodules sit on the seabed like scattered batteries creating oxygen from salt water.
Environmental advocates warn that stripping or burying these nodules could smother the very process that produces dark oxygen. One analysis noted that Scientists fear that smothering or removing nodules through deep sea mining would alter seafloor oxygen production, with knock on effects for carbon cycling at such depths. Another commentary argued that if polymetallic nodules are crucial to oceanic oxygen production, extracting them could have profound and irreversible consequences, a risk we cannot afford to take. Even some of the scientists involved have pointed out that the industry which helped sponsor the research now faces evidence that its target resource may be sustaining deep sea life in ways regulators never anticipated.
More from Morning Overview