When it comes to SUVs, not all are created equal in the eyes of mechanics. Some models are notorious for their challenging repair issues, earning them the dreaded label of “unfixable.” Whether it’s due to design flaws, expensive parts, or simply unreliable performance, certain SUVs have left many drivers and mechanics frustrated. Here’s a closer look at 12 SUVs that have been called “unfixable” by the experts.
Ford Explorer (2011-2015)
The Ford Explorer, particularly those manufactured between 2011 and 2015, has been a frequent topic of discussion among mechanics. Known for its problematic transmission and power transfer unit issues, the Explorer often leaves drivers stranded. These models have a reputation for their costly repairs that sometimes exceed the vehicle’s value, making them a tough sell for anyone looking to maintain a reliable ride.
One common complaint is the transmission failure, which can be a nightmare to diagnose and fix. Many owners have reported the need for a full transmission replacement, a repair that can run into thousands of dollars.
Jeep Grand Cherokee (2014-2019)
The Jeep Grand Cherokee has faced its share of criticism, particularly the models from 2014 to 2019. These vehicles are often plagued by electrical issues and engine problems that can stump even experienced mechanics. The cost and complexity of these repairs often lead to the vehicle being labeled as “unfixable.”
Electrical gremlins, such as faulty wiring and malfunctioning infotainment systems, are common complaints. The cost of troubleshooting and fixing these issues can quickly add up, leaving owners frustrated and mechanics bewildered.
Land Rover Discovery (2017-2020)
Land Rover Discovery models from 2017 to 2020 have a reputation for being exceptionally difficult to repair. These SUVs are known for their complex electronic systems and frequent engine issues, which can be both time-consuming and expensive to address. The cost of repairs often deters owners from attempting fixes, earning the Discovery its unfixable status.
For instance, the sophisticated air suspension system has been known to fail, requiring specialized knowledge and tools to repair. The complexity of these systems often means that even minor issues can lead to significant repair bills.
Chevrolet Traverse (2009-2012)
The Chevrolet Traverse, especially those produced between 2009 and 2012, is infamous for its engine and transmission woes. Many owners have reported premature engine failure, which can be a costly endeavor to rectify. Mechanics are often hesitant to take on such repairs due to the extensive labor involved and the high chance of repeat issues.
Aside from engine troubles, the Traverse is also known for its problematic timing chains. Replacing these can be a labor-intensive process, often leading mechanics to recommend trading in the vehicle instead of attempting repairs.
Dodge Journey (2009-2015)
The Dodge Journey has been on the receiving end of many complaints, particularly models from 2009 to 2015. Known for its frequent brake and electrical system failures, this SUV is often deemed unfixable by mechanics. The cost of repairs, combined with the vehicle’s depreciating value, makes it an unattractive option for many drivers.
Brake issues, such as premature wear and rotor warping, are common. Additionally, the electrical system can be a source of frustration, with many owners experiencing issues with the vehicle’s computer system and dashboard displays.
Nissan Pathfinder (2013-2016)
Nissan Pathfinders from 2013 to 2016 are well-known among mechanics for their transmission and cooling system issues. These problems often lead to expensive repairs that are not always successful, resulting in the SUV being labeled as unfixable by many.
The Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT) is a particular pain point, with many drivers experiencing shuddering and slipping. Repairs can be costly, and many mechanics are wary of the reliability of replacement parts.
GMC Acadia (2010-2013)
The GMC Acadia, especially the 2010-2013 models, is notorious for its electrical and powertrain issues. Mechanics often find these vehicles challenging to repair due to the complexity and cost of necessary parts and labor.
Electrical system failures, such as issues with the power windows and door locks, are common complaints. These problems can be difficult to diagnose and repair, often leading to high repair bills that make the vehicle difficult to justify keeping.
Volkswagen Touareg (2011-2014)
Volkswagen Touareg models from 2011 to 2014 are often considered unfixable due to their complex mechanical and electronic systems. Known for their frequent engine and electrical issues, these SUVs can be a nightmare for mechanics to repair.
The cost of parts and the specialized knowledge required for repairs often exceed the vehicle’s value. For example, the engine management system is known to be problematic, leading to costly and time-consuming repairs.
BMW X5 (2010-2013)
The BMW X5, particularly models from 2010 to 2013, is infamous for its high maintenance costs and complex repair needs. Frequent issues with the suspension and electrical systems make these vehicles a challenge for even the most skilled mechanics.
The air suspension system, for instance, is a common failure point that can be expensive to fix. Electrical problems, such as faulty sensors and failing control modules, can also contribute to the X5’s unfixable reputation.
Mercedes-Benz GL-Class (2007-2012)
Mercedes-Benz GL-Class models from 2007 to 2012 often earn the unfixable label due to their complex engineering and high-cost repairs. These luxury SUVs are known for their air suspension and engine problems, both of which can be costly and time-consuming to address.
Air suspension failures are common, requiring specialized tools and knowledge for repairs. The cost of parts alone can be prohibitive, leading many owners to reconsider the viability of keeping these vehicles long-term.
Cadillac SRX (2010-2015)
Cadillac SRX models from 2010 to 2015 are frequently cited as unfixable due to their persistent engine and transmission issues. Mechanics often find these repairs to be costly and complex, leading to frequent calls for vehicle replacement rather than repair.
Engine problems, such as oil consumption and timing chain failures, are common complaints. The high cost of these repairs often outweighs the vehicle’s value, leaving many owners with the difficult decision of whether to keep or sell their SUV.
Mitsubishi Outlander (2014-2017)
The Mitsubishi Outlander, particularly from 2014 to 2017, is often labeled as unfixable due to its transmission and electrical issues. These problems can be challenging for mechanics to resolve, leading to high repair costs that many owners find prohibitive.
Transmission failures, such as those involving the CVT, are a frequent complaint. The complexity of these systems can make repairs difficult, leading many mechanics to recommend selling the vehicle instead of attempting a fix. Many owners have shared their experiences on platforms like Quora, illustrating the challenges of owning these SUVs.