The Tesla Cybertruck has finally secured the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s coveted Top Safety Pick and Top Safety Pick+ badges, a milestone that once looked out of reach for the angular electric pickup. After early criticism of its lighting and pedestrian protection, a series of targeted tweaks has turned the truck from a safety question mark into one of the highest rated large pickups on the road. The shift underscores how quickly a polarizing design can be reshaped when regulators, engineers and owners all push in the same direction.
For Tesla, the turnaround is more than a bragging right. The Cybertruck’s new status as a Top Safety Pick+ contender in the United States gives the company a powerful answer to long‑running doubts about whether a stainless steel wedge could ever behave like a conventional crumple‑zone truck in a crash. It also exposes a widening gap between American and European regulators, who are looking at the same vehicle and reaching very different conclusions about what “safe” should mean in the EV era.
From crash‑test curiosity to Top Safety Pick+
The Cybertruck’s journey to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety podium started with skepticism about whether its rigid structure and sharp lines could ever play nicely with modern crash standards. Early on, the truck was treated as a rolling experiment in how far a manufacturer could push design without sacrificing survivability for occupants and people outside the vehicle. That experiment has now produced a clear result, with the Cybertruck earning an IIHS Top Safety Pick and then climbing to the Top Safety Pick+ tier after a round of refinements that addressed its weakest points.
Reports on the latest test cycle describe the Cybertruck as nailing the core crash evaluations while initially stumbling on lighting performance, a combination that kept it just shy of the top award. Once those lighting issues were addressed, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety moved the truck into the Top Safety Pick+ column, confirming that the structural concept could deliver strong protection as long as the details were tuned to match the test protocol. The result is a rare case of a radical design that now carries the same safety label as some of the most conservative pickups on sale.
How the Cybertruck outperformed rival pickups
What makes the Cybertruck’s new status more striking is that it did not simply clear the bar, it outperformed other large pickups in several key categories. In the latest round of evaluations, the Tesla Cybertruck posted stronger results than every other pickup tested, particularly in crashworthiness and head restraint performance, areas where heavy trucks often struggle because of their mass and ride height. The truck’s battery‑in‑floor layout and stiff passenger cell appear to have helped it manage crash forces in a way that spreads energy around the cabin instead of into it.
One analysis notes that the Tesla Cybertruck outperformed all other pickups in the 2025 IIHS Top Safety Pick competition, with particularly strong scores in crash categories and, after updates, for its headlights. That performance places it in rare company among large crew cab trucks, a segment where weight and height can complicate both crash dynamics and visibility. The Cybertruck’s showing suggests that electric platforms, when engineered carefully, can turn those same attributes into safety advantages.
The specific tweaks that unlocked IIHS approval
The leap from “almost there” to Top Safety Pick+ did not come from a wholesale redesign, but from a series of targeted changes that addressed the Cybertruck’s most glaring weaknesses. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s early feedback highlighted poor headlight performance and concerns about how the truck’s front end interacted with pedestrians and smaller vehicles. Tesla responded by revising the lighting hardware and software, improving beam pattern and intensity so that the truck could illuminate the road without creating excessive glare for oncoming traffic.
Coverage of the upgrade process describes how Tesla Updated The Cybertruck To Finally Earn IIHS approval by focusing on those lighting and front‑impact details rather than rethinking the entire vehicle. Earlier, owners on enthusiast forums had flagged that the truck’s headlights received a “Poor” rating, with one Well‑known member named Coolhandz calling the initial results “Interesting” and pointing directly to the headlight score. That kind of feedback loop, from lab to forum and back to the automaker’s engineering team, helped turn a single weak grade into a focused fix that unlocked the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s seal of approval.
Why only some Cybertrucks qualify for the badge
Despite the celebratory headlines, not every Cybertruck on the road carries the same safety designation. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s Top Safety Pick criteria apply to specific configurations and build periods, and the Cybertruck is no exception. Only certain crew cab versions built after a defined production change point meet the full standard, which means early adopters are driving trucks that do not technically qualify for the new label even if they look identical from the curb.
According to the award documentation, the safety designation applies only to Cybertruck crew cab pickup models manufactured after April 2025, when structural and restraint updates improved protection in driver‑side and passenger‑side frontal crashes. That cutoff reflects how the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety tracks running changes, and it also highlights a growing reality in the EV world: two vehicles with the same badge and body style can have meaningfully different safety performance depending on when they rolled off the line.
How the Cybertruck stacks up in the 2025 IIHS field
Context matters for any award, and the Cybertruck’s new status looks even more significant when set against the broader 2025 Top Safety Pick landscape. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety tightened its criteria again, adding tougher side‑impact tests and stricter requirements for pedestrian crash avoidance systems. In that environment, fewer vehicles qualify at all, and only a small subset reach the Top Safety Pick+ tier that now includes Tesla’s angular truck.
The organization’s own rundown of 2025 Top Safety Pick award winners notes that the resource includes information about additional tests that are not yet part of the formal criteria, underscoring how the bar keeps moving. Within that shifting field, the Cybertruck stands out as one of only two large pickups to secure a Top Safety Pick for 2025, a detail that is highlighted in separate reporting on the Top Safety Pick for the Cybertruck. The combination of a shrinking award pool and a standout performance gives Tesla a rare talking point in a segment long dominated by legacy truck brands.
Record‑setting safety claims and what they really mean
Tesla and its supporters have been quick to frame the Cybertruck’s performance as record‑setting, and there is some substance behind that marketing. Analyses of the latest results describe how the Tesla Cybertruck sets a safety record with its Top Safety Pick+ rating, positioning it as a benchmark for electric pickups and a proof point that unconventional design can deliver conventional safety outcomes. The claim rests on the truck’s combination of crash test scores, structural integrity and active safety systems, which together push it to the top of the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s charts for its class.
One detailed breakdown of the Tesla Cybertruck Sets Safety Record With IIHS Top Safety Pick notes that The Tesla Cybertruck has always been pitched as a vehicle that combines futuristic styling with real protection on the road, and the new rating finally aligns the marketing with independent data. Another report on how The Tesla Cybertruck was awarded a Top Safety Pick by the Insur Institute for Highway Safety emphasizes that the recognition strengthens Tesla’s position in the competitive electric vehicle market. Taken together, the record language is less about a single number and more about the Cybertruck’s status as a reference point for future electric trucks.
The lingering European problem
While the Cybertruck’s American safety story now reads like a redemption arc, the picture in Europe is far more complicated. Regulators and safety advocates there have raised concerns about the truck’s stiff stainless steel body, high front end and potential impact on pedestrians and cyclists. Those worries have translated into a much colder reception from European authorities, who are not prepared to accept the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s verdict as a global green light.
Reporting on the latest award makes clear that the Cybertruck finally earns top safety badge in the United States, but that will not fly in Europe, where different test protocols and regulatory philosophies put more weight on how a vehicle treats people outside the cabin. The split underscores a growing divergence between American and European safety regimes, with the same vehicle celebrated on one continent and treated as a potential hazard on another. For Tesla, that means the Cybertruck’s IIHS success is a powerful domestic story but not a passport to every market it might want to enter.
What the Cybertruck’s badge says about Tesla’s safety culture
The Cybertruck’s path to Top Safety Pick+ status also offers a window into how Tesla responds to external pressure. Earlier in the truck’s life, the company faced criticism over its approach to driver assistance and crash testing, including references back to a 2019 Autopilot‑related fatal crash that still shapes perceptions of its safety culture. The new award does not erase that history, but it does show that Tesla can and will rework hardware and software when a respected testing body draws a clear line between “good” and “not good enough.”
In that sense, the Cybertruck’s evolution from poor headlight scores to a full Top Safety Pick+ rating is as much about process as product. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s feedback, the owner community’s reaction and the company’s willingness to push updates all combined to move the truck into the top tier. For buyers who have watched the saga unfold, the new badge is a signal that Tesla’s boldest design yet can also be its safest, at least within the parameters set by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety and the current 2025 Top Safety Pick framework.
More from MorningOverview