Recent research is challenging the long-held view that Neanderthals were strictly carnivorous, revealing evidence of a more diverse diet that included plant intake. This builds on earlier studies that suggested Neanderthals survived the Ice Age by consuming rotting meat and maggots, and that their heavy reliance on meat may have contributed to their extinction.
Evidence from Dental and Gut Analysis
Microscopic calculus on Neanderthal teeth has revealed starch grains and plant fibers, suggesting that cooked vegetables were part of their diet. This evidence, detailed in a 2014 MIT study, counters the “super-carnivore” label often associated with Neanderthals. Isotopic evidence from dental plaque further supports this, showing consumption of tubers, nuts, and grasses alongside meat, indicating a broader dietary diversity in Eurasian sites.
Zinc Isotope Insights into Carnivory
Zinc ratios in Neanderthal bones from sites like Spy Cave in Belgium show levels akin to top predators like wolves, according to a 2022 Sapiens report. These ratios, when compared to modern herbivores and omnivores, underscore the Neanderthals’ extreme focus on meat, with figures indicating 80-90% animal protein intake. Such heavy carnivory, without significant plant buffering, may have led to nutritional imbalances during environmental shifts.
Adaptations to Rotten Meat Consumption
Neanderthals had dental adaptations like robust molars suited for tough, decayed tissues, supporting the likelihood of eating rotten meat. This is further backed by a 2018 Eos article that discussed bacterial profiles in Neanderthal microbiomes that align with scavenging spoiled carcasses, enabling survival in harsh conditions. Experimental recreations have also shown that Neanderthals could safely ingest partially decomposed animal matter without severe illness.
Role of Maggots and Carrion in Ice Age Survival
A hypothesis from ZME Science suggests that during the Ice Age, maggot-infested carrion provided essential fats and proteins to Neanderthals. Paleoenvironmental data from glacial periods around 40,000 years ago show that frozen landscapes limited fresh kills, pushing reliance on fermented or insect-laden remains. This strategy is linked to genetic evidence of enhanced detoxification enzymes in Neanderthals, aiding digestion of putrid foods.
Implications for Neanderthal Extinction
The findings on zinc-heavy diets could be linked to potential health issues like vitamin C deficiencies from insufficient plant intake. A Live Science overview suggests that dietary inflexibility compared to early modern humans, who incorporated more varied foods, could have contributed to the Neanderthals’ extinction. Archaeological sites like Vindija Cave in Croatia show meat dominance but also hints of overlooked non-meat resources.
Recent Reassessments of Dietary Diversity
New genomic and residue analyses indicate occasional seafood and fungi intake by Neanderthals, according to the same Live Science article. This, along with the 2014 MIT evidence of fire-cooked plants, argues for opportunistic vegetarianism in warmer interglacial phases. However, debates continue on whether these non-meat elements were supplemental or culturally significant, drawing from multi-site data across the Mediterranean and Levant.
More from MorningOverview