Look across the night sky and it is easy to think the universe is mostly stars, galaxies and the planets that orbit them. Yet when astronomers tally up the amount of ordinary, or “baryonic,” matter that should exist according to cosmology, most of it is missing from those bright islands of light. The bulk of the atoms that make up normal matter turn out to be hiding in far more diffuse, harder to see structures that stretch between galaxies.
Over the past few years, a combination of precision cosmology, X-ray observations and exotic radio signals has converged on a striking picture. I now have to think of galaxies not as self-contained systems, but as knots in a vast, nearly invisible web of gas where roughly three quarters of normal matter resides, and where the solution to the missing matter puzzle finally comes into focus.
What astronomers mean by “normal matter”
When cosmologists talk about missing matter, they are not referring to dark matter or dark energy, which are even more mysterious and do not consist of atoms. “Normal matter” is the familiar stuff built from protons, neutrons and electrons, collectively known as baryons, that form stars, planets, gas and dust. Measurements of the early universe, especially of the cosmic microwave background and the abundance of light elements, set a precise expectation for how many of these baryons should exist across all of space.
The problem is that when I add up everything that telescopes can see directly inside galaxies, from blazing stars to cold molecular clouds, the total falls far short of that prediction. Detailed inventories of stellar populations and interstellar gas consistently come up missing a large fraction of the expected baryons, which is why astronomers framed a “missing baryon problem” in the first place. The gap forced researchers to look beyond the bright disks and halos of galaxies and ask where the rest of the atomic matter could be hiding.
Why galaxies hold only a minority of the atoms
Galaxies are visually dominant, but they are not where most of the universe’s atoms live. Careful accounting shows that stars, planets and the dense gas inside galaxies make up only a small slice of the total baryon budget, with the majority located elsewhere. In the new work that has sharpened this picture, researchers explicitly separate the matter bound up in galaxies from the much larger reservoir in the space between them, revealing that the familiar structures we see through optical telescopes are only the tip of the iceberg.
One recent analysis, described in detail for a general audience, emphasizes that the census of baryons inside galaxies, including both hot plasma and cold gas, still leaves a large deficit compared with cosmological expectations, which points directly to a dominant component outside galactic boundaries that had been hard to detect. I find it striking that even after counting every star and cloud that modern instruments can resolve, the numbers only make sense once this hidden component is included, confirming that galaxies are minor players in the overall distribution of normal matter.
The intergalactic medium and the cosmic web
The missing atoms are not lost, they are spread through the intergalactic medium, a tenuous plasma that threads the universe in a vast network of filaments and nodes known as the cosmic web. Gravity pulls matter into these filaments over billions of years, so galaxies tend to form where the strands intersect, while most of the gas remains stretched along the connecting threads. This web-like structure was predicted in simulations long before it could be mapped in detail, but only recently have observations caught up enough to show that it really does contain the bulk of the baryons.
One synthesis of current research explains that the solution to the missing baryon puzzle lies in recognizing how this intergalactic gas traces the large scale structure of the cosmic web, rather than clustering tightly inside galaxies. In that view, galaxies are simply the densest knots in a much larger, filamentary scaffold of matter. Once I adopt that mental image, the idea that most atoms float between galaxies instead of inside them feels less like a paradox and more like a natural outcome of cosmic evolution.
How hot, thin gas hides in plain sight
Finding this intergalactic medium is difficult because it is both extremely hot and extremely diffuse. The gas between galaxies can reach temperatures of millions of degrees, which means it emits primarily in high energy X-rays rather than visible light. At the same time, its density is so low that even this X-ray glow is faint, spread over enormous volumes of space, and easily drowned out by brighter sources like galaxy clusters and active black holes.
Researchers who specialize in this field point out that the intergalactic medium’s combination of high temperature and low density makes it almost invisible to traditional telescopes, especially those tuned to optical wavelengths. One detailed explanation notes that this hot plasma is best traced at very short X-ray wavelengths, where only the most sensitive instruments can pick up its signal, which is why it remained elusive for so long. When I consider how thin this gas is, with only a few atoms in a volume the size of a room, it becomes clear why the bulk of normal matter could hide there without leaving an obvious mark on ordinary images of the sky.
Fast radio bursts as a new kind of cosmic probe
The breakthrough in locating the missing baryons has come from an unexpected tool, fast radio bursts, or FRBs, which are millisecond flashes of radio waves from distant galaxies. As these pulses travel through space, free electrons in the intergalactic medium slow down the lower frequency components more than the higher ones, a dispersive effect that encodes the total number of electrons along the line of sight. By measuring this dispersion for FRBs at known distances, astronomers can effectively weigh how much ionized gas lies between us and the source.
Earlier this year, a team led by astronomers at the Harvard and Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics and Caltech used this technique to show that more than half of the universe’s normal matter is located in diffuse clouds of gas that had previously been invisible to telescopes. Their analysis of FRB signals revealed that these clouds, which are part of the intergalactic medium, account for a large share of the missing baryons, turning the bursts into a kind of intergalactic GPS for matter. I find it remarkable that such brief, distant flashes can map out the hidden gas with enough precision to transform a long standing cosmological puzzle into a solvable measurement problem, as described in detail in their results.
A “GPS” for the intergalactic medium
Building on that insight, researchers have started to describe FRBs as a kind of navigation system for the intergalactic medium, because each burst provides a precise measurement of how much ionized gas it has passed through. Liam Connor, a CfA astronomer who has worked on this problem, framed the decades old missing baryon problem as a question not of existence but of location, since cosmology already told us the matter had to be there. By turning FRBs into calibrated distance markers, his team could assign a “home address” to the missing matter along specific sightlines through the cosmic web.
In their work, Connor and colleagues showed that combining the dispersion of FRBs with independent distance estimates allows them to reconstruct the density of electrons in the intergalactic medium, effectively mapping where the baryons reside between galaxies. This approach has been described as a new GPS for the intergalactic medium, because it lets astronomers chart the three dimensional distribution of gas that was previously inferred only in broad strokes. I see this as a shift from asking whether the missing matter exists to using FRBs as a routine tool to track it, a change captured in detail in the description of Liam Connor and his co authors’ work.
Counting up the atoms between galaxies
Independent of FRBs, other observational campaigns have tried to measure directly how much baryonic matter lies between galaxies by looking for its faint X-ray and ultraviolet signatures. One major effort combined multiple techniques and concluded that the vast majority of normal matter is indeed in the intergalactic medium rather than in stars or galactic gas. The results revealed that 76 percent of the universe’s normal matter lies in the space between galaxies, a figure that finally matches what cosmology predicts.
That specific number, 76 percent, is important because it closes the accounting gap that had persisted for decades. When I compare it with the fraction of baryons found in stars, cold gas and hot halos inside galaxies, the picture that emerges is unambiguous, most atoms are floating in the intergalactic medium, not locked into luminous structures. This agreement between independent methods, from X-ray observations to FRB dispersion, strengthens the case that the missing baryon problem has largely been solved, even if the detailed physics of how that gas is heated and distributed are still being worked out.
Why ordinary telescopes missed most of the matter
One reason the missing matter problem lasted so long is that traditional optical telescopes are poorly suited to detecting the intergalactic medium. When I look between galaxies with a standard telescope, I mostly see darkness, because the gas there is too thin to emit or absorb much visible light. Even large observatories that can pick up faint galaxies struggle to see the diffuse glow of hot plasma that stretches across millions of light years, especially when that glow is spread over a wide area of the sky.
A detailed explainer notes that looking between galaxies requires instruments that can detect extremely faint signals at wavelengths smaller than most optical telescopes can handle, particularly in the X-ray and ultraviolet bands. One account of this challenge emphasizes that the relevant structures are smaller than most optical telescopes are designed to resolve, which is why they remained hidden in plain sight until more specialized instruments and techniques were brought to bear, a point underscored in the description of how looking between galaxies exposes these subtle features. Once I factor in these observational limits, it becomes less surprising that the majority of baryons eluded direct detection for so long.
Piecing together the full baryon census
To understand where all the normal matter resides, astronomers have had to combine multiple lines of evidence, each sensitive to a different phase of gas. One synthesis aimed at non specialists explains how the new study divides baryons into components inside galaxies, such as stars and cold gas, and those in the intergalactic medium, including both hot and warm plasma. By carefully modeling how each of these components contributes to observable signals, the researchers can reconstruct a complete baryon census that finally matches the expectations from cosmology.
In that work, the authors show that once the hot and cold gas within galaxies is properly accounted for, the remaining baryons must be in the intergalactic medium, and they use a combination of X-ray data and simulations to estimate its distribution. A detailed summary of the study notes that the analysis explicitly includes hot gas, warm plasma and cold gas within galaxies, then compares the total to the cosmological baryon density, a process described in the explanation of how hot and cold gas within galaxies are treated. I find this layered approach compelling because it does not rely on any single observation, instead it cross checks multiple datasets until the numbers line up.
The extreme conditions of the intergalactic medium
Even after its existence is confirmed, the intergalactic medium remains a harsh and exotic environment compared with the relatively dense regions inside galaxies. The gas is highly ionized, with electrons stripped from atoms by intense ultraviolet and X-ray radiation, and its temperature of millions of degrees means that it behaves more like a plasma than a neutral gas. These conditions influence how galaxies grow, because gas must cool and condense out of this hot medium before it can fall into galactic halos and form new stars.
One detailed discussion of the intergalactic medium stresses that its very high temperature makes it difficult to observe directly, since it emits primarily at very short X-ray wavelengths that only specialized space based observatories can detect. The same explanation notes that mapping this hot plasma requires instruments capable of seeing the universe at very short X-ray wavelengths, which are far beyond the reach of ground based optical telescopes, as described in the account of how the intergalactic medium is very hot. When I think about these extreme conditions, it becomes clear that solving the missing matter problem is not just about counting atoms, it is also about understanding how this hot plasma shapes the life cycle of galaxies over cosmic time.
From cosmic puzzle to precision science
For decades, the missing baryon problem was a nagging inconsistency in an otherwise successful cosmological model, a reminder that even basic questions like “where are the atoms” did not have a complete answer. The convergence of FRB measurements, X-ray observations and detailed simulations has transformed that puzzle into a more precise science of mapping the intergalactic medium. I now see the focus shifting from whether the missing matter exists to how it is structured, how it flows along the cosmic web and how it interacts with galaxies and black holes.
One accessible overview of the field notes that most normal matter in the universe is not found in planets, stars or galaxies, but is instead distributed through the intergalactic medium that traces the cosmic web, a point that has been reinforced in multiple venues, including a piece that can be republished under a Creative Commons license by Dec and DOI and another that highlights how Dec and Most of the baryons reside outside galaxies. As these results settle in, the missing matter story becomes less about absence and more about perspective, a reminder that the universe is dominated not by the bright objects that first drew our attention, but by the vast, nearly invisible structures that connect them.
More from MorningOverview