Recent analysis of rock art in a Spanish cave has revealed that Neanderthals were creating abstract images and engravings at least 64,000 years ago, a time before modern humans had even arrived in Europe. This discovery, which includes ladder-like motifs and hand stencils, challenges previous assumptions about Neanderthal artistic capabilities and suggests that the timeline of their symbolic behavior could be pushed back by tens of thousands of years.
Discovery of the Cave Art
In 2018, a significant discovery was made in Spain’s La Pasiega cave. Red ochre disk shapes, ladder-like figures, and scalariform engravings were found, and through stratigraphic evidence, their origin was confirmed to be non-modern human. The cave’s Panel of the Hand was particularly intriguing, featuring hand stencils and geometric shapes that radiometric dating placed at a minimum of 64,000 years old. The cave, located in the remote region of Cantabria, Spain, was excavated by teams from the University of Bordeaux and Centro Nacional de Investigación sobre la Evolución Humana, who identified the artifacts amid layers indicative of Neanderthal occupation (National Geographic).
Dating Techniques Employed
The age of the images was determined using uranium-thorium dating, a method applied to carbonate crusts over the artwork. This technique yielded ages of 64,000 to 66,500 years for the images in La Pasiega cave. Further supporting the Neanderthal authorship, optically stimulated luminescence corroborated the timeline, ruling out any human interference post-40,000 years. Researchers have noted that “the images could be much older,” indicating that ongoing analysis might extend the dates further back (Live Science).
Evidence Linking Art to Neanderthals
Genetic and fossil evidence from the site shows an exclusive Neanderthal presence in Europe until around 40,000 years ago, making them the only plausible creators of the 64,000-year-old art. Archaeological consensus supports the absence of Homo sapiens in Western Europe prior to 45,000 years ago, attributing the cave art solely to Neanderthals. Further evidence comes from tool and bone artifacts from the same layers, including Levallois stone tools typical of Neanderthal technology, found alongside the engravings (Haaretz).
Implications for Neanderthal Cognition
The abstract designs, such as the ladder motif dated to at least 64,000 years ago, suggest advanced symbolic thinking and cultural complexity in Neanderthals. These findings draw parallels with later Homo sapiens art, indicating that Neanderthals may have had similar capacities for representation and ritual. This challenges the long-held view of Neanderthals as primitive and reshapes our understanding of their cognitive abilities. Moreover, this discovery pushes back evidence of artistic expression by over 20,000 years from previous estimates.
Debates and Alternative Theories
Despite the compelling evidence, the 2018 reports sparked controversy. Some questioned whether the art could indicate an earlier arrival of Homo sapiens in Europe, despite dating evidence favoring Neanderthals. Counterarguments included potential dating errors or misattribution, with experts debating whether the 64,000-year-old cave art truly proves Neanderthal innovation or reflects unknown migrations. However, subsequent analyses in 2025 reaffirmed Neanderthal creation through refined rock sampling.
Future Research Directions
Looking forward, researchers propose expanded uranium-thorium testing on additional carbonate layers to determine if the images exceed 64,000 years, potentially altering timelines further. Interdisciplinary studies combining genetics, AI image analysis, and ethnography are suggested to interpret the motifs’ meanings in Neanderthal society. Additionally, planned excavations in other European sites, like Ardales and Maltravieso caves, aim to seek comparable Neanderthal art and build a continental picture of their artistic capabilities.
More from MorningOverview